Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Nov 11, 2026

1685 Fenton Avenue

St. Johns, FL 32259
$760,000
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,977 sq ft · built 2013
Under contract40 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
1685 Fenton Avenue
Bottom line

This home is asking $191 per square foot. Recent comparable sales: median $225 per square foot (30 homes). Homes for sale nearby: median $249 per square foot (30 homes).

Since last week: 12 new competing listings, 13 competitors left the market.

Competitor moves this week

Similar homes nearby: 8 price cuts

Same property type and size band, within 5 miles, in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove), in the last 7 days. Tap one to open it.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold in the last 6 months (within 3 mi): same property type, living area within 40%, all in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove).

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)Tap a dot to open that home's page (only homes with a page on our site open)

Price vs. size

$500K$750K$1.0M$1.2M2,5003,0003,5004,0004,500Living area (sq ft)1681 Fenton Avenue · $550,000 · 2,555 sq ft · sold Oct 27, 20261684 Fenton Avenue · $585,000 · 2,909 sq ft · sold Sep 14, 20261629 Fenton Avenue · $875,000 · 3,668 sq ft · sold Jul 17, 2026 · sold in 50 days136 Dundee Place · $1,000,000 · 3,922 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 2026 · sold in 7 days1216 Leith Hall Drive · $819,900 · 4,257 sq ft · sold Jun 15, 2026 · sold in 8 days570 Saddlestone Drive · $785,000 · 2,840 sq ft · sold Oct 28, 2026532 Saddlestone Drive · $982,000 · 3,834 sq ft · sold Oct 2, 20261908 Dumfries Court · $945,000 · 4,032 sq ft · sold Aug 4, 2026 · sold in 28 days1261 Leith Hall Drive · $885,000 · 3,330 sq ft · sold Jun 18, 2026 · sold in 12 days3220 Chestnut Court · $660,000 · 3,103 sq ft · sold Sep 25, 2026137 Calliel Way · $825,000 · 3,665 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026 · sold in 2 days160 Woodcross Drive · $789,000 · 2,763 sq ft · sold Jul 24, 2026 · sold in 16 days321 Bent Creek Drive · $599,000 · 2,796 sq ft · sold May 22, 2026 · sold in 63 days409 Starlis Place · $579,900 · 2,400 sq ft · sold Sep 9, 2026933 Bent Creek Drive · $720,000 · 2,548 sq ft · sold Jun 24, 2026 · sold in 4 days184 Rockcreek Drive · $719,900 · 3,281 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 2026 · sold in 55 days156 Wellwood Avenue · $914,300 · 4,285 sq ft · sold Aug 6, 2026 · sold in 71 days36 Delano Street · $670,000 · 3,111 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026 · sold in 3 days162 Carina Trail · $769,000 · 2,952 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026 · sold in 48 days171 Wellwood Avenue · $1,275,000 · 4,289 sq ft · sold Jul 1, 2026 · sold in 3 days2608 Pecan Place · $689,000 · 2,574 sq ft · sold Jul 2, 2026 · sold in 0 days159 Rockcreek Drive · $775,000 · 3,452 sq ft · sold Jun 26, 2026 · sold in 6 days27 Timber Stand Road · $726,000 · 3,289 sq ft · sold Sep 23, 2026174 Staplehurst Drive · $815,000 · 3,201 sq ft · sold Nov 6, 202684 Pavia Place · $685,000 · 2,763 sq ft · sold Jul 24, 2026 · sold in 8 days157 Longwood Street · $583,000 · 2,807 sq ft · sold Sep 17, 2026762 Bent Creek Drive · $540,000 · 2,484 sq ft · sold Nov 6, 2026102 Starlis Place · $615,000 · 3,196 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026 · sold in 206 days237 Sparrow Branch Circle · $595,000 · 2,732 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 2026 · sold in 47 days48 Lacaille Avenue · $660,000 · 3,193 sq ft · sold Jul 31, 2026 · sold in 71 days1745 Pennan Place · $789,900 · 3,159 sq ft · active · 57 days on market804 Stelling Court · $809,900 · 3,297 sq ft · active · 110 days on market92 Maleda Way · $835,000 · 3,619 sq ft · active · 15 days on market383 Pine Haven Drive · $929,000 · 3,597 sq ft · active · 68 days on market240 Pine Haven Drive · $899,900 · 3,304 sq ft · active · 111 days on market3900 E Glendale Court · $551,352 · 3,422 sq ft · active · 15 days on market55 Blue Hole Court · $1,364,900 · 4,323 sq ft · active · 25 days on market1101 Roundtree Circle · $499,000 · 3,502 sq ft · active · 89 days on market116 Quail Creek Circle · $675,000 · 3,594 sq ft · active · 127 days on