Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Nov 17, 2026

274 Shinnecock Drive

St. Johns, FL 32259
$1,450,000
5 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,226 sq ft · built 2024
Active39 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
274 Shinnecock Drive
Bottom line

This home is asking $343 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $240 per square foot (20 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $244 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 12 new competing listings, 10 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 2 price cuts, 1 came off the market

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove), in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 20 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%, all in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove).

This home Active now (30) Sold (20)Tap a dot to open that home's page (only homes with a page on our site open)

Price vs. size

$500K$1.0M$1.5M2,5003,0003,5004,000Living area (sq ft)381 Shinnecock Drive · $1,010,000 · 3,008 sq ft · sold Aug 3, 2026 · sold in 72 days146 Woodbay Court · $1,040,000 · 4,274 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 2026 · sold in 75 days460 Shinnecock Drive · $915,000 · 3,258 sq ft · sold Sep 8, 2026265 Twin Flower Place · $775,000 · 2,744 sq ft · sold Jun 22, 2026 · sold in 70 days246 Twin Flower Place · $554,500 · 2,744 sq ft · sold Sep 30, 202662 Broadleaf Lane · $998,000 · 3,439 sq ft · sold Jun 15, 2026 · sold in 123 days99 Quailberry Place · $689,000 · 3,200 sq ft · sold Oct 27, 2026411 Footbridge Road · $750,000 · 3,217 sq ft · sold Sep 2, 2026353 Footbridge Road · $750,000 · 3,347 sq ft · sold Jun 11, 2026 · sold in 63 days58 Keeneland Road · $665,500 · 2,800 sq ft · sold Jul 8, 2026 · sold in 46 days177 Rawlings Drive · $675,000 · 2,844 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 18 days1637 Orange Branch Trail · $777,000 · 3,347 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 2026 · sold in 74 days192 Whirlaway Court · $1,059,000 · 4,206 sq ft · sold Oct 26, 2026165 High Brush Court · $1,000,000 · 3,436 sq ft · sold Jul 27, 2026 · sold in 56 days48 Riva Ridge Place · $610,000 · 3,161 sq ft · sold Jul 23, 2026 · sold in 50 days305 Sternwheel Drive · $730,000 · 3,148 sq ft · sold Nov 10, 202640 Thorton Court · $815,000 · 3,193 sq ft · sold Jul 31, 2026 · sold in 14 days550 Brambly Vine Drive · $726,000 · 3,289 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 7 days94 Black Horse Way · $932,569 · 3,022 sq ft · sold May 20, 2026 · sold in 0 days45 Big Sur Way · $623,847 · 2,603 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 23 days218 Shinnecock Drive · $1,025,000 · 2,851 sq ft · active · 18 days on market169 Shinnecock Drive · $1,150,000 · 4,226 sq ft · active · 12 days on market407 Shinnecock Drive · $899,000 · 3,000 sq ft · active · 81 days on market135 Shinnecock Drive · $1,100,000 · 3,850 sq ft · active · 4 days on market28 Woodbay Court · $1,075,000 · 3,239 sq ft · active · 61 days on market492 Shinnecock Drive · $1,200,000 · 4,064 sq ft · active · 116 days on market52 Terra Oaks Drive · $799,000 · 3,225 sq ft · active · 281 days on market106 Key Grass Court · $619,999 · 2,554 sq ft · active · 52 days on market1246 Orange Branch Trail · $599,000 · 2,664 sq ft · active · 93 days on market45 Gan Way · $558,000 · 2,660 sq ft · active · 169 days on market231 Silkgrass Place · $625,000 · 2,563 sq ft · active · 61 days on market140 Belmont Drive · $1,640,000 · 3,695 sq ft · active · 11 days on market173 Belmont Drive · $1,300,000 · 3,294 sq ft · active · 65 days on market82 Wards Ravine Way · $523,500 · 2,642 sq ft · active · 145 days on market99 Mission Drive · $689,000 · 2,664 sq ft · active · 4 days on market81 Tarklin Road · $560,000 · 2,539 sq ft · active · 45 days on market85 Beaufort Court · $704,958 · 2,799 sq ft · active · 34 days on market387 Adirondack Drive · $709,000 · 2,951 sq ft · active · 24 days on market59 Beaufort Court · $711,650 · 3,007 sq ft · active · 27 days on market407 Adirondack Drive · $682,000 · 2,890 sq ft · active · 3 days on market542 Adirondack Drive · $809,322 · 3,408 sq ft · active · 10 days on market390 Adirondack Drive · $744,000 · 3,408 sq ft · active · 24 days on market380 Adirondack Drive · $686,000 · 2,890 sq ft · active · 27 days on market313 Meadow Creek Drive · $626,500 · 2,797 sq ft · active · 58 days on market130 Sapelo Place · $600,000 · 2,654 sq ft · active · 9 days on market454 Rittburn Lane · $640,000 · 3,070 sq ft · active · 110 days on market329 Sapling Terrace · $1,064,000 · 3,534 sq ft · active · 59 days on market383 Sapling Terrace · $1,274,900 · 3,892 sq ft · active · 59 days on market415 Sapling Terrace · $899,000 · 3,214 sq ft · active · 159 days on market39 Molasses Court · $674,900 · 3,685 sq ft · active · 95 days on marketThis home · $1,450,000 · 4,226 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$200$300$400Sold (6 mo) (20)381 Shinnecock Drive · $336/sq ft · $1,010,000146 