Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 20, 2026

5166 Highland Avenue

Jacksonville, FL 32258
$450,000
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,654 sq ft · built 2027
Active33 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
5166 Highland Avenue
Bottom line

This home is asking $272 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $229 per square foot (30 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $233 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 10 new competing listings, 10 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 8 price cuts

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)Tap any dot to open that home

Price vs. size

$300K$400K$500K$600K1,5002,000Living area (sq ft)4956 Grand Lakes Drive · $435,000 · 2,103 sq ft · sold May 13, 2026 · sold in 3 days5327 Racoon Ridge Court · $350,000 · 1,551 sq ft · sold Sep 3, 202612311 Autumnbrook Trail · $270,000 · 1,939 sq ft · sold Jun 10, 2026 · sold in 12 days12283 Autumnbrook Trail · $385,000 · 1,940 sq ft · sold Sep 15, 20265472 Running Creek Lane · $380,000 · 1,940 sq ft · sold Oct 2, 20265489 Running Creek Lane · $375,000 · 1,939 sq ft · sold May 8, 2026 · sold in 6 days4477 Carolyn Cove Lane · $375,000 · 1,512 sq ft · sold Sep 2, 20264474 Carolyn Cove Lane · $359,900 · 1,402 sq ft · sold May 8, 2026 · sold in 13 days12280 Peach Orchard Drive · $605,900 · 2,306 sq ft · sold Aug 7, 2026 · sold in 3 days4134 Shetland Pony Lane · $332,000 · 1,708 sq ft · sold Jul 20, 2026 · sold in 2 days4134 Six Gun Court · $485,000 · 2,056 sq ft · sold Jul 22, 2026 · sold in 3 days12675 Filly Court · $455,000 · 1,938 sq ft · sold Sep 28, 202612607 Quarterhorse Trail · $445,000 · 2,068 sq ft · sold May 11, 2026 · sold in 15 days12527 Shady Creek Drive · $445,000 · 1,782 sq ft · sold Sep 14, 20264055 Waterway Court · $380,000 · 1,657 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 20264050 Waterway Court · $490,000 · 2,145 sq ft · sold May 8, 2026 · sold in 4 days11791 J Anthony Drive · $399,000 · 1,926 sq ft · sold May 13, 2026 · sold in 4 days4321 Pathwood Way · $265,000 · 1,390 sq ft · sold Sep 30, 20263752 Helicon Drive · $520,000 · 2,262 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 20263735 Helicon Drive · $520,000 · 2,046 sq ft · sold Jul 30, 2026 · sold in 5 days1405 W Chinaberry Court · $479,000 · 2,240 sq ft · sold May 8, 2026 · sold in 52 days11513 Dandelion Way · $370,000 · 1,468 sq ft · sold Jun 18, 2026 · sold in 16 days11654 Lake Ride Drive · $347,000 · 1,306 sq ft · sold May 7, 2026 · sold in 4 days11531 Knobby Way · $390,000 · 1,685 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 28 days11599 Lake Ride Drive · $255,000 · 1,248 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 2026 · sold in 74 days863 S Lilac Loop · $349,000 · 1,555 sq ft · sold May 5, 2026 · sold in 3 days11659 Mossy Way · $355,000 · 1,415 sq ft · sold May 27, 2026 · sold in 34 days11631 East Ride Drive · $320,000 · 1,524 sq ft · sold May 18, 2026 · sold in 70 days204 Elmwood Drive · $530,000 · 2,236 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 3 days825 S Lilac Loop · $420,750 · 1,727 sq ft · sold May 28, 2026 · sold in 9 days12737 Old St Augustine Road · $400,000 · 1,727 sq ft · active · 139 days on market5100 Courtland Oaks Street · $409,900 · 1,652 sq ft · active · 6 days on market5024 Courtland Oaks Street · $409,900 · 1,652 sq ft · active · 6 days on market5022 Azure Street · $330,000 · 1,097 sq ft · active · 12 days on market5015 Verdis Street · $345,000 · 1,355 sq ft · active · 11 days on market4941 Verdis Street · $419,900 · 1,815 sq ft · active · 64 days on market12283 Deeder Lane · $515,000 · 2,097 sq ft · active · 12 days on market4979 Tan Street · $295,000 · 1,230 sq ft · active · 26 days on market5048 Cerise Street · $315,000 · 1,087 sq ft · active · 19 days on market5182 Beige Street · $385,000 · 1,524 sq ft · active · 32 days on market5325 Lake