Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 20, 2026

4840 Colonial Avenue

Jacksonville, FL 32210
$150,000
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,225 sq ft · built 1941
Active211 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
4840 Colonial Avenue
Bottom line

This home is asking $122 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $179 per square foot (30 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $178 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 11 new competing listings, 11 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 8 price cuts

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)Tap any dot to open that home

Price vs. size

$100K$200K$300K$400K7501,0001,2501,5001,750Living area (sq ft)5044 Colonial Avenue · $250,000 · 1,366 sq ft · sold Apr 28, 2026 · sold in 152 days5044 Sunderland Road · $165,000 · 996 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 2026 · sold in 113 days2211 Bayview Road · $125,000 · 1,269 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 7 days2223 Bayview Road · $311,000 · 1,603 sq ft · sold Aug 3, 2026 · sold in 41 days5128 Sunderland Road · $223,000 · 1,050 sq ft · sold Jun 9, 2026 · sold in 174 days4737 Manchester Road · $165,000 · 1,136 sq ft · sold Jul 22, 2026 · sold in 19 days5143 Palmer Avenue · $175,000 · 1,274 sq ft · sold Aug 31, 20264615 Sunderland Road · $219,000 · 1,222 sq ft · sold May 21, 2026 · sold in 15 days5051 Lexington Avenue · $140,000 · 786 sq ft · sold Jul 21, 2026 · sold in 37 days4626 Birkenhead Road · $250,000 · 1,359 sq ft · sold Sep 11, 20264605 Appleton Avenue · $239,000 · 1,488 sq ft · sold Jun 30, 2026 · sold in 99 days4582 Appleton Avenue · $255,000 · 1,470 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026 · sold in 7 days4649 Cambridge Road · $235,000 · 1,118 sq ft · sold Jun 10, 2026 · sold in 97 days4609 Cambridge Road · $130,000 · 1,270 sq ft · sold May 21, 2026 · sold in 173 days4567 Palmer Avenue · $159,000 · 1,114 sq ft · sold May 19, 2026 · sold in 50 days4816 Riverdale Road · $285,000 · 1,707 sq ft · sold Jun 9, 2026 · sold in 9 days4520 Birkenhead Road · $170,000 · 1,324 sq ft · sold Aug 31, 20265338 Palmer Avenue · $245,000 · 1,220 sq ft · sold Aug 21, 20262618 Bayview Road · $200,000 · 1,116 sq ft · sold Jul 16, 2026 · sold in 26 days4511 Cambridge Road · $210,000 · 1,110 sq ft · sold Oct 9, 20262781 Hyde Park Road · $118,000 · 1,222 sq ft · sold Jul 27, 2026 · sold in 62 days4630 Merrimac Avenue · $92,650 · 920 sq ft · sold Oct 16, 20264582 Merrimac Avenue · $205,000 · 1,228 sq ft · sold Aug 28, 20264436 Melrose Avenue · $260,000 · 1,080 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 107 days4330 Shirley Avenue · $297,000 · 936 sq ft · sold Jul 10, 2026 · sold in 5 days2107 Euclid Street · $430,000 · 1,376 sq ft · sold Jun 2, 2026 · sold in 31 days1522 Murray Drive · $240,000 · 1,002 sq ft · sold Oct 15, 20261499 Stimson Street · $340,000 · 1,668 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 2026 · sold in 81 days4409 St Johns Avenue · $300,000 · 1,524 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 81 days4149 San Juan Avenue · $355,000 · 1,366 sq ft · sold May 27, 2026 · sold in 12 days4839 Appleton Avenue · $240,000 · 1,116 sq ft · active · 123 days on market5106 Appleton Avenue · $250,000 · 1,515 sq ft · active · 4 days on market5027 Blackburn Street · $235,000 · 1,205 sq ft · active · 39 days on market4774 Lexington Avenue · $201,000 · 1,261 sq ft · active · 59 days on market5133 Palmer Avenue · $254,900 · 1,372 sq ft · active · 17 days on market4612 Fremont Street · $179,900 · 962 sq ft · active · 176 days on market4762 Cambridge Road · $210,000 · 1,526 sq ft · active · 152 days on market4595 Colonial Avenue · $264,900 · 1,272 sq ft · active · 6 days on market5226 Palmer Avenue · $231,000 · 1,571 sq ft · active · 20 days on market4826 