Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Nov 11, 2026

1731 Horton Drive

Orange Park, FL 32073
$315,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,666 sq ft · built 1974
Active7 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Kady Andreoli
Listing agent · Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
1731 Horton Drive
Bottom line

This home is asking $189 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $183 per square foot (30 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $181 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 4 new competing listings, 8 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 7 price cuts, 1 came off the market

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, on the same side of the St. Johns River, in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%, all on the same side of the St. Johns River.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)Tap a dot to open that home's page (only homes with a page on our site open)

Price vs. size

$200K$300K$400K1,0001,5002,000Living area (sq ft)1740 Poplar Drive · $300,000 · 1,679 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 2 days470 Kevin Drive · $365,000 · 1,805 sq ft · sold Aug 24, 20261728 Alder Drive · $338,833 · 1,825 sq ft · sold Aug 18, 2026516 Kevin Drive · $314,900 · 1,844 sq ft · sold Oct 9, 20261485 N Dolphin Street · $260,000 · 1,947 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 2026200 Debarry Avenue · $309,000 · 1,699 sq ft · sold Sep 15, 20261310 Dolphin Street · $370,000 · 1,814 sq ft · sold Sep 25, 2026461 Kevin Drive · $315,000 · 1,830 sq ft · sold May 28, 2026 · sold in 73 days1661 Bartlett Avenue · $250,000 · 1,480 sq ft · sold Aug 14, 20261311 Elk · $350,000 · 1,908 sq ft · sold Nov 4, 20261736 Papaya Drive · $340,000 · 1,651 sq ft · sold Jul 3, 2026 · sold in 12 days1042 Grove Park Lane · $399,900 · 1,780 sq ft · sold Sep 21, 20261810 Olive Court · $374,000 · 1,671 sq ft · sold Jun 17, 2026 · sold in 14 days1339 Grove Park Drive · $376,000 · 2,222 sq ft · sold Sep 9, 2026962 Grove Park Drive · $339,000 · 2,232 sq ft · sold Nov 2, 20261683 Patricia Lane · $242,000 · 1,264 sq ft · sold Oct 1, 2026398 Toccoa Road · $218,000 · 1,040 sq ft · sold Sep 21, 2026472 Sigsbee Road · $245,000 · 1,380 sq ft · sold Jul 20, 2026 · sold in 43 days465 Sigsbee Court · $249,900 · 1,082 sq ft · sold Sep 18, 20261720 Bay Circle · $216,000 · 1,728 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 2026 · sold in 92 days479 Alsey Drive · $180,020 · 1,390 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 2026 · sold in 6 days1474 Betty Court · $325,000 · 1,644 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 59 days1445 Marcia Drive · $390,000 · 1,697 sq ft · sold Jul 2, 2026 · sold in 41 days586 Madeira Drive · $260,000 · 1,315 sq ft · sold Nov 4, 2026552 S Clermont Avenue · $240,000 · 1,352 sq ft · sold Sep 11, 2026308 Bonnlyn Drive · $180,000 · 2,061 sq ft · sold May 26, 2026 · sold in 8 days1331 Crosby Lane · $351,350 · 1,741 sq ft · sold May 22, 2026 · sold in 64 days717 Winfred Drive · $355,000 · 1,716 sq ft · sold Jun 2, 2026 · sold in 11 days295 Blairmore Boulevard · $205,000 · 1,256 sq ft · sold May 28, 2026 · sold in 29 days295 Bonnlyn Drive · $230,000 · 1,392 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 2026 · sold in 34 days506 Kevin Drive · $355,000 · 1,898 sq ft · active · 62 days on market1858 Aba Drive · $330,000 · 1,823 sq ft · active · 25 days on market1757 Alder Drive · $365,490 · 1,970 sq ft · active · 65 days on market1114 Grove Park Drive · $349,990 · 1,480 sq ft · active · 26 days on market1527 St Francis Drive · $315,000 · 1,876 sq ft · active · 158 days on market1751 Gumtree Drive · $364,900 · 1,655 sq ft · active · 4 days on market1730 Gumtree Drive · $289,000 · 1,280 sq ft · active · 42 days on market1877 Aba Drive · $397,000 · 2,098 sq ft · active · 5 days on market1506 Freckles Court · $350,000 · 2,072 sq ft · active · 5 days on market1007 Grove Park Lane · $285,000 · 1,701 sq ft · active · 241 days on market1174 Gano · $299,900 · 1,664 sq ft · active · 1 days on market1741 Laura Ann Lane · $269,900 · 1,302 sq ft · active · 82 days on market1580 Beecher Lane · $297,500 · 1,821 sq ft · active · 47 days on market495 Alsey Drive · $199,000 · 1,248 sq ft · active · 40 days on market1706 Grove Park Drive · $257,500 · 1,440 sq ft · active · 96 days on market1701 Grove Park Drive · $239,900 · 1,116 sq ft · active · 218 days on market1720 Bay Circle · $379,900 · 1,728 sq ft · active · 101 days on market1563 Larhaz Court · $310,000 · 1,560 sq ft · active · 63 days on market370 Madeira Drive · $199,000 · 1,132 sq ft · active · 91 days on market1814 Grove Park Drive · $267,000 · 1,704 sq ft · active · 158 days on market250 Hilltop Drive · $139,500 · 1,100 sq ft · active · 11 days on market845 Floyd Circle · $205,000 · 1,248 sq ft · active · 121 days on market1847 Grove Park Drive · $280,000 · 1,384 sq ft · active · 82 days on market341 Parkwood Drive · $255,000 · 1,498 sq ft · active · 164 days on market336 Hilltop Drive · $145,000 · 1,312 sq ft · active · 7 days on market215 Hilltop Drive · $269,900 · 1,100 sq ft · active · 92 days on market549 Clermont Avenue · $239,000 · 1,352 sq ft · active · 50 days on market1746 Winfred Drive · $325,000 · 1,916 sq ft · active · 41 days on market1353 Crosby Lane · $349,000 · 1,853 sq ft · active · 5 days on market514 Valderia Drive · $245,000 · 1,001 sq ft · active · 26 days on marketThis home · $315,000 · 1,666 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$50$100$150$200$250Sold (6 mo) (30)1740 Poplar Drive · $179/sq ft · $300,000470 Kevin Drive · $202/sq ft · $365,0001728 Alder Drive · $186/sq ft · $338,833516 Kevin Drive · $171/sq ft · $314,9001485 N Dolphin Street · $134/sq ft · $260,000200 Debarry Avenue · $182/sq ft · $309,0001310 Dolphin Street · $204/sq ft · $370,000461 Kevin Drive · $172/sq ft · $315,0001661 Bartlett Avenue · $169/sq ft · $250,0001311 Elk · $183/sq ft · $350,0001736 Papaya Drive · $206/sq ft · $340,0001042 Grove Park Lane · $225/sq ft · $399,9001810 Olive Court · $224/sq ft · $374,0001339 Grove Park Drive · $169/sq ft · $376,000962 Grove Park Drive · $152/sq ft · $339,0001683 Patricia Lane · $191/sq ft · $242,000398 Toccoa Road · $210/sq ft · $218,000472 Sigsbee Road · $178/sq ft · $245,000465 Sigsbee Court · $231/sq ft · $249,9001720 Bay Circle · $125/sq ft · $216,000479 Alsey Drive · $130/sq ft · $180,0201474 Betty Court · $198/sq ft · $325,0001445 Marcia Drive · $230/sq ft · $390,000586 Madeira Drive · $198/sq ft · $260,000552 S Clermont Avenue · $178/sq ft · $240,000308 Bonnlyn Drive · $87/sq ft · $180,0001331 Crosby Lane · $202/sq ft · $351,350717 Winfred Drive · $207/sq ft · $355,000295 Blairmore Boulevard · $163/sq ft · $205,000295 Bonnlyn Drive · $165/sq ft · $230,000median $183/sq ftActive now (30)506 Kevin Drive · $187/sq ft · $355,0001858 Aba Drive · $181/sq ft · $330,0001757 Alder Drive · $186/sq ft · $365,4901114 Grove Park Drive · $236/sq ft · $349,9901527 St Francis Drive · $168/sq ft · $315,0001751 Gumtree Drive · $220/sq ft · $364,9001730 Gumtree Drive · $226/sq ft · $289,0001877 Aba Drive · $189/sq ft · $397,0001506 Freckles Court · $169/sq ft · $350,0001007 Grove Park Lane · $168/sq ft · $285,0001174 Gano · $180/sq ft · $299,9001741 Laura Ann Lane · $207/sq ft · $269,9001580 Beecher Lane · $163/sq ft · $297,500495 Alsey Drive · $159/sq ft · $199,0001706 Grove Park Drive · $179/sq ft · $257,5001701 Grove Park Drive · $215/sq ft · $239,9001720 Bay Circle · $220/sq ft · $379,9001563 Larhaz Court · $199/sq ft · $310,000370 Madeira Drive · $176/sq ft · $199,0001814 