market103 Port Avenue · $699,000 · 2,887 sq ft · active · 213 days on market109 Earlston Way · $679,000 · 3,148 sq ft · active · 118 days on market295 Willow Winds Parkway · $575,000 · 2,394 sq ft · active · 39 days on market482 Sparrow Branch Circle · $649,900 · 2,544 sq ft · active · 14 days on market123 Willow Winds Parkway · $569,000 · 2,559 sq ft · active · 1 days on market397 Lakeview Pass Way · $1,409,000 · 4,502 sq ft · active · 93 days on market790 Navigators Road · $765,232 · 2,538 sq ft · active · 120 days on market389 Tierra Cove · $1,025,000 · 4,419 sq ft · active · 99 days on market179 Navigators Road · $849,000 · 3,526 sq ft · active · 41 days on market14367 Durbin Island Way · $467,900 · 2,393 sq ft · active · 34 days on market103 Junction Avenue · $939,583 · 3,196 sq ft · active · 63 days on market71 Junction Avenue · $949,204 · 3,813 sq ft · active · 158 days on market21 Star Crossed Lane · $635,000 · 2,485 sq ft · active · 146 days on market104 Moselle Lane · $559,999 · 2,790 sq ft · active · 165 days on market228 Conquistador Road · $819,000 · 3,164 sq ft · active · 161 days on market124 Berot Circle · $699,000 · 2,724 sq ft · active · 26 days on market113 Berot Circle · $645,000 · 2,561 sq ft · active · 9 days on market108 Crowder Court · $769,000 · 3,246 sq ft · active · 10 days on market200 S Arabella Way · $699,000 · 2,542 sq ft · active · 251 days on market385 Dogleg Run · $679,970 · 2,726 sq ft · active · 47 days on market700 N Indigo Terrace · $625,000 · 2,835 sq ft · active · 47 days on marketThis home · $760,000 · 3,977 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$150$200$250$300$350Sold (6 mo) (30)1681 Fenton Avenue · $215/sq ft · $550,0001684 Fenton Avenue · $201/sq ft · $585,0001629 Fenton Avenue · $239/sq ft · $875,000136 Dundee Place · $255/sq ft · $1,000,0001216 Leith Hall Drive · $193/sq ft · $819,900570 Saddlestone Drive · $276/sq ft · $785,000532 Saddlestone Drive · $256/sq ft · $982,0001908 Dumfries Court · $234/sq ft · $945,0001261 Leith Hall Drive · $266/sq ft · $885,0003220 Chestnut Court · $213/sq ft · $660,000137 Calliel Way · $225/sq ft · $825,000160 Woodcross Drive · $286/sq ft · $789,000321 Bent Creek Drive · $214/sq ft · $599,000409 Starlis Place · $242/sq ft · $579,900933 Bent Creek Drive · $283/sq ft · $720,000184 Rockcreek Drive · $219/sq ft · $719,900156 Wellwood Avenue · $213/sq ft · $914,30036 Delano Street · $215/sq ft · $670,000162 Carina Trail · $261/sq ft · $769,000171 Wellwood Avenue · $297/sq ft · $1,275,0002608 Pecan Place · $268/sq ft · $689,000159 Rockcreek Drive · $225/sq ft · $775,00027 Timber Stand Road · $221/sq ft · $726,000174 Staplehurst Drive · $255/sq ft · $815,00084 Pavia Place · $248/sq ft · $685,000157 Longwood Street · $208/sq ft · $583,000762 Bent Creek Drive · $217/sq ft · $540,000102 Starlis Place · $192/sq ft · $615,000237 Sparrow Branch Circle · $218/sq ft · $595,00048 Lacaille Avenue · $207/sq ft · $660,000median $225/sq ftActive now (30)1745 Pennan Place · $250/sq ft · $789,900804 Stelling Court · $246/sq ft · $809,90092 Maleda Way · $231/sq ft · $835,000383 Pine Haven Drive · $258/sq ft · $929,000240 Pine Haven Drive · $272/sq ft · $899,9003900 E Glendale Court · $161/sq ft · $551,35255 Blue Hole Court · $316/sq ft · $1,364,9001101 Roundtree Circle · $142/sq ft · $499,000116 Quail Creek Circle · $188/sq ft · $675,000103 Port Avenue · $242/sq ft · $699,000109 Earlston Way · $216/sq ft · $679,000295 Willow Winds Parkway · $240/sq ft · $575,000482 Sparrow Branch Circle · $255/sq ft · $649,900123 Willow Winds Parkway · $222/sq ft · $569,000397 Lakeview Pass Way · $313/sq ft · $1,409,000790 Navigators Road · $302/sq ft · $765,232389 Tierra Cove · $232/sq ft · $1,025,000179 Navigators Road · $241/sq ft · $849,00014367 Durbin Island Way · $196/sq ft · $467,900103 Junction Avenue · $294/sq ft · $939,58371 Junction Avenue · $249/sq ft · $949,20421 Star Crossed Lane · $256/sq ft · $635,000104 Moselle Lane · $201/sq ft · $559,999228 Conquistador Road · $259/sq ft · $819,000124 Berot Circle · $257/sq ft · $699,000113 Berot Circle · $252/sq ft · $645,000108 Crowder Court · $237/sq ft · $769,000200 S Arabella Way · $275/sq ft · $699,000385 Dogleg Run · $249/sq ft · $679,970700 N Indigo Terrace · $220/sq ft · $625,000median $249/sq ftThis home $191/sq ft

