Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 2, 2026

5166 Highland Avenue

Jacksonville, FL 32258
$450,000
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,654 sq ft · built 2027
Active14 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty · Justin E Timmons
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
5166 Highland Avenue
How it's doing

Performance

14days on market (MLS) · listed about Sep 18

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 2, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

5022 Azure Street
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,097 sq ft · 0.1 mi away · listed Sep 24, 2026 · Courtesy of HERRON REAL ESTATE LLC
$330,000$301/sq ft
4979 Tan Street
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,230 sq ft · 0.3 mi away · listed Sep 25, 2026 · Courtesy of EXP REALTY LLC
$299,900$244/sq ft
4964 Lake Charles Drive
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,243 sq ft · 0.5 mi away · listed Oct 1, 2026 · Courtesy of MARK SPAIN REAL ESTATE
$460,000$205/sq ft
5009 Herton Drive
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,760 sq ft · 0.7 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of HERRON REAL ESTATE LLC
$475,000$270/sq ft
5625 Baxter Lake Drive
5 bd · 3 ba · 2,789 sq ft · 0.9 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of UNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERY
$540,000$194/sq ft
13304 Old Saint Augustine Road
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,006 sq ft · 0.9 mi away · listed Sep 25, 2026 · Courtesy of DJ & LINDSEY REAL ESTATE
$540,000$269/sq ft
4444 Summer Walk Court
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,473 sq ft · 1.2 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of UNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERY
$474,950$192/sq ft
12951 Julington Ridge Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,695 sq ft · 1.3 mi away · listed Oct 1, 2026 · Courtesy of BRANDYWINE HOMES USA LLC
$379,900$224/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

3342 Sarah Spaulding Drive, Jacksonville
4 bd · 1,681 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Lake Mandarin
$375,000$223/sq ft
4321 Pathwood Way, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,390 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · The Junction guide →
$265,000$191/sq ft
3407 Fairbanks Grant Road, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,527 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Lake Mandarin
$317,000$208/sq ft
12675 Filly Court, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,938 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Saddle Ridge guide →
$455,000$235/sq ft
13627 Brookwater Drive, Jacksonville
4 bd · 2,003 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Wells Creek guide →
$430,000$215/sq ft
3401 Parson Court, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,517 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Lake Mandarin
$289,000$191/sq ft
9042 Warwickshire Road, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,456 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Brierwood guide →
$310,000$213/sq ft
4931 N Southwark Drive, Jacksonville
3 bd · 1,592 sq ft · closed Sep 24, 2026 · Brierwood guide →
$298,000$187/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold recently (within 3 mi). Same property type, living area within 40%. The subdivision-only comparison is under Pricing position below.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)

