Momentum RealtyFull listing page →
Listing report · updated Oct 2, 2026

1685 Fenton Avenue

St. Johns, FL 32259
$760,000
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,977 sq ft · built 2013
Active0 days on marketListed by Momentum Realty · Heather Strazinsky
Ask about this homeCopy share linkText it
1685 Fenton Avenue
How it's doing

Performance

0days on market (MLS)

Days on market per the MLS. Google figures are Search Console data for this listing's page on movewithmomentum.com (28 days to Oct 2, 2026); they count search appearances and clicks, not all visits. Price changes are our own observations.

Competition

New listings nearby this week

8 similar homes listed by any brokerage within 5 miles in the last 7 days at a comparable price — the buyers touring this home are seeing these too.

616 E Tropical Trace
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,746 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of CHRISTIE'S INTERNATIONAL REAL ESTATE FIRST COAST
$510,000$292/sq ft
174 Staplehurst Drive
5 bd · 4 ba · 3,201 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Oct 1, 2026 · Courtesy of SAVVY AVENUE, LLC.
$855,000$267/sq ft
211 Tadcaster Court
3 bd · 2 ba · 2,070 sq ft · 1.0 mi away · listed Sep 26, 2026 · Courtesy of REAL BROKER LLC
$500,000$242/sq ft
121 Chatsworth Drive
5 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,229 sq ft · 1.2 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS
$910,000$282/sq ft
362 Freshwater Drive
4 bd · 4 ba · 3,257 sq ft · 1.7 mi away · listed Sep 24, 2026 · Courtesy of ROUND TABLE REALTY
$989,000$304/sq ft
373 Navigators Road
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,491 sq ft · 1.8 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of KARSTEN REAL ESTATE TEAM
$699,000$281/sq ft
21 Star Crossed Lane
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,485 sq ft · 1.8 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of EXP REALTY, LLC
$640,000$258/sq ft
272 Prince Albert Avenue
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,361 sq ft · 2.0 mi away · listed Sep 29, 2026 · Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER VANGUARD REALTY
$599,000$254/sq ft

Source: Momentum's hourly MLS refresh, all brokerages. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Just sold

Recent closed sales nearby

8 closed sales of a similar home within 5 miles in the last 90 days. Tap one to open its neighborhood guide.

53 Lumen Court, St. Augustine
4 bd · 3,315 sq ft · closed Oct 1, 2026 · Beacon Lake
$750,000$226/sq ft
516 Bronze Branch Court, St. Johns
5 bd · 4,315 sq ft · closed Sep 30, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan guide →
$1,000,000$232/sq ft
141 Chestnut Oak Road, St. Augustine
4 bd · 3,969 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Silverleaf guide →
$1,458,064$367/sq ft
237 Crooked Court, St. Johns
3 bd · 2,006 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan guide →
$475,000$237/sq ft
312 Morning Glory Lane, Fruit Cove
4 bd · 2,193 sq ft · closed Sep 28, 2026 · Julington Creek Plan
$430,000$196/sq ft
177 Southern Grove Drive, St. Johns
3 bd · 1,496 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Southern Grove guide →
$330,000$221/sq ft
275 Freshwater Drive, St. Johns
4 bd · 3,244 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Julington Lakes guide →
$775,000$239/sq ft
43 Cruden Bay Court, St. Johns
4 bd · 2,041 sq ft · closed Sep 25, 2026 · Aberdeen guide →
$440,000$216/sq ft

Sold prices are MLS closed-sale records, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for context only — not an appraisal of this home.

Where it sits

This home vs. active and sold comparables

This home against 30 similar homes for sale now (within 3 mi) and 30 similar homes that sold recently (within 3 mi). Same property type, living area within 40%. The subdivision-only comparison is under Pricing position below.

