Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 20, 2026

5012 Clayton Court

St. Augustine, FL 32092
$549,900
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,225 sq ft · built 2007
Active63 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Alexis Short
Listing agent · Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
5012 Clayton Court
Bottom line

This home is asking $247 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $217 per square foot (30 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $205 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 8 new competing listings, 9 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 8 price cuts

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)Tap any dot to open that home

Price vs. size

$400K$600K$800K$1.0M$1.2M1,5002,0002,5003,000Living area (sq ft)5021 Clayton Court · $742,500 · 3,051 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 2026 · sold in 77 days4640 Tuscan Wood Court · $525,000 · 3,001 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 287 days2864 Oakgrove Avenue · $1,180,000 · 3,028 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026 · sold in 3 days2844 Oakgrove Avenue · $1,040,000 · 2,988 sq ft · sold Jun 22, 2026 · sold in 159 days4208 S Franklinia Street · $708,000 · 2,781 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 2026 · sold in 131 days4232 S Franklinia Street · $629,900 · 2,823 sq ft · sold Aug 25, 20263737 Berenstain Drive · $648,000 · 2,451 sq ft · sold May 26, 2026 · sold in 46 days237 Cedarstone Way · $675,000 · 2,798 sq ft · sold Aug 10, 2026 · sold in 56 days2781 Oakgrove Avenue · $630,000 · 2,767 sq ft · sold Oct 16, 202636 Sunberry Way · $599,000 · 2,796 sq ft · sold Apr 28, 2026 · sold in 133 days136 Providence Drive · $620,900 · 2,566 sq ft · sold Jun 26, 2026 · sold in 8 days49 Sunberry Way · $520,000 · 2,055 sq ft · sold Apr 23, 2026 · sold in 33 days107 Providence Drive · $520,000 · 2,325 sq ft · sold Sep 9, 20265187 Farm Creek Road · $875,000 · 1,776 sq ft · sold Jul 27, 2026 · sold in 37 days62 Alderwood Place · $425,000 · 2,066 sq ft · sold Oct 1, 202635 Pepperpike Way · $445,000 · 2,049 sq ft · sold Aug 3, 2026 · sold in 14 days23 Pepperpike Way · $435,000 · 2,066 sq ft · sold Aug 6, 2026 · sold in 47 days144 Alderwood Place · $436,000 · 2,066 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 2026103 Ferndale Way · $468,000 · 2,498 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026 · sold in 68 days98 Ferndale Way · $410,000 · 1,893 sq ft · sold Sep 23, 2026308 Ferndale Way · $437,900 · 2,500 sq ft · sold Apr 21, 2026 · sold in 37 days105 Bloomfield Way · $474,900 · 2,270 sq ft · sold Oct 2, 2026182 Foxcross Avenue · $445,000 · 2,341 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026 · sold in 21 days213 Foxcross Avenue · $450,000 · 2,362 sq ft · sold Jun 24, 2026 · sold in 34 days92 Patina Place · $439,000 · 2,345 sq ft · sold Sep 4, 2026169 Clarys Run · $390,000 · 1,957 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 2026 · sold in 231 days77 Foxcross Avenue · $410,000 · 2,165 sq ft · sold May 14, 2026 · sold in 5 days41 Seasons Court · $380,000 · 1,811 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 15 days192 Goldenrod Drive · $590,000 · 2,367 sq ft · sold Oct 1, 20263541 Pacetti Road · $570,000 · 1,820 sq ft · sold May 19, 2026 · sold in 173 days4644 Tuscan Wood Court · $575,000 · 2,802 sq ft · active · 102 days on market2513 Swallowtail Lane · $505,368 · 2,640 sq ft · active · 22 days on market3500 Joe Ashton Road · $950,000 · 2,000 sq ft · active · 18 days on market723 Mandarin Terrace · $395,000 · 1,897 sq ft · active · 19 days on market785 Back Creek Drive · $949,900 · 2,936 sq ft · active · 90 days on market2447 Woodstork Court · $570,000 · 2,645 sq ft · active · 55 days on market116 Providence Drive · $520,000 · 2,383 sq ft · active · 11 days on market71 Cedarstone Way · $590,000 · 2,893 sq