Sold in the last 6 months: 30 homes, median $225 per sq ft; 0 priced below this home and 30 at or above it.

Homes for sale nearby: 30 homes, median $249 per sq ft; 3 priced below this home and 27 at or above it.

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusDays on marketPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
1745 Pennan PlaceActive57$789,9003,159$2500.3
804 Stelling CourtActive110$809,9003,297$2460.4
92 Maleda WayActive15$835,0003,619$2311.0
383 Pine Haven DriveActive68$929,0003,597$2581.1
240 Pine Haven DriveActive111$899,9003,304$2721.2
3900 E Glendale CourtActive15$551,3523,422$1611.2
55 Blue Hole CourtActive25$1,364,9004,323$3161.3
1101 Roundtree CircleActive89$499,0003,502$1421.4
116 Quail Creek CircleActive127$675,0003,594$1881.4
103 Port AvenueActive213$699,0002,887$2421.4
109 Earlston WayActive118$679,0003,148$2161.5
295 Willow Winds ParkwayActive39$575,0002,394$2401.5
482 Sparrow Branch CircleActive14$649,9002,544$2551.6
123 Willow Winds ParkwayActive1$569,0002,559$2221.6
397 Lakeview Pass WayActive93$1,409,0004,502$3131.6
790 Navigators RoadActive120$765,2322,538$3021.6
389 Tierra CoveActive99$1,025,0004,419$2321.7
179 Navigators RoadActive41$849,0003,526$2411.7
14367 Durbin Island WayActive34$467,9002,393$1961.7
103 Junction AvenueActive63$939,5833,196$2941.8
71 Junction AvenueActive158$949,2043,813$2491.8
21 Star Crossed LaneActive146$635,0002,485$2561.8
104 Moselle LaneActive165$559,9992,790$2012.2
228 Conquistador RoadActive161$819,0003,164$2592.2
124 Berot CircleActive26$699,0002,724$2572.3
113 Berot CircleActive9$645,0002,561$2522.3
108 Crowder CourtActive10$769,0003,246$2372.3
200 S Arabella WayActive251$699,0002,542$2752.3
385 Dogleg RunActive47$679,9702,726$2492.4
700 N Indigo TerraceActive47$625,0002,835$2202.5
1681 Fenton AvenueSold Oct 27, 2026—$550,0002,555$2150.0
1684 Fenton AvenueSold Sep 14, 2026—$585,0002,909$2010.0
1629 Fenton AvenueSold Jul 17, 202650$875,0003,668$2390.2
136 Dundee PlaceSold Jul 7, 20267$1,000,0003,922$2550.2
1216 Leith Hall DriveSold Jun 15, 20268$819,9004,257$1930.3
570 Saddlestone DriveSold Oct 28, 2026—$785,0002,840$2760.4
532 Saddlestone DriveSold Oct 2, 2026—$982,0003,834$2560.4
1908 Dumfries CourtSold Aug 4, 202628$945,0004,032$2340.4
1261 Leith Hall DriveSold Jun 18, 202612$885,0003,330$2660.5
3220 Chestnut CourtSold Sep 25, 2026—$660,0003,103$2130.7
137 Calliel WaySold Jun 5, 20262$825,0003,665$2250.8
160 Woodcross DriveSold Jul 24, 202616$789,0002,763$2860.8
321 Bent Creek DriveSold May 22, 202663$599,0002,796$2140.8
409 Starlis PlaceSold Sep 9, 2026—$579,9002,400$2420.8
933 Bent Creek DriveSold Jun 24, 20264$720,0002,548$2830.9
184 Rockcreek DriveSold Jun 1, 202655$719,9003,281$2190.9
156 Wellwood AvenueSold Aug 6, 202671$914,3004,285$2130.9
36 Delano StreetSold May 29, 20263$670,0003,111$2150.9
162 Carina TrailSold Jun 5, 202648$769,0002,952$2610.9
171 Wellwood AvenueSold Jul 1, 20263$1,275,0004,289$2970.9
2608 Pecan PlaceSold Jul 2, 20260$689,0002,574$2681.0
159 Rockcreek DriveSold Jun 26, 20266$775,0003,452$2251.0
27 Timber Stand RoadSold Sep 23, 2026—$726,0003,289$2211.0
174 Staplehurst DriveSold Nov 6, 2026—$815,0003,201$2551.0
84 Pavia PlaceSold Jul 24, 20268$685,0002,763$2481.0
157 Longwood StreetSold Sep 17, 2026—$583,0002,807$2081.0
762 Bent Creek DriveSold Nov 6, 2026—$540,0002,484$2171.0
102 Starlis PlaceSold Jun 5, 2026206$615,0003,196$1921.0
237 Sparrow Branch CircleSold Jun 12, 202647$595,0002,732$2181.1
48 Lacaille AvenueSold Jul 31, 202671$660,0003,193$2071.1