Riverdale Road · $183,000 · 1,110 sq ft · active · 233 days on market4609 Cambridge Road · $249,700 · 1,270 sq ft · active · 24 days on market5235 Lexington Avenue · $184,999 · 1,257 sq ft · active · 48 days on market4748 Beverly Circle · $219,000 · 1,442 sq ft · active · 42 days on market2320 Hamilton Street · $240,000 · 1,420 sq ft · active · 55 days on market5207 Janice Circle · $175,000 · 1,428 sq ft · active · 90 days on market5359 Lexington Avenue · $150,000 · 1,272 sq ft · active · 61 days on market2712 Cherrywood Road · $187,000 · 1,598 sq ft · active · 97 days on market2737 Cherrywood Road · $265,000 · 1,584 sq ft · active · 36 days on market4822 Merrimac Avenue · $200,000 · 1,122 sq ft · active · 18 days on market4432 Marquette Avenue · $335,000 · 996 sq ft · active · 67 days on market2352 Woodridge Road · $239,500 · 1,095 sq ft · active · 76 days on market4412 Marquette Avenue · $369,999 · 1,212 sq ft · active · 19 days on market3011 Lake Shore Boulevard · $219,200 · 1,125 sq ft · active · 99 days on market4629 Merrimac Avenue · $225,000 · 1,400 sq ft · active · 2 days on market4443 Melrose Avenue · $312,000 · 1,160 sq ft · active · 60 days on market1574 Hamilton Street · $199,900 · 1,475 sq ft · active · 96 days on market3639 Rendale Drive · $195,000 · 1,512 sq ft · active · 43 days on market5239 Glenwood Avenue · $225,000 · 1,260 sq ft · active · 90 days on market5462 Park Street · $199,900 · 973 sq ft · active · 21 days on market6360 Kimberly Lane · $263,904 · 1,209 sq ft · active · 18 days on marketThis home · $150,000 · 1,225 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$0$100$200$300Sold (6 mo) (30)5044 Colonial Avenue · $183/sq ft · $250,0005044 Sunderland Road · $166/sq ft · $165,0002211 Bayview Road · $99/sq ft · $125,0002223 Bayview Road · $194/sq ft · $311,0005128 Sunderland Road · $212/sq ft · $223,0004737 Manchester Road · $145/sq ft · $165,0005143 Palmer Avenue · $137/sq ft · $175,0004615 Sunderland Road · $179/sq ft · $219,0005051 Lexington Avenue · $178/sq ft · $140,0004626 Birkenhead Road · $184/sq ft · $250,0004605 Appleton Avenue · $161/sq ft · $239,0004582 Appleton Avenue · $173/sq ft · $255,0004649 Cambridge Road · $210/sq ft · $235,0004609 Cambridge Road · $102/sq ft · $130,0004567 Palmer Avenue · $143/sq ft · $159,0004816 Riverdale Road · $167/sq ft · $285,0004520 Birkenhead Road · $128/sq ft · $170,0005338 Palmer Avenue · $201/sq ft · $245,0002618 Bayview Road · $179/sq ft · $200,0004511 Cambridge Road · $189/sq ft · $210,0002781 Hyde Park Road · $97/sq ft · $118,0004630 Merrimac Avenue · $101/sq ft · $92,6504582 Merrimac Avenue · $167/sq ft · $205,0004436 Melrose Avenue · $241/sq ft · $260,0004330 Shirley Avenue · $317/sq ft · $297,0002107 Euclid Street · $312/sq ft · $430,0001522 Murray Drive · $240/sq ft · $240,0001499 Stimson Street · $204/sq ft · $340,0004409 St Johns Avenue · $197/sq ft · $300,0004149 San Juan Avenue · $260/sq ft · $355,000median $179/sq ftActive now (30)4839 Appleton Avenue · $215/sq ft · $240,0005106 Appleton Avenue · $165/sq ft · $250,0005027 Blackburn Street · $195/sq ft · $235,0004774 Lexington Avenue · $159/sq ft · $201,0005133 Palmer Avenue · $186/sq ft · $254,9004612 Fremont Street · $187/sq ft · $179,9004762 Cambridge Road · $138/sq ft · $210,0004595 Colonial Avenue · $208/sq ft · $264,9005226 Palmer Avenue · $147/sq ft · $231,0004826 Riverdale Road · $165/sq ft · $183,0004609 Cambridge Road · $197/sq ft · $249,7005235 Lexington Avenue · $147/sq ft · $184,9994748 Beverly Circle · $152/sq ft · $219,0002320 Hamilton Street · $169/sq ft · $240,0005207 Janice Circle · $123/sq ft · $175,0005359 Lexington Avenue · $118/sq ft · $150,0002712 Cherrywood Road · $117/sq ft · $187,0002737 Cherrywood Road · $167/sq ft · $265,0004822 Merrimac Avenue · $178/sq ft · $200,0004432 Marquette Avenue · $336/sq ft · $335,0002352 Woodridge Road · $219/sq ft · $239,5004412 