Price vs. size

$300K$400K$500K$600K1,5002,000Living area (sq ft)4956 Grand Lakes Drive · $435,000 · 2,103 sq ft · sold May 13, 20265327 Racoon Ridge Court · $350,000 · 1,551 sq ft · sold Sep 3, 202612311 Autumnbrook Trail · $270,000 · 1,939 sq ft · sold Jun 10, 202612283 Autumnbrook Trail · $385,000 · 1,940 sq ft · sold Sep 15, 20265489 Running Creek Lane · $375,000 · 1,939 sq ft · sold May 8, 20264477 Carolyn Cove Lane · $375,000 · 1,512 sq ft · sold Sep 2, 20264474 Carolyn Cove Lane · $359,900 · 1,402 sq ft · sold May 8, 202612352 Hood Landing Road · $420,000 · 1,838 sq ft · sold Apr 6, 202612280 Peach Orchard Drive · $605,900 · 2,306 sq ft · sold Aug 7, 20264134 Shetland Pony Lane · $332,000 · 1,708 sq ft · sold Jul 20, 20264134 Six Gun Court · $485,000 · 2,056 sq ft · sold Jul 22, 202612675 Filly Court · $455,000 · 1,938 sq ft · sold Sep 28, 202612607 Quarterhorse Trail · $445,000 · 2,068 sq ft · sold May 11, 202612527 Shady Creek Drive · $445,000 · 1,782 sq ft · sold Sep 14, 20264055 Waterway Court · $380,000 · 1,657 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 20264050 Waterway Court · $490,000 · 2,145 sq ft · sold May 8, 202611791 J Anthony Drive · $399,000 · 1,926 sq ft · sold May 13, 20264321 Pathwood Way · $265,000 · 1,390 sq ft · sold Sep 30, 20263752 Helicon Drive · $520,000 · 2,262 sq ft · sold Aug 27, 202611290 Pine Street · $455,000 · 2,138 sq ft · sold Apr 3, 20263735 Helicon Drive · $520,000 · 2,046 sq ft · sold Jul 30, 20261405 W Chinaberry Court · $479,000 · 2,240 sq ft · sold May 8, 202611513 Dandelion Way · $370,000 · 1,468 sq ft · sold Jun 18, 202611654 Lake Ride Drive · $347,000 · 1,306 sq ft · sold May 7, 202611531 Knobby Way · $390,000 · 1,685 sq ft · sold May 29, 202611599 Lake Ride Drive · $255,000 · 1,248 sq ft · sold Apr 24, 2026863 S Lilac Loop · $349,000 · 1,555 sq ft · sold May 5, 202611659 Mossy Way · $355,000 · 1,415 sq ft · sold May 27, 202611631 East Ride Drive · $320,000 · 1,524 sq ft · sold May 18, 2026825 S Lilac Loop · $420,750 · 1,727 sq ft · sold May 28, 202612737 Old St Augustine Road · $405,000 · 1,727 sq ft · active5022 Azure Street · $330,000 · 1,097 sq ft · active4941 Verdis Street · $419,900 · 1,815 sq ft · active4979 Tan Street · $299,900 · 1,230 sq ft · active5048 Cerise Street · $315,000 · 1,087 sq ft · active5182 Beige Street · $400,000 · 1,524 sq ft · active5325 Lake Gardens Lane · $420,000 · 1,976 sq ft · active4964 Lake Charles Drive · $460,000 · 2,243 sq ft · active12614 Joda Lane · $515,000 · 1,676 sq ft · active5465 Autumnbrook Trail #2 · $375,000 · 1,939 sq ft · active5340 Gathering Oaks Court · $439,000 · 1,939 sq ft · active5308 Julington Creek Road · $395,000 · 1,407 sq ft · active13304 Old Saint Augustine Road · $540,000 · 2,006 sq ft · active5405 Julington Creek Road · $369,000 · 2,034 sq ft · active5628 Crest Creek Drive · $465,000 · 2,268 sq ft · active12844 Plummer Grant Road · $579,900 · 1,961 sq ft · active12717 Allport Road · $332,000 · 1,884 sq ft · active12951 Julington Ridge Drive · $379,900 · 1,695 sq ft · active4887 Norwalk Place · $349,750 · 1,782 sq ft · active12459 Shady Creek Drive · $376,000 · 1,769 sq ft · active4063 Julington Creek Road · $390,000 · 2,025 sq ft · active10930 Steeding Horse Drive · $315,000 · 1,828 sq ft · active4008 Field Brook Lane · $525,000 · 1,728 sq ft · active12234 Lavenhorn Road · $420,000 · 1,681 sq ft · active11561 St Josephs Road · $360,000 · 1,566 sq ft · active10859 Saddle Horn Drive · $350,000 · 1,639 sq ft · active1316 E Chinaberry Court · $449,800 · 2,182 sq ft · active5312 Blue Pacific Drive · $460,000 · 2,184 sq ft · active11852 Pegasus Drive · $545,000 · 2,252 sq ft · active3741 N Ride Drive · $264,900 · 1,644 sq ft · activeThis home · $450,000 · 1,654 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$150$200$250$300Sold (6 mo) (30)$207/sq ft$226/sq ft$139/sq ft$198/sq ft$193/sq ft$248/sq ft$257/sq ft$229/sq ft$263/sq ft$194/sq ft$236/sq ft$235/sq ft$215/sq ft$250/sq ft$229/sq ft$228/sq ft$207/sq ft$191/sq ft$230/sq ft$213/sq ft$254/sq ft$214/sq ft$252/sq ft$266/sq ft$231/sq ft$204/sq ft$224/sq ft$251/sq ft$210/sq ft$244/sq ftmedian $229/sq ftActive now (30)$235/sq ft$301/sq ft$231/sq ft$244/sq ft$290/sq ft$262/sq ft$213/sq ft$205/sq ft$307/sq ft$193/sq ft$226/sq ft$281/sq ft$269/sq ft$181/sq ft$205/sq ft$296/sq ft$176/sq ft$224/sq ft$196/sq ft$213/sq ft$193/sq ft$172/sq ft$304/sq ft$250/sq ft$230/sq ft$214/sq ft$206/sq ft$211/sq ft$242/sq ft$161/sq ftmedian $226/sq ftThis home $272/sq ft

Priced at $272 per sq ft, higher than 30 of 30 recent sales (median $229).

Priced at $272 per sq ft, higher than 24 of 30 active competitors (median $226).