Gardens Lane · $420,000 · 1,976 sq ft · active · 136 days on market4964 Lake Charles Drive · $450,000 · 2,243 sq ft · active · 20 days on market12614 Joda Lane · $495,000 · 1,676 sq ft · active · 32 days on market12643 Deeder Lane · $439,000 · 1,809 sq ft · active · 4 days on market5248 Tilting Oaks Court · $415,000 · 1,882 sq ft · active · 33 days on market12444 Agatite Road · $515,000 · 1,914 sq ft · active · 49 days on market5308 Julington Creek Road · $385,000 · 1,407 sq ft · active · 31 days on market5345 Julington Ridge Court · $325,000 · 1,518 sq ft · active · 4 days on market5405 Julington Creek Road · $369,000 · 2,034 sq ft · active · 104 days on market12048 Collins Creek Drive · $335,000 · 2,179 sq ft · active · 1 days on market5628 Crest Creek Drive · $455,000 · 2,268 sq ft · active · 88 days on market12844 Plummer Grant Road · $574,900 · 1,961 sq ft · active · 61 days on market12717 Allport Road · $332,000 · 1,884 sq ft · active · 243 days on market12798 Wilderness Lane · $325,000 · 1,492 sq ft · active · 4 days on market12790 Allport Road · $360,000 · 1,709 sq ft · active · 18 days on market12951 Julington Ridge Drive · $369,900 · 1,695 sq ft · active · 20 days on market11288 Southington Place · $349,900 · 1,501 sq ft · active · 21 days on market4120 Pony Express Lane · $475,000 · 1,893 sq ft · active · 68 days on market4887 Norwalk Place · $344,900 · 1,782 sq ft · active · 47 days on market4871 Northford Place · $375,000 · 1,832 sq ft · active · 4 days on marketThis home · $450,000 · 1,654 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$150$200$250$300Sold (6 mo) (30)4956 Grand Lakes Drive · $207/sq ft · $435,0005327 Racoon Ridge Court · $226/sq ft · $350,00012311 Autumnbrook Trail · $139/sq ft · $270,00012283 Autumnbrook Trail · $198/sq ft · $385,0005472 Running Creek Lane · $196/sq ft · $380,0005489 Running Creek Lane · $193/sq ft · $375,0004477 Carolyn Cove Lane · $248/sq ft · $375,0004474 Carolyn Cove Lane · $257/sq ft · $359,90012280 Peach Orchard Drive · $263/sq ft · $605,9004134 Shetland Pony Lane · $194/sq ft · $332,0004134 Six Gun Court · $236/sq ft · $485,00012675 Filly Court · $235/sq ft · $455,00012607 Quarterhorse Trail · $215/sq ft · $445,00012527 Shady Creek Drive · $250/sq ft · $445,0004055 Waterway Court · $229/sq ft · $380,0004050 Waterway Court · $228/sq ft · $490,00011791 J Anthony Drive · $207/sq ft · $399,0004321 Pathwood Way · $191/sq ft · $265,0003752 Helicon Drive · $230/sq ft · $520,0003735 Helicon Drive · $254/sq ft · $520,0001405 W Chinaberry Court · $214/sq ft · $479,00011513 Dandelion Way · $252/sq ft · $370,00011654 Lake Ride Drive · $266/sq ft · $347,00011531 Knobby Way · $231/sq ft · $390,00011599 Lake Ride Drive · $204/sq ft · $255,000863 S Lilac Loop · $224/sq ft · $349,00011659 Mossy Way · $251/sq ft · $355,00011631 East Ride Drive · $210/sq ft · $320,000204 Elmwood Drive · $237/sq ft · $530,000825 S Lilac Loop · $244/sq ft · $420,750median $229/sq ftActive now (30)12737 Old St Augustine Road · $232/sq ft · $400,0005100 Courtland Oaks Street · $248/sq ft · $409,9005024 Courtland Oaks Street · $248/sq ft · $409,9005022 Azure Street · $301/sq ft · $330,0005015 Verdis Street · $255/sq ft · $345,0004941 Verdis Street · $231/sq ft · $419,90012283 Deeder Lane · $246/sq ft · $515,0004979 Tan Street · $240/sq ft · $295,0005048 Cerise Street · $290/sq ft · $315,0005182 Beige Street · $253/sq ft · $385,0005325 Lake Gardens Lane · $213/sq ft · $420,0004964 Lake Charles Drive · $201/sq ft · $450,00012614 Joda Lane · $295/sq ft · $495,00012643 Deeder Lane · $243/sq ft · $439,0005248 Tilting Oaks Court · $221/sq ft · $415,00012444 Agatite Road · $269/sq ft · $515,0005308 Julington Creek Road · $274/sq ft · $385,0005345 Julington Ridge Court · $214/sq ft · $325,0005405 Julington Creek Road · $181/sq ft · $369,00012048 Collins Creek Drive · $154/sq ft · $335,0005628 Crest Creek Drive · $201/sq ft · $455,00012844 Plummer Grant Road · $293/sq