This home Active now (30) Sold (30)

Price vs. size

$500K$750K$1.0M$1.2M$1.5M2,5003,0003,5004,0004,500Living area (sq ft)1684 Fenton Avenue · $585,000 · 2,909 sq ft · sold Sep 14, 20261629 Fenton Avenue · $875,000 · 3,668 sq ft · sold Jul 17, 20261621 Fenton Avenue · $726,000 · 4,323 sq ft · sold Apr 16, 2026136 Dundee Place · $1,000,000 · 3,922 sq ft · sold Jul 7, 20261216 Leith Hall Drive · $819,900 · 4,257 sq ft · sold Jun 15, 2026425 Buckhead Court · $750,000 · 3,380 sq ft · sold Apr 14, 20261908 Dumfries Court · $945,000 · 4,032 sq ft · sold Aug 4, 20261261 Leith Hall Drive · $885,000 · 3,330 sq ft · sold Jun 18, 20261940 Dumfries Court · $955,000 · 3,319 sq ft · sold Apr 8, 20263220 Chestnut Court · $660,000 · 3,103 sq ft · sold Sep 25, 2026137 Calliel Way · $825,000 · 3,665 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026160 Woodcross Drive · $789,000 · 2,763 sq ft · sold Jul 24, 2026321 Bent Creek Drive · $599,000 · 2,796 sq ft · sold May 22, 2026409 Starlis Place · $579,900 · 2,400 sq ft · sold Sep 9, 2026933 Bent Creek Drive · $720,000 · 2,548 sq ft · sold Jun 24, 2026184 Rockcreek Drive · $719,900 · 3,281 sq ft · sold Jun 1, 20264085 Lonicera Loop · $603,000 · 2,935 sq ft · sold Apr 30, 2026156 Wellwood Avenue · $914,300 · 4,285 sq ft · sold Aug 6, 202636 Delano Street · $670,000 · 3,111 sq ft · sold May 29, 2026162 Carina Trail · $769,000 · 2,952 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026171 Wellwood Avenue · $1,275,000 · 4,289 sq ft · sold Jul 1, 20262608 Pecan Place · $689,000 · 2,574 sq ft · sold Jul 2, 2026159 Rockcreek Drive · $775,000 · 3,452 sq ft · sold Jun 26, 202627 Timber Stand Road · $726,000 · 3,289 sq ft · sold Sep 23, 202648 Pavia Place · $700,000 · 3,008 sq ft · sold Apr 28, 202684 Pavia Place · $685,000 · 2,763 sq ft · sold Jul 24, 2026157 Longwood Street · $583,000 · 2,807 sq ft · sold Sep 17, 2026102 Starlis Place · $615,000 · 3,196 sq ft · sold Jun 5, 2026237 Sparrow Branch Circle · $595,000 · 2,732 sq ft · sold Jun 12, 202648 Lacaille Avenue · $660,000 · 3,193 sq ft · sold Jul 31, 20261745 Pennan Place · $789,900 · 3,159 sq ft · active1324 Fryston Street · $930,000 · 3,064 sq ft · active804 Stelling Court · $849,900 · 3,297 sq ft · active200 Huntston Way · $613,000 · 3,100 sq ft · active221 Tollerton Avenue · $479,900 · 2,565 sq ft · active127 Rockcreek Drive · $749,900 · 3,440 sq ft · active101 Brianhead Court · $629,999 · 2,935 sq ft · active215 Carina Trail · $750,000 · 2,604 sq ft · active2608 Pecan Place · $689,000 · 2,574 sq ft · active174 Staplehurst Drive · $855,000 · 3,201 sq ft · active448 Pine Haven Drive · $749,000 · 2,673 sq ft · active383 Pine Haven Drive · $929,000 · 3,597 sq ft · active4025 Lonicera Loop · $559,000 · 2,584 sq ft · active240 Pine Haven Drive · $994,000 · 3,304 sq ft · active121 Chatsworth Drive · $910,000 · 3,229 sq ft · active123 Sugar Sand Lane · $939,900 · 3,703 sq ft · active969 W Tennessee Trace · $549,000 · 3,523 sq ft · active250 Shadow Cove · $850,000 · 3,245 sq ft · active200 Ravensbury Way · $740,000 · 3,228 sq ft · active1101 Roundtree Circle · $505,000 · 3,502 sq ft · active116 Quail Creek Circle · $675,000 · 3,594 sq ft · active103 Port Avenue · $719,000 · 2,887 sq ft · active295 Willow Winds Parkway · $575,000 · 2,394 sq ft · active215 Freshwater Drive · $850,000 · 2,695 sq ft · active245 Freshwater Drive · $844,700 · 3,182 sq ft · active1925 Barham Court · $609,925 · 2,685 sq ft · active276 Ellsworth Circle · $668,000 · 2,993 sq ft · active397 Lakeview Pass Way · $1,449,000 · 4,502 sq ft · active790 Navigators Road · $765,232 · 2,538 sq ft · active315 Tierra Cove · $1,074,999 · 4,412 sq ft · activeThis home · $760,000 · 3,977 sq ftThis home

