St. Johns County and Amendment 3: What It Means for the County Budget

By Jon Brooks, Co-Founder, Momentum Realty · Last updated Nov 19, 2026 · Method and sources · Corrections

St. Johns County at a glance

Bottom line: after Amendment 3, St. Johns County is in the middle among Florida's 67 counties for financial strength. It is estimated to take in $136.1M less each year by 2028-29, about 17 cents of every dollar it takes in today.

New taxes or fees on the table here

1 proposal to raise new money has come up since Amendment 3 was put on the ballot. The first words of each line say how far it has gone.

  • Workshop; staff study, no vote. Local option gas tax, a sales surtax and higher fees for some services listed as options to study; staff to check whether tourist tax can pay for eligible services. County Administrator Joy Andrews, Nov 17, 2026. What state law requires: Fuel tax: board vote within statutory caps (s.336.025); sales surtax: referendum (s.212.055) held at a general election; fees: allowed if tied to the cost of the service. Source: News (St. Johns Citizen); agenda item 8, Nov 17, 2026
Financial health after Amendment 348.3 of 100Middle Rank 31 of 67 (1 is strongest)
  • Before Amendment 3: 69.2, rank 10 (strongest fifth)
  • Change: down 20.9 points
  • Management measures: 87.3, rank 10 of 67
Details and sources
Revenue the county is estimated to lose$136.1M a year by 2028-29About 17 cents of every dollar the county takes in
  • First year, FY2027-28: $68.3M
  • Range across the two estimates, FY2028-29: $109.4M to $136.1M
  • Per resident: $391
Details and sources
Why the score is what it isStrengths and weak spots
  • Strength Debt repaid from taxes, per resident: $0
  • Strength Property value per resident: $170K
  • Weak spot How much the budget leans on property tax: 41.3%
  • Weak spot Spending growth per resident, after inflation: 12.9%

Data check: the state filing shows $0 of tax-supported debt; the county audit shows $231.2M of governmental bonds and notes. The score uses the state filing, as for every county.

Details and sources
Why the budget grew$376.8M to $653.8MFY2014-15 to FY2023-24, up 74%
  • From more people: $208.0M
  • From inflation: $189.2M
  • Leaving out a one-time 2015 bond refinancing: $59.3M more than extra people and inflation explain. The state file, with the refinancing in, shows $120.2M less
  • Biggest drivers: Parks and recreation, Roads and streets, Other public safety (inspections, medical examiner, other)
  • Look closer 3 areas with no explanation yet: Economic environment, Culture and recreation, Roads and streets
Details and sources
Where to look for savings$64.8M a year, largest item
  • Parks, libraries, culture: $64.8M a year
  • General government and admin: $9.4M a year
  • Economic development and housing: $6.6M a year

Places to review, not findings that money was misspent. Items can overlap.

Details and sources
Spending above similar counties (200K-500K residents)3 areas
  • Parks, libraries, culture: 3.4x the median ($262 vs $76 per resident)
  • General government and admin: 1.8x the median ($60 vs $33 per resident)
  • Economic development and housing: 1.4x the median ($70 vs $51 per resident)

1 of 17 review rules applies to this county.

Details and sources
Sections

In brief: St. Johns County and Amendment 3

Amendment 3 (CS/HJR 1-F) was adopted by voters Nov 3, 2026 with 61.98% Yes (4,922,977 Yes to 3,020,085 No; 60% required), according to the Florida Division of Elections. It takes effect Jan 1, 2027. Source: Florida Division of Elections.

State economists (EDR, July 10, 2026) estimate that St. Johns County government collects $68.3M less property tax in FY2027-28 and $136.1M less in FY2028-29 at current tax rates. The Florida Association of Counties (June 2026) estimates $58.2M and $109.4M. The FY2028-29 range is $109.4M to $136.1M, or 17.3% of FY2023-24 operating revenue on the EDR figure. The financial health score is 69.2 of 100 before Amendment 3 (rank 10 of 67) and 48.3 after on the EDR estimate (rank 31). Rank 1 is the highest score.

Review level: County-source cross-check. Population 348,336 (April 1, 2025, Florida EDR/BEBR, April 1, 2025 population estimates by county).

For what Amendment 3 changes on a homeowner's own bill, see what Amendment 3 saves a St. Johns homeowner.

St. Johns County money map

Property tax brings in $325.2M of the $788.3M the county takes in each year. That is the part Amendment 3 shrinks. Press play to watch the gap open.

Shortfall, today$0

No change yet. Amendment 3 takes effect Jan 1, 2027. Pick a year or press play.

County debt$561.0M

Equal to 71% of one year of operating revenue ($788.3M, FY2023-24); $1,611 per resident. Total debt on Sept 30, 2025, audited (ACFR ten-year schedule).