ft · $574,90012717 Allport Road · $176/sq ft · $332,00012798 Wilderness Lane · $218/sq ft · $325,00012790 Allport Road · $211/sq ft · $360,00012951 Julington Ridge Drive · $218/sq ft · $369,90011288 Southington Place · $233/sq ft · $349,9004120 Pony Express Lane · $251/sq ft · $475,0004887 Norwalk Place · $194/sq ft · $344,9004871 Northford Place · $205/sq ft · $375,000median $233/sq ftThis home $272/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 30 homes, median $229 per sq ft; 30 priced below this home and 0 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $233 per sq ft; 25 priced below this home and 5 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
12737 Old St Augustine RoadActive139$400,0001,727$2320.0
5100 Courtland Oaks StreetActive6$409,9001,652$2480.0
5024 Courtland Oaks StreetActive6$409,9001,652$2480.1
5022 Azure StreetActive12$330,0001,097$3010.1
5015 Verdis StreetActive11$345,0001,355$2550.2
4941 Verdis StreetActive64$419,9001,815$2310.2
12283 Deeder LaneActive12$515,0002,097$2460.3
4979 Tan StreetActive26$295,0001,230$2400.3
5048 Cerise StreetActive19$315,0001,087$2900.4
5182 Beige StreetActive32$385,0001,524$2530.5
5325 Lake Gardens LaneActive136$420,0001,976$2130.5
4964 Lake Charles DriveActive20$450,0002,243$2010.5
12614 Joda LaneActive32$495,0001,676$2950.6
12643 Deeder LaneActive4$439,0001,809$2430.6
5248 Tilting Oaks CourtActive33$415,0001,882$2210.8
12444 Agatite RoadActive49$515,0001,914$2690.9
5308 Julington Creek RoadActive31$385,0001,407$2740.9
5345 Julington Ridge CourtActive4$325,0001,518$2141.0
5405 Julington Creek RoadActive104$369,0002,034$1811.0
12048 Collins Creek DriveActive1$335,0002,179$1541.0
5628 Crest Creek DriveActive88$455,0002,268$2011.0
12844 Plummer Grant RoadActive61$574,9001,961$2931.1
12717 Allport RoadActive243$332,0001,884$1761.2
12798 Wilderness LaneActive4$325,0001,492$2181.2
12790 Allport RoadActive18$360,0001,709$2111.2
12951 Julington Ridge DriveActive20$369,9001,695$2181.3
11288 Southington PlaceActive21$349,9001,501$2331.3
4120 Pony Express LaneActive68$475,0001,893$2511.5
4887 Norwalk PlaceActive47$344,9001,782$1941.6
4871 Northford PlaceActive4$375,0001,832$2051.6
4956 Grand Lakes DriveSold May 13, 20263$435,0002,103$2070.3
5327 Racoon Ridge CourtSold Sep 3, 2026—$350,0001,551$2260.6
12311 Autumnbrook TrailSold Jun 10, 202612$270,0001,939$1390.6
12283 Autumnbrook TrailSold Sep 15, 2026—$385,0001,940$1980.6
5472 Running Creek LaneSold Oct 2, 2026—$380,0001,940$1960.8
5489 Running Creek LaneSold May 8, 20266$375,0001,939$1930.8
4477 Carolyn Cove LaneSold Sep 2, 2026—$375,0001,512$2481.0
4474 Carolyn Cove LaneSold May 8, 202613$359,9001,402$2571.0
12280 Peach Orchard DriveSold Aug 7, 20263$605,9002,306$2631.3
4134 Shetland Pony LaneSold Jul 20, 20262$332,0001,708$1941.5
4134 Six Gun CourtSold Jul 22, 20263$485,0002,056$2361.6
12675 Filly CourtSold Sep 28, 2026—$455,0001,938$2351.6
12607 Quarterhorse TrailSold May 11, 202615$445,0002,068$2151.7
12527 Shady Creek DriveSold Sep 14, 2026—$445,0001,782$2501.7
4055 Waterway CourtSold Aug 27, 2026—$380,0001,657$2291.8
4050 Waterway CourtSold May 8, 20264$490,0002,145$2281.8
11791 J Anthony DriveSold May 13, 20264$399,0001,926$2072.1
4321 Pathwood WaySold Sep 30, 2026—$265,0001,390$1912.2
3752 Helicon DriveSold Aug 27, 2026—$520,0002,262$2302.2
3735 Helicon DriveSold Jul 30, 20265$520,0002,046$2542.3
1405 W Chinaberry CourtSold May 8, 202652$479,0002,240$2142.3
11513 Dandelion WaySold Jun 18, 202616$370,0001,468$2522.4
11654 Lake Ride DriveSold May 7, 20264$347,0001,306$2662.4
11531 Knobby WaySold May 29, 202628$390,0001,685$2312.4
11599 Lake Ride DriveSold Apr 24, 202674$255,0001,248$2042.4
863 S Lilac LoopSold May 5, 20263$349,0001,555$2242.4
11659 Mossy WaySold May 27, 202634$355,0001,415$2512.4
11631 East Ride DriveSold May 18, 202670$320,0001,524$2102.4
204 Elmwood DriveSold Jun 12, 20263$530,0002,236$2372.5
825 S Lilac LoopSold May 28, 20269$420,7501,727$2442.5