Marquette Avenue · $305/sq ft · $369,9993011 Lake Shore Boulevard · $195/sq ft · $219,2004629 Merrimac Avenue · $161/sq ft · $225,0004443 Melrose Avenue · $269/sq ft · $312,0001574 Hamilton Street · $136/sq ft · $199,9003639 Rendale Drive · $129/sq ft · $195,0005239 Glenwood Avenue · $179/sq ft · $225,0005462 Park Street · $205/sq ft · $199,9006360 Kimberly Lane · $218/sq ft · $263,904median $178/sq ftThis home $122/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 30 homes, median $179 per sq ft; 4 priced below this home and 26 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $178 per sq ft; 2 priced below this home and 28 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
4839 Appleton AvenueActive123$240,0001,116$2150.1
5106 Appleton AvenueActive4$250,0001,515$1650.2
5027 Blackburn StreetActive39$235,0001,205$1950.2
4774 Lexington AvenueActive59$201,0001,261$1590.3
5133 Palmer AvenueActive17$254,9001,372$1860.3
4612 Fremont StreetActive176$179,900962$1870.3
4762 Cambridge RoadActive152$210,0001,526$1380.3
4595 Colonial AvenueActive6$264,9001,272$2080.3
5226 Palmer AvenueActive20$231,0001,571$1470.4
4826 Riverdale RoadActive233$183,0001,110$1650.4
4609 Cambridge RoadActive24$249,7001,270$1970.4
5235 Lexington AvenueActive48$184,9991,257$1470.4
4748 Beverly CircleActive42$219,0001,442$1520.5
2320 Hamilton StreetActive55$240,0001,420$1690.5
5207 Janice CircleActive90$175,0001,428$1230.5
5359 Lexington AvenueActive61$150,0001,272$1180.6
2712 Cherrywood RoadActive97$187,0001,598$1170.7
2737 Cherrywood RoadActive36$265,0001,584$1670.7
4822 Merrimac AvenueActive18$200,0001,122$1780.7
4432 Marquette AvenueActive67$335,000996$3360.7
2352 Woodridge RoadActive76$239,5001,095$2190.8
4412 Marquette AvenueActive19$369,9991,212$3050.8
3011 Lake Shore BoulevardActive99$219,2001,125$1950.8
4629 Merrimac AvenueActive2$225,0001,400$1610.8
4443 Melrose AvenueActive60$312,0001,160$2690.8
1574 Hamilton StreetActive96$199,9001,475$1360.9
3639 Rendale DriveActive43$195,0001,512$1290.9
5239 Glenwood AvenueActive90$225,0001,260$1791.0
5462 Park StreetActive21$199,900973$2051.1
6360 Kimberly LaneActive18$263,9041,209$2181.1
5044 Colonial AvenueSold Apr 28, 2026152$250,0001,366$1830.1
5044 Sunderland RoadSold Apr 24, 2026113$165,000996$1660.2
2211 Bayview RoadSold May 29, 20267$125,0001,269$990.2
2223 Bayview RoadSold Aug 3, 202641$311,0001,603$1940.3
5128 Sunderland RoadSold Jun 9, 2026174$223,0001,050$2120.3
4737 Manchester RoadSold Jul 22, 202619$165,0001,136$1450.3
5143 Palmer AvenueSold Aug 31, 2026—$175,0001,274$1370.3
4615 Sunderland RoadSold May 21, 202615$219,0001,222$1790.3
5051 Lexington AvenueSold Jul 21, 202637$140,000786$1780.3
4626 Birkenhead RoadSold Sep 11, 2026—$250,0001,359$1840.3
4605 Appleton AvenueSold Jun 30, 202699$239,0001,488$1610.3
4582 Appleton AvenueSold Jun 3, 20267$255,0001,470$1730.4
4649 Cambridge RoadSold Jun 10, 202697$235,0001,118$2100.4
4609 Cambridge RoadSold May 21, 2026173$130,0001,270$1020.4
4567 Palmer AvenueSold May 19, 202650$159,0001,114$1430.4
4816 Riverdale RoadSold Jun 9, 20269$285,0001,707$1670.4
4520 Birkenhead RoadSold Aug 31, 2026—$170,0001,324$1280.4
5338 Palmer AvenueSold Aug 21, 2026—$245,0001,220$2010.5
2618 Bayview RoadSold Jul 16, 202626$200,0001,116$1790.5
4511 Cambridge RoadSold Oct 9, 2026—$210,0001,110$1890.5
2781 Hyde Park RoadSold Jul 27, 202662$118,0001,222$970.6
4630 Merrimac AvenueSold Oct 16, 2026—$92,650920$1010.8
4582 Merrimac AvenueSold Aug 28, 2026—$205,0001,228$1670.8
4436 Melrose AvenueSold Jun 12, 2026107$260,0001,080$2410.8
4330 Shirley AvenueSold Jul 10, 20265$297,000936$3170.8
2107 Euclid StreetSold Jun 2, 202631$430,0001,376$3120.9
1522 Murray DriveSold Oct 15, 2026—$240,0001,002$2400.9
1499 Stimson StreetSold Apr 24, 202681$340,0001,668$2040.9
4409 St Johns AvenueSold May 29, 202681$300,0001,524$1970.9
4149 San Juan AvenueSold May 27, 202612$355,0001,366$2601.1