Price per square foot

$100$150$200$250$300Sold (6 mo) (30)$201/sq ft$239/sq ft$168/sq ft$255/sq ft$193/sq ft$222/sq ft$234/sq ft$266/sq ft$288/sq ft$213/sq ft$225/sq ft$286/sq ft$214/sq ft$242/sq ft$283/sq ft$219/sq ft$205/sq ft$213/sq ft$215/sq ft$261/sq ft$297/sq ft$268/sq ft$225/sq ft$221/sq ft$233/sq ft$248/sq ft$208/sq ft$192/sq ft$218/sq ft$207/sq ftmedian $225/sq ftActive now (30)$250/sq ft$304/sq ft$258/sq ft$198/sq ft$187/sq ft$218/sq ft$215/sq ft$288/sq ft$268/sq ft$267/sq ft$280/sq ft$258/sq ft$216/sq ft$301/sq ft$282/sq ft$254/sq ft$156/sq ft$262/sq ft$229/sq ft$144/sq ft$188/sq ft$249/sq ft$240/sq ft$315/sq ft$265/sq ft$227/sq ft$223/sq ft$322/sq ft$302/sq ft$244/sq ftmedian $254/sq ftThis home $191/sq ft

Priced at $191 per sq ft, below 29 of 30 recent sales (median $225).

Priced at $191 per sq ft, below 26 of 30 active competitors (median $254).

