Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 2, 2026

5012 Clayton Court

St. Augustine, FL 32092
$549,900
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,225 sq ft · built 2007
Active44 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty · Alexis Short
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
5012 Clayton Court
How it's doing

Performance

44days on market (MLS) · listed about Aug 19

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 2, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

2513 Swallowtail Lane
5 bd · 2 ba · 2,640 sq ft · 0.5 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of AXEN REALTY LLC
$505,368$191/sq ft
257 Pepperpike Way
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,039 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Oct 1, 2026 · Courtesy of DOCTORS LAKE REALTY
$368,500$181/sq ft
1341 River City Street
5 bd · 3 ba · 3,045 sq ft · 1.1 mi away · listed Sep 25, 2026 · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS ST JOHNS
$450,900$148/sq ft
210 Wineberry Lane
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,048 sq ft · 1.5 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of REAL BROKER LLC
$404,990$198/sq ft
221 Foxcross Avenue
4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,220 sq ft · 1.6 mi away · listed Sep 26, 2026 · Courtesy of REAL BROKER LLC
$450,000$203/sq ft
660 Goldenrod Drive
4 bd · 3 ba · 3,092 sq ft · 2.0 mi away · listed Sep 25, 2026 · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS ST. AUGUSTINE
$625,000$202/sq ft
710 Goldenrod Drive
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,400 sq ft · 2.0 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of PREMIER HOMES REALTY INC
$579,900$242/sq ft
216 Amberwood Drive
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,779 sq ft · 2.0 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of PREMIER HOMES REALTY INC
$495,000$278/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

192 Goldenrod Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,367 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$590,000$249/sq ft
744 Farmfield Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,500 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$515,000$206/sq ft
754 Farmfield Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,190 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$460,000$210/sq ft
760 Farmfield Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 1,968 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$425,000$216/sq ft
80 Lucia Place, St. Augustine
5 bd · 3,060 sq ft · closed Sep 29, 2026 · Silverleaf guide →
$673,395$220/sq ft
165 Bluegrass Way, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,503 sq ft · closed Sep 29, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$469,000$187/sq ft
708 Farmfield Drive, St. Augustine
4 bd · 2,190 sq ft · closed Sep 26, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$467,500$213/sq ft
530 Farmfield Drive, St. Augustine
3 bd · 1,622 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Trailmark guide →
$406,000$250/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold recently (within 3 mi). Same property type, living area within 40%. The subdivision-only comparison is under Pricing position below.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)