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap any dot: active homes open their listing, sold homes open their community guide. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

211days on market (MLS) · listed about Mar 23

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 20, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

5462 Park Street
2 bd · 1 ba · 973 sq ft · 1.1 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of DJ & LINDSEY REAL ESTATE
$199,900$205/sq ft
5351 Royce Avenue
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,040 sq ft · 1.3 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of EAGLES WORLD REALTY, INC
$199,999$192/sq ft
1166 Murray Drive
2 bd · 1 ba · 866 sq ft · 1.7 mi away · listed Oct 11, 2026 · 9 days on market · Courtesy of ROOT REALTY LLC
$209,900$242/sq ft
5549 Plymouth Street
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,147 sq ft · 1.8 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of UNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERY
$120,000$105/sq ft
4512 Ish Brant Road
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,218 sq ft · 1.9 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of IRON VALLEY REAL ESTATE NORTH FLORIDA
$179,000$147/sq ft
4179 Oriely Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,182 sq ft · 2.3 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of ENTERA REALTY LLC
$209,900$178/sq ft
3624 Myra Street
2 bd · 1 ba · 771 sq ft · 2.6 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of TRADITIONS REALTY LLC
$169,900$220/sq ft
4409 Melvin Circle
4 bd · 1.5 ba · 912 sq ft · 2.7 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of AGENTCHASE LLC
$174,900$192/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

5242 101st Street #2, Jacksonville
2 bd · 840 sq ft · closed Oct 19, 2026 · Ortega Farms
$155,000$185/sq ft
5304 Carder Street, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,185 sq ft · closed Oct 19, 2026 · Hillcrest guide →
$225,000$190/sq ft
4630 Merrimac Avenue, Jacksonville
2 bd · 920 sq ft · closed Oct 16, 2026 · St Johns Park guide →
$92,650$101/sq ft
6813 Sandperch Street, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,590 sq ft · closed Oct 16, 2026 · Wells Landing guide →
$313,000$197/sq ft
1522 Murray Drive, Jacksonville
2 bd · 1,002 sq ft · closed Oct 15, 2026 · Highland Park guide →
$240,000$240/sq ft
4037 Gilmore Street, Jacksonville
2 bd · 1,000 sq ft · closed Oct 9, 2026 · Murray Hill
$182,500$182/sq ft
5919 Sonora Drive, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,280 sq ft · closed Oct 9, 2026 · Oak Hill guide →
$195,000$152/sq ft
4759 Post Street, Jacksonville
2 bd · 1,050 sq ft · closed Oct 9, 2026 · Murray Hill Heights
$259,900$248/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Matthew BraddyMatthew Braddy lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (352) 363-0237Email mattbraddyrealtor@gmail.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in Jacksonville · Jacksonville housing market · Duval County homes for sale · All Momentum listings