See these homes as a table
HomeStatusPriceSq ft$/sq ftMiles
1745 Pennan PlaceActive$789,9003,159$2500.3
1324 Fryston StreetActive$930,0003,064$3040.4
804 Stelling CourtActive$849,9003,297$2580.4
200 Huntston WayActive$613,0003,100$1980.5
221 Tollerton AvenueActive$479,9002,565$1870.8
127 Rockcreek DriveActive$749,9003,440$2180.9
101 Brianhead CourtActive$629,9992,935$2150.9
215 Carina TrailActive$750,0002,604$2880.9
2608 Pecan PlaceActive$689,0002,574$2681.0
174 Staplehurst DriveActive$855,0003,201$2671.0
448 Pine Haven DriveActive$749,0002,673$2801.1
383 Pine Haven DriveActive$929,0003,597$2581.1
4025 Lonicera LoopActive$559,0002,584$2161.1
240 Pine Haven DriveActive$994,0003,304$3011.2
121 Chatsworth DriveActive$910,0003,229$2821.2
123 Sugar Sand LaneActive$939,9003,703$2541.2
969 W Tennessee TraceActive$549,0003,523$1561.3
250 Shadow CoveActive$850,0003,245$2621.4
200 Ravensbury WayActive$740,0003,228$2291.4
1101 Roundtree CircleActive$505,0003,502$1441.4
116 Quail Creek CircleActive$675,0003,594$1881.4
103 Port AvenueActive$719,0002,887$2491.4
295 Willow Winds ParkwayActive$575,0002,394$2401.5
215 Freshwater DriveActive$850,0002,695$3151.5
245 Freshwater DriveActive$844,7003,182$2651.5
1925 Barham CourtActive$609,9252,685$2271.6
276 Ellsworth CircleActive$668,0002,993$2231.6
397 Lakeview Pass WayActive$1,449,0004,502$3221.6
790 Navigators RoadActive$765,2322,538$3021.6
315 Tierra CoveActive$1,074,9994,412$2441.6
1684 Fenton AvenueSold Sep 14, 2026$585,0002,909$2010.0
1629 Fenton AvenueSold Jul 17, 2026$875,0003,668$2390.2
1621 Fenton AvenueSold Apr 16, 2026$726,0004,323$1680.2
136 Dundee PlaceSold Jul 7, 2026$1,000,0003,922$2550.2
1216 Leith Hall DriveSold Jun 15, 2026$819,9004,257$1930.3
425 Buckhead CourtSold Apr 14, 2026$750,0003,380$2220.3
1908 Dumfries CourtSold Aug 4, 2026$945,0004,032$2340.4
1261 Leith Hall DriveSold Jun 18, 2026$885,0003,330$2660.5
1940 Dumfries CourtSold Apr 8, 2026$955,0003,319$2880.5
3220 Chestnut CourtSold Sep 25, 2026$660,0003,103$2130.7
137 Calliel WaySold Jun 5, 2026$825,0003,665$2250.8
160 Woodcross DriveSold Jul 24, 2026$789,0002,763$2860.8
321 Bent Creek DriveSold May 22, 2026$599,0002,796$2140.8
409 Starlis PlaceSold Sep 9, 2026$579,9002,400$2420.8
933 Bent Creek DriveSold Jun 24, 2026$720,0002,548$2830.9
184 Rockcreek DriveSold Jun 1, 2026$719,9003,281$2190.9
4085 Lonicera LoopSold Apr 30, 2026$603,0002,935$2050.9
156 Wellwood AvenueSold Aug 6, 2026$914,3004,285$2130.9
36 Delano StreetSold May 29, 2026$670,0003,111$2150.9
162 Carina TrailSold Jun 5, 2026$769,0002,952$2610.9
171 Wellwood AvenueSold Jul 1, 2026$1,275,0004,289$2970.9
2608 Pecan PlaceSold Jul 2, 2026$689,0002,574$2681.0
159 Rockcreek DriveSold Jun 26, 2026$775,0003,452$2251.0
27 Timber Stand RoadSold Sep 23, 2026$726,0003,289$2211.0
48 Pavia PlaceSold Apr 28, 2026$700,0003,008$2331.0
84 Pavia PlaceSold Jul 24, 2026$685,0002,763$2481.0
157 Longwood StreetSold Sep 17, 2026$583,0002,807$2081.0
102 Starlis PlaceSold Jun 5, 2026$615,0003,196$1921.0
237 Sparrow Branch CircleSold Jun 12, 2026$595,0002,732$2181.1
48 Lacaille AvenueSold Jul 31, 2026$660,0003,193$2071.1

Active listings from Momentum's hourly MLS refresh (all brokerages); sold prices are MLS closed-sale records. Hover or tap a dot for the address. Context only — not an appraisal or valuation. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Pricing position

Price per square foot vs. comparable sales

$191this home, per sq ft
$234median of 6 comparable sales in Durbin Crossing
2 of 6comparable sales priced below this home per sq ft

Comparable sales: same property type, living area within 30%, closed within 18 months, in Durbin Crossing. Stronger local evidence. Context, not a valuation.

Next step

Talk to the listing agent

Heather Strazinsky lists this home. Questions, showings, or a full comparative market analysis for your own home start here.

Request a showingCall (904) 351-6461
More reports

Other Momentum listing reports nearby

Homes for sale in St. Johns · St. Johns housing market · St. Johns County homes for sale · All Momentum listings