Price vs. size

$400K$600K$800K$1.0M$1.2M1,5002,0002,5003,000Living area (sq ft)5021 Clayton Court · $742,500 · 3,051 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 20264640 Tuscan Wood Court · $525,000 · 3,001 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 20262864 Oakgrove Avenue · $1,180,000 · 3,028 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 20262844 Oakgrove Avenue · $1,040,000 · 2,988 sq ft · sold Jun 22, 20264208 S Franklinia Street · $708,000 · 2,781 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 20264232 S Franklinia Street · $629,900 · 2,823 sq ft · sold Aug 25, 20263737 Berenstain Drive · $648,000 · 2,451 sq ft · sold May 26, 2026237 Cedarstone Way · $675,000 · 2,798 sq ft · sold Aug 10, 202636 Sunberry Way · $599,000 · 2,796 sq ft · sold Apr 28, 2026136 Providence Drive · $620,900 · 2,566 sq ft · sold Jun 26, 202649 Sunberry Way · $520,000 · 2,055 sq ft · sold Apr 23, 2026107 Providence Drive · $520,000 · 2,325 sq ft · sold Sep 9, 20265187 Farm Creek Road · $875,000 · 1,776 sq ft · sold Jul 27, 202635 Pepperpike Way · $445,000 · 2,049 sq ft · sold Aug 3, 202623 Pepperpike Way · $435,000 · 2,066 sq ft · sold Aug 6, 2026144 Alderwood Place · $436,000 · 2,066 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 2026103 Ferndale Way · $468,000 · 2,498 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026308 Ferndale Way · $437,900 · 2,500 sq ft · sold Apr 21, 2026182 Foxcross Avenue · $445,000 · 2,341 sq ft · sold Jun 3, 2026213 Foxcross Avenue · $450,000 · 2,362 sq ft · sold Jun 24, 202692 Patina Place · $439,000 · 2,345 sq ft · sold Sep 4, 2026169 Clarys Run · $390,000 · 1,957 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 202677 Foxcross Avenue · $410,000 · 2,165 sq ft · sold May 14, 202641 Seasons Court · $380,000 · 1,811 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026192 Goldenrod Drive · $590,000 · 2,367 sq ft · sold Oct 1, 20263541 Pacetti Road · $570,000 · 1,820 sq ft · sold May 19, 2026159 Weathered Edge Drive · $665,000 · 2,952 sq ft · sold Aug 31, 2026435 Goldenrod Drive · $605,000 · 3,070 sq ft · sold Apr 6, 202635 White Rabbit Run · $408,000 · 2,126 sq ft · sold Aug 13, 2026301 Field Flower Way · $509,000 · 2,642 sq ft · sold Jun 2, 20264644 Tuscan Wood Court · $575,000 · 2,802 sq ft · active2513 Swallowtail Lane · $505,368 · 2,640 sq ft · active3500 Joe Ashton Road · $950,000 · 2,000 sq ft · active723 Mandarin Terrace · $395,000 · 1,897 sq ft · active785 Back Creek Drive · $949,900 · 2,936 sq ft · active2447 Woodstork Court · $570,000 · 2,645 sq ft · active693 Mackenzie Circle · $279,000 · 1,823 sq ft · active71 Cedarstone Way · $590,000 · 2,893 sq ft · active1314 Ardmore Street · $455,000 · 1,853 sq ft · active617 Birchbark Trail · $356,000 · 1,979 sq ft · active257 Pepperpike Way · $368,500 · 2,039 sq ft · active1341 River City Street · $450,900 · 3,045 sq ft · active214 Pepperpike Way · $435,000 · 2,049 sq ft · active929 Indian River Road · $485,000 · 2,614 sq ft · active1725 Windover Place · $435,000 · 2,281 sq ft · active1704 Windover Place · $419,000 · 2,147 sq ft · active54 Pepperpike Way · $398,000 · 2,077 sq ft · active1208 Springhealth Court · $484,900 · 2,327 sq ft · active405 Mackenzie Circle · $345,000 · 1,425 sq ft · active324 Ferndale Way · $499,000 · 2,498 sq ft · active210 Wineberry Lane · $404,990 · 2,048 sq ft · active221 Foxcross Avenue · $450,000 · 2,220 sq ft · active400 Weathered Edge Drive · $469,900 · 2,498 sq ft · active1700 E Cobblestone Lane · $599,900 · 2,765 sq ft · active509 Knolle Court · $445,000 · 2,529 sq ft · active352 Rustic Mill Drive · $583,900 · 2,428 sq ft · active308 Rustic Mill Drive · $549,000 · 2,564 sq ft · active78 Farmfield Drive · $550,000 · 2,510 sq ft · active216 Amberwood Drive · $495,000 · 1,779 sq ft · active1552 Barrington Circle · $444,999 · 1,994 sq ft · activeThis home · $549,900 · 2,225 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$200$300$400$500Sold (6 mo) (30)$243/sq ft$175/sq ft$390/sq ft$348/sq ft$255/sq ft$223/sq ft$264/sq ft$241/sq ft$214/sq ft$242/sq ft$253/sq ft$224/sq ft$493/sq ft$217/sq ft$211/sq ft$211/sq ft$187/sq ft$175/sq ft$190/sq ft$191/sq ft$187/sq ft$199/sq ft$189/sq ft$210/sq ft$249/sq ft$313/sq ft$225/sq ft$197/sq ft$192/sq ft$193/sq ftmedian $217/sq ftActive now (30)$205/sq ft$191/sq ft$475/sq ft$208/sq ft$324/sq ft$216/sq ft$153/sq ft$204/sq ft$246/sq ft$180/sq ft$181/sq ft$148/sq ft$212/sq ft$186/sq ft$191/sq ft$195/sq ft$192/sq ft$208/sq ft$242/sq ft$200/sq ft$198/sq ft$203/sq ft$188/sq ft$217/sq ft$176/sq ft$240/sq ft$214/sq ft$219/sq ft$278/sq ft$223/sq ftmedian $205/sq ftThis home $247/sq ft

Priced at $247 per sq ft, higher than 22 of 30 recent sales (median $217).

Priced at $247 per sq ft, higher than 27 of 30 active competitors (median $205).