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Tap a dot to open that home's own page on our site (its listing, or its sold or off-market page); homes without a page here are not linked. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How it's doing

Performance

40days on market (MLS) · listed about Oct 2

Showings, saves and portal inquiries are not in this data.

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Nov 11, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

6 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove) in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

92 Maleda Way
4 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,619 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Nov 5, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS FIRST COAST REALTY
$835,000$231/sq ft
2409 Cimarrone Boulevard
4 bd · 3 ba · 3,112 sq ft · 1.9 mi away · listed Nov 5, 2026 · 6 days on market · Courtesy of RE/MAX UNLIMITED
$925,000$297/sq ft
1972 Web Foot Place
4 bd · 2 ba · 2,481 sq ft · 3.7 mi away · listed Nov 10, 2026 · 1 day on market · Courtesy of HOMECOIN.COM
$749,900$302/sq ft
381 Caribbean Place
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,555 sq ft · 4.2 mi away · listed Nov 7, 2026 · 4 days on market · Courtesy of REAL BROKER LLC
$610,000$239/sq ft
120 Crown Wheel Circle
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 3,042 sq ft · 4.4 mi away · listed Oct 31, 2026 · 11 days on market · Courtesy of BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY
$485,000$159/sq ft
1610 Lemonwood Road
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,631 sq ft · 4.6 mi away · listed Nov 7, 2026 · 4 days on market · Courtesy of UNITED REAL ESTATE GALLERY
$625,000$238/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the same part of St. Johns County (Fruit Cove) in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

174 Staplehurst Drive, St. Johns
5 bd · 3,201 sq ft · closed Nov 6, 2026 · Durbin Crossing guide →
$815,000$255/sq ft
762 Bent Creek Drive, St. Johns
4 bd · 2,484 sq ft · closed Nov 6, 2026 · Durbin Creek Estates guide →
$540,000$217/sq ft
220 Pine Haven Drive, St. Johns
3 bd · 2,673 sq ft · closed Nov 2, 2026 · Julington Lakes guide →
$855,000$320/sq ft
570 Saddlestone Drive, St. Johns
5 bd · 2,840 sq ft · closed Oct 28, 2026 · Durbin Crossing guide →
$785,000$276/sq ft
1681 Fenton Avenue, St. Johns
4 bd · 2,555 sq ft · closed Oct 27, 2026 · Durbin Crossing guide →
$550,000$215/sq ft
189 St Johns Forest Boulevard, St. Johns
6 bd · 4,113 sq ft · closed Oct 26, 2026 · St Johns Forest guide →
$1,087,500$264/sq ft
212 Twining Trce, St. Johns
5 bd · 2,996 sq ft · closed Oct 23, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan guide →
$765,000$255/sq ft
1311 Cormorant Court, St. Johns
4 bd · 2,582 sq ft · closed Oct 21, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan guide →
$665,000$258/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Heather StrazinskyHeather Strazinsky lists this home. View profile. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 598-4656Email heather@teamheatheranddanielle.com
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in St. Johns · St. Johns housing market · St. Johns County homes for sale · All Momentum listings