ft · active · 39 days on market1314 Ardmore Street · $455,000 · 1,853 sq ft · active · 200 days on market52 Providence Drive · $469,000 · 2,383 sq ft · active · 11 days on market617 Birchbark Trail · $348,000 · 1,979 sq ft · active · 134 days on market257 Pepperpike Way · $368,500 · 2,039 sq ft · active · 20 days on market1341 River City Street · $450,900 · 3,045 sq ft · active · 26 days on market214 Pepperpike Way · $435,000 · 2,049 sq ft · active · 34 days on market1725 Windover Place · $435,000 · 2,281 sq ft · active · 138 days on market1704 Windover Place · $414,000 · 2,147 sq ft · active · 56 days on market54 Pepperpike Way · $398,000 · 2,077 sq ft · active · 512 days on market1208 Springhealth Court · $484,900 · 2,327 sq ft · active · 32 days on market405 Mackenzie Circle · $335,000 · 1,425 sq ft · active · 59 days on market141 Linsbury Court · $515,000 · 2,444 sq ft · active · 14 days on market324 Ferndale Way · $499,000 · 2,498 sq ft · active · 31 days on market210 Wineberry Lane · $404,990 · 2,048 sq ft · active · 123 days on market624 Weathered Edge Drive · $429,000 · 2,126 sq ft · active · 8 days on market273 Wineberry Lane · $379,900 · 2,035 sq ft · active · 51 days on market400 Weathered Edge Drive · $464,900 · 2,498 sq ft · active · 187 days on market1700 E Cobblestone Lane · $599,900 · 2,765 sq ft · active · 151 days on market216 Goldenrod Drive · $579,900 · 2,454 sq ft · active · 1 days on market80 White Rabbit Run · $423,000 · 2,027 sq ft · active · 13 days on market509 Knolle Court · $445,000 · 2,529 sq ft · active · 96 days on market352 Rustic Mill Drive · $583,900 · 2,428 sq ft · active · 67 days on marketThis home · $549,900 · 2,225 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$200$300$400$500Sold (6 mo) (30)5021 Clayton Court · $243/sq ft · $742,5004640 Tuscan Wood Court · $175/sq ft · $525,0002864 Oakgrove Avenue · $390/sq ft · $1,180,0002844 Oakgrove Avenue · $348/sq ft · $1,040,0004208 S Franklinia Street · $255/sq ft · $708,0004232 S Franklinia Street · $223/sq ft · $629,9003737 Berenstain Drive · $264/sq ft · $648,000237 Cedarstone Way · $241/sq ft · $675,0002781 Oakgrove Avenue · $228/sq ft · $630,00036 Sunberry Way · $214/sq ft · $599,000136 Providence Drive · $242/sq ft · $620,90049 Sunberry Way · $253/sq ft · $520,000107 Providence Drive · $224/sq ft · $520,0005187 Farm Creek Road · $493/sq ft · $875,00062 Alderwood Place · $206/sq ft · $425,00035 Pepperpike Way · $217/sq ft · $445,00023 Pepperpike Way · $211/sq ft · $435,000144 Alderwood Place · $211/sq ft · $436,000103 Ferndale Way · $187/sq ft · $468,00098 Ferndale Way · $217/sq ft · $410,000308 Ferndale Way · $175/sq ft · $437,900105 Bloomfield Way · $209/sq ft · $474,900182 Foxcross Avenue · $190/sq ft · $445,000213 Foxcross Avenue · $191/sq ft · $450,00092 Patina Place · $187/sq ft · $439,000169 Clarys Run · $199/sq ft · $390,00077 Foxcross Avenue · $189/sq ft · $410,00041 Seasons Court · $210/sq ft · $380,000192 Goldenrod Drive · $249/sq ft · $590,0003541 Pacetti Road · $313/sq ft · $570,000median $217/sq ftActive now (30)4644 Tuscan Wood Court · $205/sq ft · $575,0002513 Swallowtail Lane · $191/sq ft · $505,3683500 Joe Ashton Road · $475/sq ft · $950,000723 Mandarin Terrace · $208/sq ft · $395,000785 Back Creek Drive · $324/sq ft · $949,9002447 Woodstork Court · $216/sq ft · $570,000116 Providence Drive · $218/sq ft · $520,00071 Cedarstone Way · $204/sq ft · $590,0001314 Ardmore Street · $246/sq ft · $455,00052 Providence Drive · $197/sq ft · $469,000617 Birchbark Trail · $176/sq ft · $348,000257 Pepperpike Way · $181/sq ft · $368,5001341 River City Street · $148/sq ft · $450,900214 Pepperpike Way · $212/sq ft · $435,0001725 Windover Place · $191/sq ft · $435,0001704 Windover Place · $193/sq ft · $414,00054 Pepperpike Way · $192/sq ft · $398,0001208 Springhealth Court · $208/sq ft · $484,900405 Mackenzie Circle · $235/sq ft · $335,000141 Linsbury Court · $211/sq ft · $515,000324 