Grove Park Drive · $157/sq ft · $267,000250 Hilltop Drive · $127/sq ft · $139,500845 Floyd Circle · $164/sq ft · $205,0001847 Grove Park Drive · $202/sq ft · $280,000341 Parkwood Drive · $170/sq ft · $255,000336 Hilltop Drive · $111/sq ft · $145,000215 Hilltop Drive · $245/sq ft · $269,900549 Clermont Avenue · $177/sq ft · $239,0001746 Winfred Drive · $170/sq ft · $325,0001353 Crosby Lane · $188/sq ft · $349,000514 Valderia Drive · $245/sq ft · $245,000median $181/sq ftThis home $189/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 30 homes, median $183 per sq ft; 17 priced below this home and 13 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $181 per sq ft; 19 priced below this home and 11 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
506 Kevin DriveActive62$355,0001,898$1870.2
1858 Aba DriveActive25$330,0001,823$1810.2
1757 Alder DriveActive65$365,4901,970$1860.3
1114 Grove Park DriveActive26$349,9901,480$2360.3
1527 St Francis DriveActive158$315,0001,876$1680.3
1751 Gumtree DriveActive4$364,9001,655$2200.3
1730 Gumtree DriveActive42$289,0001,280$2260.4
1877 Aba DriveActive5$397,0002,098$1890.4
1506 Freckles CourtActive5$350,0002,072$1690.4
1007 Grove Park LaneActive241$285,0001,701$1680.5
1174 GanoActive1$299,9001,664$1800.5
1741 Laura Ann LaneActive82$269,9001,302$2070.6
1580 Beecher LaneActive47$297,5001,821$1630.6
495 Alsey DriveActive40$199,0001,248$1590.6
1706 Grove Park DriveActive96$257,5001,440$1790.6
1701 Grove Park DriveActive218$239,9001,116$2150.7
1720 Bay CircleActive101$379,9001,728$2200.7
1563 Larhaz CourtActive63$310,0001,560$1990.7
370 Madeira DriveActive91$199,0001,132$1760.7
1814 Grove Park DriveActive158$267,0001,704$1570.7
250 Hilltop DriveActive11$139,5001,100$1270.7
845 Floyd CircleActive121$205,0001,248$1640.8
1847 Grove Park DriveActive82$280,0001,384$2020.8
341 Parkwood DriveActive164$255,0001,498$1700.8
336 Hilltop DriveActive7$145,0001,312$1110.9
215 Hilltop DriveActive92$269,9001,100$2450.9
549 Clermont AvenueActive50$239,0001,352$1771.0
1746 Winfred DriveActive41$325,0001,916$1701.0
1353 Crosby LaneActive5$349,0001,853$1881.0
514 Valderia DriveActive26$245,0001,001$2451.0
1740 Poplar DriveSold May 29, 20262$300,0001,679$1790.0
470 Kevin DriveSold Aug 24, 2026—$365,0001,805$2020.2
1728 Alder DriveSold Aug 18, 2026—$338,8331,825$1860.2
516 Kevin DriveSold Oct 9, 2026—$314,9001,844$1710.3
1485 N Dolphin StreetSold Aug 27, 2026—$260,0001,947$1340.3
200 Debarry AvenueSold Sep 15, 2026—$309,0001,699$1820.3
1310 Dolphin StreetSold Sep 25, 2026—$370,0001,814$2040.3
461 Kevin DriveSold May 28, 202673$315,0001,830$1720.3
1661 Bartlett AvenueSold Aug 14, 2026—$250,0001,480$1690.3
1311 ElkSold Nov 4, 2026—$350,0001,908$1830.4
1736 Papaya DriveSold Jul 3, 202612$340,0001,651$2060.4
1042 Grove Park LaneSold Sep 21, 2026—$399,9001,780$2250.4
1810 Olive CourtSold Jun 17, 202614$374,0001,671$2240.4
1339 Grove Park DriveSold Sep 9, 2026—$376,0002,222$1690.5
962 Grove Park DriveSold Nov 2, 2026—$339,0002,232$1520.5
1683 Patricia LaneSold Oct 1, 2026—$242,0001,264$1910.5
398 Toccoa RoadSold Sep 21, 2026—$218,0001,040$2100.5
472 Sigsbee RoadSold Jul 20, 202643$245,0001,380$1780.5
465 Sigsbee CourtSold Sep 18, 2026—$249,9001,082$2310.6
1720 Bay CircleSold Jul 7, 202692$216,0001,728$1250.7
479 Alsey DriveSold Jun 1, 20266$180,0201,390$1300.7
1474 Betty CourtSold Jun 12, 202659$325,0001,644$1980.9
1445 Marcia DriveSold Jul 2, 202641$390,0001,697$2300.9
586 Madeira DriveSold Nov 4, 2026—$260,0001,315$1980.9
552 S Clermont AvenueSold Sep 11, 2026—$240,0001,352$1780.9
308 Bonnlyn DriveSold May 26, 20268$180,0002,061$871.0
1331 Crosby LaneSold May 22, 202664$351,3501,741$2021.0
717 Winfred DriveSold Jun 2, 202611$355,0001,716$2071.0
295 Blairmore BoulevardSold May 28, 202629$205,0001,256$1631.0
295 Bonnlyn DriveSold Jun 1, 202634$230,0001,392$1651.1