Woodbay Court · $243/sq ft · $1,040,000460 Shinnecock Drive · $281/sq ft · $915,000265 Twin Flower Place · $282/sq ft · $775,000246 Twin Flower Place · $202/sq ft · $554,50062 Broadleaf Lane · $290/sq ft · $998,00099 Quailberry Place · $215/sq ft · $689,000411 Footbridge Road · $233/sq ft · $750,000353 Footbridge Road · $224/sq ft · $750,00058 Keeneland Road · $238/sq ft · $665,500177 Rawlings Drive · $237/sq ft · $675,0001637 Orange Branch Trail · $232/sq ft · $777,000192 Whirlaway Court · $252/sq ft · $1,059,000165 High Brush Court · $291/sq ft · $1,000,00048 Riva Ridge Place · $193/sq ft · $610,000305 Sternwheel Drive · $232/sq ft · $730,00040 Thorton Court · $255/sq ft · $815,000550 Brambly Vine Drive · $221/sq ft · $726,00094 Black Horse Way · $309/sq ft · $932,56945 Big Sur Way · $240/sq ft · $623,847median $240/sq ftActive now (30)218 Shinnecock Drive · $360/sq ft · $1,025,000169 Shinnecock Drive · $272/sq ft · $1,150,000407 Shinnecock Drive · $300/sq ft · $899,000135 Shinnecock Drive · $286/sq ft · $1,100,00028 Woodbay Court · $332/sq ft · $1,075,000492 Shinnecock Drive · $295/sq ft · $1,200,00052 Terra Oaks Drive · $248/sq ft · $799,000106 Key Grass Court · $243/sq ft · $619,9991246 Orange Branch Trail · $225/sq ft · $599,00045 Gan Way · $210/sq ft · $558,000231 Silkgrass Place · $244/sq ft · $625,000140 Belmont Drive · $444/sq ft · $1,640,000173 Belmont Drive · $395/sq ft · $1,300,00082 Wards Ravine Way · $198/sq ft · $523,50099 Mission Drive · $259/sq ft · $689,00081 Tarklin Road · $221/sq ft · $560,00085 Beaufort Court · $252/sq ft · $704,958387 Adirondack Drive · $240/sq ft · $709,00059 Beaufort Court · $237/sq ft · $711,650407 Adirondack Drive · $236/sq ft · $682,000542 Adirondack Drive · $237/sq ft · $809,322390 Adirondack Drive · $218/sq ft · $744,000380 Adirondack Drive · $237/sq ft · $686,000313 Meadow Creek Drive · $224/sq ft · $626,500130 Sapelo Place · $226/sq ft · $600,000454 Rittburn Lane · $208/sq ft · $640,000329 Sapling Terrace · $301/sq ft · $1,064,000383 Sapling Terrace · $328/sq ft · $1,274,900415 Sapling Terrace · $280/sq ft · $899,00039 Molasses Court · $183/sq ft · $674,900median $244/sq ftThis home $343/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 20 homes, median $240 per sq ft; 20 priced below this home and 0 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $244 per sq ft; 27 priced below this home and 3 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
218 Shinnecock DriveActive18$1,025,0002,851$3600.0
169 Shinnecock DriveActive12$1,150,0004,226$2720.1
407 Shinnecock DriveActive81$899,0003,000$3000.1
135 Shinnecock DriveActive4$1,100,0003,850$2860.1
28 Woodbay CourtActive61$1,075,0003,239$3320.1
492 Shinnecock DriveActive116$1,200,0004,064$2950.2
52 Terra Oaks DriveActive281$799,0003,225$2480.3
106 Key Grass CourtActive52$619,9992,554$2430.4
1246 Orange Branch TrailActive93$599,0002,664$2250.7
45 Gan WayActive169$558,0002,660$2101.1
231 Silkgrass PlaceActive61$625,0002,563$2441.1
140 Belmont DriveActive11$1,640,0003,695$4441.1
173 Belmont DriveActive65$1,300,0003,294$3951.1
82 Wards Ravine WayActive145$523,5002,642$1981.2
99 Mission DriveActive4$689,0002,664$2591.2
81 Tarklin RoadActive45$560,0002,539$2211.3
85 Beaufort CourtActive34$704,9582,799$2521.4
387 Adirondack DriveActive24$709,0002,951$2401.4
59 Beaufort CourtActive27$711,6503,007$2371.4
407 Adirondack DriveActive3$682,0002,890$2361.4
542 Adirondack DriveActive10$809,3223,408$2371.5
390 Adirondack DriveActive24$744,0003,408$2181.5
380 Adirondack DriveActive27$686,0002,890$2371.5
313 Meadow Creek DriveActive58$626,5002,797$2241.5
130 Sapelo PlaceActive9$600,0002,654$2261.6
454 Rittburn LaneActive110$640,0003,070$2081.7
329 Sapling TerraceActive59$1,064,0003,534$3011.7
383 Sapling TerraceActive59$1,274,9003,892$3281.7
415 Sapling TerraceActive159$899,0003,214$2801.7
39 Molasses CourtActive95$674,9003,685$1831.8
381 Shinnecock DriveSold Aug 3, 202672$1,010,0003,008$3360.1
146 Woodbay CourtSold Jun 1, 202675$1,040,0004,274$2430.1
460 Shinnecock DriveSold Sep 8, 2026—$915,0003,258$2810.1
265 Twin Flower PlaceSold Jun 22, 202670$775,0002,744$2820.4
246 Twin Flower PlaceSold Sep 30, 2026—$554,5002,744$2020.5
62 Broadleaf LaneSold Jun 15, 2026123$998,0003,439$2900.5
99 Quailberry PlaceSold Oct 27, 2026—$689,0003,200$2150.5
411 Footbridge RoadSold Sep 2, 2026—$750,0003,217$2330.6
353 Footbridge RoadSold Jun 11, 202663$750,0003,347$2240.6
58 Keeneland RoadSold Jul 8, 202646$665,5002,800$2380.9
177 Rawlings DriveSold Jun 12, 202618$675,0002,844$2370.9
1637 Orange Branch TrailSold Jul 7, 202674$777,0003,347$2321.0
192 Whirlaway CourtSold Oct 26, 2026—$1,059,0004,206$2521.1
165 High Brush CourtSold Jul 27, 202656$1,000,0003,436$2911.2
48 Riva Ridge PlaceSold Jul 23, 202650$610,0003,161$1931.3
305 Sternwheel DriveSold Nov 10, 2026—$730,0003,148$2321.4
40 Thorton CourtSold Jul 31, 202614$815,0003,193$2552.1
550 Brambly Vine DriveSold May 29, 20267$726,0003,289$2212.2
94 Black Horse WaySold May 20, 20260$932,5693,022$3092.8
45 Big Sur WaySold May 29, 202623$623,8472,603$2402.9