Ferndale Way · $200/sq ft · $499,000210 Wineberry Lane · $198/sq ft · $404,990624 Weathered Edge Drive · $202/sq ft · $429,000273 Wineberry Lane · $187/sq ft · $379,900400 Weathered Edge Drive · $186/sq ft · $464,9001700 E Cobblestone Lane · $217/sq ft · $599,900216 Goldenrod Drive · $236/sq ft · $579,90080 White Rabbit Run · $209/sq ft · $423,000509 Knolle Court · $176/sq ft · $445,000352 Rustic Mill Drive · $240/sq ft · $583,900median $205/sq ftThis home $247/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 30 homes, median $217 per sq ft; 22 priced below this home and 8 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $205 per sq ft; 28 priced below this home and 2 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
4644 Tuscan Wood CourtActive102$575,0002,802$2050.2
2513 Swallowtail LaneActive22$505,3682,640$1910.5
3500 Joe Ashton RoadActive18$950,0002,000$4750.6
723 Mandarin TerraceActive19$395,0001,897$2080.7
785 Back Creek DriveActive90$949,9002,936$3240.7
2447 Woodstork CourtActive55$570,0002,645$2160.7
116 Providence DriveActive11$520,0002,383$2180.9
71 Cedarstone WayActive39$590,0002,893$2041.0
1314 Ardmore StreetActive200$455,0001,853$2461.0
52 Providence DriveActive11$469,0002,383$1971.0
617 Birchbark TrailActive134$348,0001,979$1761.0
257 Pepperpike WayActive20$368,5002,039$1811.0
1341 River City StreetActive26$450,9003,045$1481.1
214 Pepperpike WayActive34$435,0002,049$2121.1
1725 Windover PlaceActive138$435,0002,281$1911.2
1704 Windover PlaceActive56$414,0002,147$1931.2
54 Pepperpike WayActive512$398,0002,077$1921.3
1208 Springhealth CourtActive32$484,9002,327$2081.3
405 Mackenzie CircleActive59$335,0001,425$2351.4
141 Linsbury CourtActive14$515,0002,444$2111.4
324 Ferndale WayActive31$499,0002,498$2001.4
210 Wineberry LaneActive123$404,9902,048$1981.5
624 Weathered Edge DriveActive8$429,0002,126$2021.5
273 Wineberry LaneActive51$379,9002,035$1871.6
400 Weathered Edge DriveActive187$464,9002,498$1861.6
1700 E Cobblestone LaneActive151$599,9002,765$2171.6
216 Goldenrod DriveActive1$579,9002,454$2361.8
80 White Rabbit RunActive13$423,0002,027$2091.9
509 Knolle CourtActive96$445,0002,529$1761.9
352 Rustic Mill DriveActive67$583,9002,428$2401.9
5021 Clayton CourtSold Jul 7, 202677$742,5003,051$2430.0
4640 Tuscan Wood CourtSold Jun 12, 2026287$525,0003,001$1750.2
2864 Oakgrove AvenueSold Jun 3, 20263$1,180,0003,028$3900.5
2844 Oakgrove AvenueSold Jun 22, 2026159$1,040,0002,988$3480.5
4208 S Franklinia StreetSold Jun 1, 2026131$708,0002,781$2550.6
4232 S Franklinia StreetSold Aug 25, 2026—$629,9002,823$2230.6
3737 Berenstain DriveSold May 26, 202646$648,0002,451$2640.8
237 Cedarstone WaySold Aug 10, 202656$675,0002,798$2410.8
2781 Oakgrove AvenueSold Oct 16, 2026—$630,0002,767$2280.8
36 Sunberry WaySold Apr 28, 2026133$599,0002,796$2140.9
136 Providence DriveSold Jun 26, 20268$620,9002,566$2420.9
49 Sunberry WaySold Apr 23, 202633$520,0002,055$2530.9
107 Providence DriveSold Sep 9, 2026—$520,0002,325$2240.9
5187 Farm Creek RoadSold Jul 27, 202637$875,0001,776$4931.1
62 Alderwood PlaceSold Oct 1, 2026—$425,0002,066$2061.2
35 Pepperpike WaySold Aug 3, 202614$445,0002,049$2171.3
23 Pepperpike WaySold Aug 6, 202647$435,0002,066$2111.3
144 Alderwood PlaceSold Aug 27, 2026—$436,0002,066$2111.3
103 Ferndale WaySold Jun 3, 202668$468,0002,498$1871.3
98 Ferndale WaySold Sep 23, 2026—$410,0001,893$2171.4
308 Ferndale WaySold Apr 21, 202637$437,9002,500$1751.4
105 Bloomfield WaySold Oct 2, 2026—$474,9002,270$2091.5
182 Foxcross AvenueSold Jun 3, 202621$445,0002,341$1901.6
213 Foxcross AvenueSold Jun 24, 202634$450,0002,362$1911.6
92 Patina PlaceSold Sep 4, 2026—$439,0002,345$1871.6
169 Clarys RunSold Apr 24, 2026231$390,0001,957$1991.6
77 Foxcross AvenueSold May 14, 20265$410,0002,165$1891.7
41 Seasons CourtSold Jun 12, 202615$380,0001,811$2101.8
192 Goldenrod DriveSold Oct 1, 2026—$590,0002,367$2491.8
3541 Pacetti RoadSold May 19, 2026173$570,0001,820$3131.8