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
4644 Tuscan Wood CourtActive$575,0002,802$2050.2
2513 Swallowtail LaneActive$505,3682,640$1910.5
3500 Joe Ashton RoadActive$950,0002,000$4750.6
723 Mandarin TerraceActive$395,0001,897$2080.7
785 Back Creek DriveActive$949,9002,936$3240.7
2447 Woodstork CourtActive$570,0002,645$2160.7
693 Mackenzie CircleActive$279,0001,823$1530.9
71 Cedarstone WayActive$590,0002,893$2041.0
1314 Ardmore StreetActive$455,0001,853$2461.0
617 Birchbark TrailActive$356,0001,979$1801.0
257 Pepperpike WayActive$368,5002,039$1811.0
1341 River City StreetActive$450,9003,045$1481.1
214 Pepperpike WayActive$435,0002,049$2121.1
929 Indian River RoadActive$485,0002,614$1861.2
1725 Windover PlaceActive$435,0002,281$1911.2
1704 Windover PlaceActive$419,0002,147$1951.2
54 Pepperpike WayActive$398,0002,077$1921.3
1208 Springhealth CourtActive$484,9002,327$2081.3
405 Mackenzie CircleActive$345,0001,425$2421.4
324 Ferndale WayActive$499,0002,498$2001.4
210 Wineberry LaneActive$404,9902,048$1981.5
221 Foxcross AvenueActive$450,0002,220$2031.6
400 Weathered Edge DriveActive$469,9002,498$1881.6
1700 E Cobblestone LaneActive$599,9002,765$2171.6
509 Knolle CourtActive$445,0002,529$1761.9
352 Rustic Mill DriveActive$583,9002,428$2401.9
308 Rustic Mill DriveActive$549,0002,564$2141.9
78 Farmfield DriveActive$550,0002,510$2192.0
216 Amberwood DriveActive$495,0001,779$2782.0
1552 Barrington CircleActive$444,9991,994$2232.0
5021 Clayton CourtSold Jul 7, 2026$742,5003,051$2430.0
4640 Tuscan Wood CourtSold Jun 12, 2026$525,0003,001$1750.2
2864 Oakgrove AvenueSold Jun 3, 2026$1,180,0003,028$3900.5
2844 Oakgrove AvenueSold Jun 22, 2026$1,040,0002,988$3480.5
4208 S Franklinia StreetSold Jun 1, 2026$708,0002,781$2550.6
4232 S Franklinia StreetSold Aug 25, 2026$629,9002,823$2230.6
3737 Berenstain DriveSold May 26, 2026$648,0002,451$2640.8
237 Cedarstone WaySold Aug 10, 2026$675,0002,798$2410.8
36 Sunberry WaySold Apr 28, 2026$599,0002,796$2140.9
136 Providence DriveSold Jun 26, 2026$620,9002,566$2420.9
49 Sunberry WaySold Apr 23, 2026$520,0002,055$2530.9
107 Providence DriveSold Sep 9, 2026$520,0002,325$2240.9
5187 Farm Creek RoadSold Jul 27, 2026$875,0001,776$4931.1
35 Pepperpike WaySold Aug 3, 2026$445,0002,049$2171.3
23 Pepperpike WaySold Aug 6, 2026$435,0002,066$2111.3
144 Alderwood PlaceSold Aug 27, 2026$436,0002,066$2111.3
103 Ferndale WaySold Jun 3, 2026$468,0002,498$1871.3
308 Ferndale WaySold Apr 21, 2026$437,9002,500$1751.4
182 Foxcross AvenueSold Jun 3, 2026$445,0002,341$1901.6
213 Foxcross AvenueSold Jun 24, 2026$450,0002,362$1911.6
92 Patina PlaceSold Sep 4, 2026$439,0002,345$1871.6
169 Clarys RunSold Apr 24, 2026$390,0001,957$1991.6
77 Foxcross AvenueSold May 14, 2026$410,0002,165$1891.7
41 Seasons CourtSold Jun 12, 2026$380,0001,811$2101.8
192 Goldenrod DriveSold Oct 1, 2026$590,0002,367$2491.8
3541 Pacetti RoadSold May 19, 2026$570,0001,820$3131.8
159 Weathered Edge DriveSold Aug 31, 2026$665,0002,952$2251.8
435 Goldenrod DriveSold Apr 6, 2026$605,0003,070$1971.8
35 White Rabbit RunSold Aug 13, 2026$408,0002,126$1921.8
301 Field Flower WaySold Jun 2, 2026$509,0002,642$1931.9

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Hover or tap a dot for the address. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Pricing position

Price per square foot vs. comparable sales

$247this home, per sq ft
$255median of 6 comparable sales in Wgv King Andbear
3 of 6comparable sales priced below this home per sq ft

Comparable sales: same property type, living area within 30%, closed within 18 months, in Wgv King Andbear. Stronger local evidence. Context, not a valuation.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Alexis Short lists this home. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 351-6461
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in St. Augustine · St. Augustine housing market · St. Johns County homes for sale · All Momentum listings