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap a dot to open that home's own page on our site (its listing, or its sold or off-market page); homes without a page here are not linked. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

7days on market (MLS) · listed about Nov 4

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Nov 11, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles on the same side of the St. Johns River in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

1751 Gumtree Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,655 sq ft · 0.3 mi away · listed Nov 5, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of LA ROSA REALTY NORTH FLORIDA, LLC.
$364,900$220/sq ft
1506 Freckles Court
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,072 sq ft · 0.4 mi away · listed Nov 8, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of ASSIST2SELL FULL SERVICE REALTY LLC.
$350,000$169/sq ft
1174 Gano
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,664 sq ft · 0.5 mi away · listed Nov 10, 2026 · 1 day on market · Courtesy of BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC
$299,900$180/sq ft
1424 Dog Fennel Court
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,399 sq ft · 0.5 mi away · listed Nov 2, 2026 · 9 days on market
$280,000$200/sq ft
1439 Beecher Lane
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,314 sq ft · 0.8 mi away · listed Nov 5, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC
$275,000$209/sq ft
1353 Crosby Lane
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,853 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Nov 7, 2026 · 4 days on market · Courtesy of ISLAND REALTY, INC.
$349,000$188/sq ft
1957 Birch Run
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sq ft · 1.2 mi away · listed Oct 31, 2026 · 11 days on market · Courtesy of THE PROPERTY EXPERTS REALTY & INVESTMENTS INC.
$250,000$213/sq ft
10 Virginia Court
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,892 sq ft · 1.4 mi away · listed Nov 8, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of 1 REALTY CORP
$257,000$136/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles on the same side of the St. Johns River in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

1000 Marbleridge Drive, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,707 sq ft · closed Nov 10, 2026 · Foxridge guide →
$244,600$143/sq ft
292 Mercury Drive, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,249 sq ft · closed Nov 6, 2026 · Orange Park guide →
$253,000$203/sq ft
586 Madeira Drive, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,315 sq ft · closed Nov 4, 2026 · Bellair
$260,000$198/sq ft
1311 Elk, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,908 sq ft · closed Nov 4, 2026 · Bellair
$350,000$183/sq ft
962 Grove Park Drive, Orange Park
5 bd · 2,232 sq ft · closed Nov 2, 2026 · Grove Park guide →
$339,000$152/sq ft
186 Foxridge Road, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,496 sq ft · closed Nov 2, 2026 · Foxridge guide →
$280,000$187/sq ft
1623 Highland View Court, Fleming Island
3 bd · 1,514 sq ft · closed Nov 2, 2026 · Eagle Harbor guide →
$375,000$248/sq ft
1975 Bluebird Run, Orange Park
3 bd · 1,324 sq ft · closed Oct 30, 2026 · Cedar Bend guide →
$250,000$189/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Kady AndreoliKady Andreoli lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 400-2131Email Kajaxbuyers@gmail.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in Orange Park · Orange Park housing market · Clay County homes for sale · All Momentum listings