All Homes for Sale in Sugarloaf Key, FL

Every home for sale in Sugarloaf Key, FL from the live MLS: 21 listings, newest first, 21 per page, 1 pages. Back to the Sugarloaf Key homes for sale hub for prices by ZIP, property type and community.

1. 1041 Buttonwood Drive · $9,970,000 · 6 bd/6.5 ba
2. 265 S Point Drive · $2,549,000 · 4 bd/3 ba
3. 17162 W Starfish Lane · $6,400,000 · 5 bd/5 ba
4. 17155 W Hibiscus Lane · $949,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
5. 17015 W Wahoo Lane · $3,999,999 · 3 bd/3 ba
6. 17050 Old State Road #4A · $949,000 · 2 bd/2 ba
7. 1481 Sugarloaf Boulevard · $1,650,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
8. 1151 Sugarloaf Boulevard · $1,499,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
9. 19590 Tequesta Street · $739,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
10. 19421 Canal Drive · $699,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
11. 182 Venetian Way · $1,595,000 · 3 bd/3 ba
12. 19543 Navajo Street · $749,900 · 3 bd/2 ba
13. 17041 Marlin Drive · $2,849,000 · 3 bd/2 ba · Pending
14. 17286 Jamaica Lane · $1,200,000 · 2 bd/2 ba
15. 937 Loggerhead Lane · $799,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
16. 83 Sugarloaf Drive · $998,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
17. 19267 Hansen Trail · $899,000 · 3 bd/2 ba
18. 17183 Coral Drive · $3,199,000 · 4 bd/3.5 ba
19. 17013 Coral Drive · $5,200,000 · 4 bd/3.5 ba
20. 15760 Old State Road 4A · $19,750,000 · 6 bd/6.5 ba
21. 16750 Old State Road 4A · $8,995,000 · 6 bd/4.5 ba

Updated November 12, 2026. Listing data from the MLS, deemed reliable but not guaranteed.