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
12737 Old St Augustine RoadActive$405,0001,727$2350.0
5022 Azure StreetActive$330,0001,097$3010.1
4941 Verdis StreetActive$419,9001,815$2310.2
4979 Tan StreetActive$299,9001,230$2440.3
5048 Cerise StreetActive$315,0001,087$2900.4
5182 Beige StreetActive$400,0001,524$2620.5
5325 Lake Gardens LaneActive$420,0001,976$2130.5
4964 Lake Charles DriveActive$460,0002,243$2050.5
12614 Joda LaneActive$515,0001,676$3070.6
5465 Autumnbrook Trail #2Active$375,0001,939$1930.7
5340 Gathering Oaks CourtActive$439,0001,939$2260.9
5308 Julington Creek RoadActive$395,0001,407$2810.9
13304 Old Saint Augustine RoadActive$540,0002,006$2690.9
5405 Julington Creek RoadActive$369,0002,034$1811.0
5628 Crest Creek DriveActive$465,0002,268$2051.0
12844 Plummer Grant RoadActive$579,9001,961$2961.1
12717 Allport RoadActive$332,0001,884$1761.2
12951 Julington Ridge DriveActive$379,9001,695$2241.3
4887 Norwalk PlaceActive$349,7501,782$1961.6
12459 Shady Creek DriveActive$376,0001,769$2131.7
4063 Julington Creek RoadActive$390,0002,025$1931.8
10930 Steeding Horse DriveActive$315,0001,828$1721.9
4008 Field Brook LaneActive$525,0001,728$3041.9
12234 Lavenhorn RoadActive$420,0001,681$2502.0
11561 St Josephs RoadActive$360,0001,566$2302.1
10859 Saddle Horn DriveActive$350,0001,639$2142.1
1316 E Chinaberry CourtActive$449,8002,182$2062.3
5312 Blue Pacific DriveActive$460,0002,184$2112.3
11852 Pegasus DriveActive$545,0002,252$2422.3
3741 N Ride DriveActive$264,9001,644$1612.4
4956 Grand Lakes DriveSold May 13, 2026$435,0002,103$2070.3
5327 Racoon Ridge CourtSold Sep 3, 2026$350,0001,551$2260.6
12311 Autumnbrook TrailSold Jun 10, 2026$270,0001,939$1390.6
12283 Autumnbrook TrailSold Sep 15, 2026$385,0001,940$1980.6
5489 Running Creek LaneSold May 8, 2026$375,0001,939$1930.8
4477 Carolyn Cove LaneSold Sep 2, 2026$375,0001,512$2481.0
4474 Carolyn Cove LaneSold May 8, 2026$359,9001,402$2571.0
12352 Hood Landing RoadSold Apr 6, 2026$420,0001,838$2291.2
12280 Peach Orchard DriveSold Aug 7, 2026$605,9002,306$2631.3
4134 Shetland Pony LaneSold Jul 20, 2026$332,0001,708$1941.5
4134 Six Gun CourtSold Jul 22, 2026$485,0002,056$2361.6
12675 Filly CourtSold Sep 28, 2026$455,0001,938$2351.6
12607 Quarterhorse TrailSold May 11, 2026$445,0002,068$2151.7
12527 Shady Creek DriveSold Sep 14, 2026$445,0001,782$2501.7
4055 Waterway CourtSold Aug 27, 2026$380,0001,657$2291.8
4050 Waterway CourtSold May 8, 2026$490,0002,145$2281.8
11791 J Anthony DriveSold May 13, 2026$399,0001,926$2072.1
4321 Pathwood WaySold Sep 30, 2026$265,0001,390$1912.2
3752 Helicon DriveSold Aug 27, 2026$520,0002,262$2302.2
11290 Pine StreetSold Apr 3, 2026$455,0002,138$2132.2
3735 Helicon DriveSold Jul 30, 2026$520,0002,046$2542.3
1405 W Chinaberry CourtSold May 8, 2026$479,0002,240$2142.3
11513 Dandelion WaySold Jun 18, 2026$370,0001,468$2522.4
11654 Lake Ride DriveSold May 7, 2026$347,0001,306$2662.4
11531 Knobby WaySold May 29, 2026$390,0001,685$2312.4
11599 Lake Ride DriveSold Apr 24, 2026$255,0001,248$2042.4
863 S Lilac LoopSold May 5, 2026$349,0001,555$2242.4
11659 Mossy WaySold May 27, 2026$355,0001,415$2512.4
11631 East Ride DriveSold May 18, 2026$320,0001,524$2102.4
825 S Lilac LoopSold May 28, 2026$420,7501,727$2442.5

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Hover or tap a dot for the address. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Pricing position

Price per square foot vs. comparable sales

$272this home, per sq ft
$226median of 6 comparable sales within about 3 miles
6 of 6comparable sales priced below this home per sq ft

Comparable sales: same property type, living area within 30%, closed within 18 months, within about 3 miles. Stronger local evidence. Context, not a valuation.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Justin E Timmons lists this home. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 351-6461
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in Jacksonville · Jacksonville housing market · Duval County homes for sale · All Momentum listings