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap a dot to open that home's own page on our site (its listing, or its sold or off-market page); homes without a page here are not linked. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

39days on market (MLS) · listed about Oct 9

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Nov 16, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove) in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

407 Shinnecock Drive
5 bd · 3 ba · 3,000 sq ft · 0.1 mi away · listed Nov 11, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
$899,000$300/sq ft
135 Shinnecock Drive
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,850 sq ft · 0.1 mi away · listed Nov 13, 2026 · 4 days on market · Courtesy of REAL BROKER LLC
$1,100,000$286/sq ft
492 Shinnecock Drive
6 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,064 sq ft · 0.2 mi away · listed Nov 11, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC
$1,200,000$295/sq ft
329 Sapling Ter
5 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,534 sq ft · 1.7 mi away · listed Nov 16, 2026 · 1 day on market · Courtesy of BLACKSTONE REAL ESTATE
$1,064,000$301/sq ft
237 Fells Cove
4 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,724 sq ft · 1.7 mi away · listed Nov 11, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of US REALTY HUB
$1,575,000$423/sq ft
26 Hillendale Circle
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,320 sq ft · 2.2 mi away · listed Nov 13, 2026 · 4 days on market · Courtesy of RE/MAX SPECIALISTS
$899,000$271/sq ft
173 Julep Place
5 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,461 sq ft · 2.7 mi away · listed Nov 11, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of MATTAMY REAL ESTATE SERVICES
$1,114,762$250/sq ft
179 Julep Place
5 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,374 sq ft · 2.7 mi away · listed Nov 11, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of MATTAMY REAL ESTATE SERVICES
$1,184,206$271/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove) in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

305 Sternwheel Drive, St. Johns
5 bd · 3,148 sq ft · closed Nov 10, 2026 · Rivertown guide →
$730,000$232/sq ft
215 Freshwater Drive, St. Johns
3 bd · 2,695 sq ft · closed Nov 10, 2026 · Julington Lakes guide →
$835,000$310/sq ft
99 Quailberry Place, St. Johns
5 bd · 3,200 sq ft · closed Oct 27, 2026 · Rivertown guide →
$689,000$215/sq ft
192 Whirlaway Court, St. Johns
5 bd · 4,206 sq ft · closed Oct 26, 2026 · Rivertown guide →
$1,059,000$252/sq ft
212 Twining Trce, St. Johns
5 bd · 2,996 sq ft · closed Oct 23, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan guide →
$765,000$255/sq ft
681 Grampian Highlands Drive, St. Johns
5 bd · 2,774 sq ft · closed Oct 14, 2026 · Aberdeen guide →
$559,499$202/sq ft
280 Queen Victoria Avenue, St. Johns
5 bd · 3,544 sq ft · closed Oct 2, 2026 · Aberdeen guide →
$600,000$169/sq ft
1768 Greenridge Circle, St. Johns
5 bd · 2,560 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Greenridge guide →
$550,000$215/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Heather StrazinskyHeather Strazinsky lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 598-4656Email heather@teamheatheranddanielle.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in St. Johns · St. Johns housing market · St. Johns County homes for sale · All Momentum listings