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap any dot: active homes open their listing, sold homes open their community guide. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

63days on market (MLS) · listed about Aug 18
4Google Search views, 28 days
0clicks from Google, 28 days
6.2average Google position

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 20, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

116 Providence Drive
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,383 sq ft · 0.9 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of HALDEMAN REALTY & MANAGEMENT LLC
$520,000$218/sq ft
122 Leafmore Lane
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,367 sq ft · 1.4 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of 7 STAR REALTY, INC.
$350,000$148/sq ft
624 Weathered Edge Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,126 sq ft · 1.5 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS
$429,000$202/sq ft
273 Wineberry Lane
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,035 sq ft · 1.6 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of DUVAL REALTY OF JAX
$379,900$187/sq ft
174 Scarlet Rose Lane
5 bd · 4 ba · 2,894 sq ft · 1.6 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of REALTY ONE GROUP ELEVATE
$655,000$226/sq ft
1411 Barrington Circle
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,048 sq ft · 2.1 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of ENDLESS SUMMER REALTY
$600,000$293/sq ft
202 Bluegrass Way
4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,036 sq ft · 2.3 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of OLYMPUS EXECUTIVE REALTY, INC
$494,990$243/sq ft
31 Grassmere Court
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,622 sq ft · 2.3 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of OLYMPUS EXECUTIVE REALTY, INC
$349,990$216/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

2781 Oakgrove Avenue, St. Johns
3 bd · 2,767 sq ft · closed Oct 16, 2026 · Wgv King Andbear
$630,000$228/sq ft
268 Bedford Terrace, St. Augustine
3 bd · 2,183 sq ft · closed Oct 15, 2026 · Silverleaf guide →
$530,000$243/sq ft
106 Ancient Springs Lane, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,393 sq ft · closed Oct 14, 2026 · Silverleaf guide →
$549,000$229/sq ft
42 Ancient Springs Lane, St. Augustine
3 bd · 2,393 sq ft · closed Oct 13, 2026 · Silverleaf guide →
$493,930$206/sq ft
2080 Crown Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,626 sq ft · closed Oct 8, 2026 · Wgv King Andbear
$625,000$238/sq ft
94 Lone Cypress Way, St. Augustine
3 bd · 1,807 sq ft · closed Oct 2, 2026 · Summer Bay At Grand Oaks guide →
$475,000$263/sq ft
105 Bloomfield Way, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,270 sq ft · closed Oct 2, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$474,900$209/sq ft
62 Alderwood Place, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,066 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$425,000$206/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Alexis ShortAlexis Short lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 466-1447Email alexiscloseshomes@gmail.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in St. Augustine · St. Augustine housing market · St. Johns County homes for sale · All Momentum listings