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap any dot: active homes open their listing, sold homes open their community guide. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

33days on market (MLS) · listed about Sep 17

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 20, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

5100 Courtland Oaks Street
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,652 sq ft · 0.0 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS
$409,900$248/sq ft
5024 Courtland Oaks Street
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,652 sq ft · 0.1 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS
$409,900$248/sq ft
5015 Verdis Street
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,355 sq ft · 0.2 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of NAVY TO NAVY HOMES LLC
$345,000$255/sq ft
4992 Tan Street
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,736 sq ft · 0.3 mi away · listed Oct 11, 2026 · 9 days on market · Courtesy of BETTER HOMES & GARDENS REAL ESTATE LIFESTYLES REALTY
$295,000$170/sq ft
12643 Deeder Lane
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,809 sq ft · 0.6 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of ASSIST2SELL FULL SERVICE REALTY LLC.
$439,000$243/sq ft
12143 Silver Saddle Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,469 sq ft · 0.9 mi away · listed Oct 15, 2026 · 5 days on market · Courtesy of 904 REALTY LLC
$364,900$248/sq ft
5345 Julington Ridge Court
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,518 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of 1 PERCENT LISTS FIRST COAST
$325,000$214/sq ft
12798 Wilderness Lane
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,492 sq ft · 1.2 mi away · listed Oct 17, 2026 · 3 days on market · Courtesy of FADER & CO REALTY LLC
$325,000$218/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

12432 Muscovy Drive, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,813 sq ft · closed Oct 16, 2026 · Julington Hills guide →
$399,000$220/sq ft
3333 Picadilly Lane, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,874 sq ft · closed Oct 14, 2026 · Pickwick Park guide →
$395,000$211/sq ft
12202 Mayors Drive, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,458 sq ft · closed Oct 5, 2026 · Mandarin Forest guide →
$329,900$226/sq ft
5472 Running Creek Lane, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,940 sq ft · closed Oct 2, 2026 · Julington Crossing
$380,000$196/sq ft
3342 Sarah Spaulding Drive, Jacksonville
4 bd · 1,681 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Lake Mandarin
$375,000$223/sq ft
4321 Pathwood Way, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,390 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · The Junction guide →
$265,000$191/sq ft
3407 Fairbanks Grant Road, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,527 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Lake Mandarin
$317,000$208/sq ft
12675 Filly Court, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,938 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Saddle Ridge guide →
$455,000$235/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Justin TimmonsJustin Timmons lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 472-4359Email Justintimmonsrealtor@gmail.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in Jacksonville · Jacksonville housing market · Duval County homes for sale · All Momentum listings