St. Johns County today: where the money comes from and where it goes
Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $325.2M (41%). 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $325.2M. 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M (15%). FY2023-24Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M. FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M (6%). FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M. FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M (6%). FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M. FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M (5%). FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M. FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M (4%). FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M. FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M (3%). FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M. FY2023-24Other operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M (19%). Operating revenue minus the sources listedOther operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M. Operating revenue minus the sources listedPublic safety: $255.2M (42%). FY2023-24Public safety: $255.2M. FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M (17%). FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M. FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M (18%). FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M. FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M (4%). FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M. FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M (4%). FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M. FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M (15%). FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M. FY2023-24Operating revenue FY2023-24: $788.3M$788.3MProperty tax $325.2MUtility charges $120.0MImpact fees $49.7MState grants $48.1MFederal grants $39.9MHalf-cent sales tax $30.5MTourist development tax $23.2MOther operating revenue $151.6M$255.2M Public safety$104.7M Physical environment$112.3M Transportation$24.5M Economic environment$22.1M Human services$91.1M Culture and recreation

Center: Operating revenue FY2023-24, $788.3M (Florida EDR, county revenues and expenditures from Annual Financial Reports (LGFR), FY2005-06 to FY2023-24). Left: the largest revenue sources; the remainder is everything else in operating revenue. Right: spending by function, all funds, FY2023-24 (Florida EDR, 2025 Local Government Financial Reporting data set with metrics (counties)); it includes fee-funded services, so it can be larger than operating revenue. Widths use one dollar scale.

St. Johns County with the FY2027-28 Amendment 3 estimate applied
Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $256.9M (36%). 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $256.9M. 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M (17%). FY2023-24Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M. FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M (7%). FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M. FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M (7%). FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M. FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M (6%). FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M. FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M (4%). FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M. FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M (3%). FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M. FY2023-24Other operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M (21%). Operating revenue minus the sources listedOther operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M. Operating revenue minus the sources listedPublic safety: $255.2M (42%). FY2023-24Public safety: $255.2M. FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M (17%). FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M. FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M (18%). FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M. FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M (4%). FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M. FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M (4%). FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M. FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M (15%). FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M. FY2023-24Operating revenue after the estimated change: $720.0M$720.0MProperty tax $256.9MUtility charges $120.0MImpact fees $49.7MState grants $48.1MFederal grants $39.9MHalf-cent sales tax $30.5MTourist development tax $23.2MOther operating revenue $151.6M$255.2M Public safety$104.7M Physical environment$112.3M Transportation$24.5M Economic environment$22.1M Human services$91.1M Culture and recreationShortfall FY2027-28: $68.3MShortfall FY2027-28 $68.3M

Illustration, not a forecast. Today's budget (FY2023-24) with the state estimate for FY2027-28 taken out of property tax: $68.3M (Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026)). Tax rates, other revenue and spending are held at today's levels; growth in the tax base is not modeled. The dashed block is the shortfall the county would have to close with cuts, reserves, other revenue or a higher rate.

St. Johns County with the FY2028-29 Amendment 3 estimate applied
Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $189.1M (29%). 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $189.1M. 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M (18%). FY2023-24Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M. FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M (8%). FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M. FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M (7%). FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M. FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M (6%). FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M. FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M (5%). FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M. FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M (4%). FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M. FY2023-24Other operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M (23%). Operating revenue minus the sources listedOther operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M. Operating revenue minus the sources listedPublic safety: $255.2M (42%). FY2023-24Public safety: $255.2M. FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M (17%). FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M. FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M (18%). FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M. FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M (4%). FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M. FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M (4%). FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M. FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M (15%). FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M. FY2023-24Operating revenue after the estimated change: $652.2M$652.2MProperty tax $189.1MUtility charges $120.0MImpact fees $49.7MState grants $48.1MFederal grants $39.9MHalf-cent sales tax $30.5MTourist development tax $23.2MOther operating revenue $151.6M$255.2M Public safety$104.7M Physical environment$112.3M Transportation$24.5M Economic environment$22.1M Human services$91.1M Culture and recreationShortfall FY2028-29: $136.1MShortfall FY2028-29 $136.1M

Illustration, not a forecast. Today's budget (FY2023-24) with the state estimate for FY2028-29 taken out of property tax: $136.1M (Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026)). Tax rates, other revenue and spending are held at today's levels; growth in the tax base is not modeled. The dashed block is the shortfall the county would have to close with cuts, reserves, other revenue or a higher rate.

St. Johns County with the FY2029-30 Amendment 3 estimate applied
Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $172.7M (27%). 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll): $172.7M. 2023 roll (FY2023-24)Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M (19%). FY2023-24Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste): $120.0M. FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M (8%). FY2023-24Impact fees: $49.7M. FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M (8%). FY2023-24State grants: $48.1M. FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M (6%). FY2023-24Federal grants: $39.9M. FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M (5%). FY2023-24Half-cent sales tax (state-shared): $30.5M. FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M (4%). FY2023-24Tourist development tax: $23.2M. FY2023-24Other operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M (24%). Operating revenue minus the sources listedOther operating revenue (remainder): $151.6M. Operating revenue minus the sources listedPublic safety: $255.2M (42%). FY2023-24Public safety: $255.2M. FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M (17%). FY2023-24Physical environment: $104.7M. FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M (18%). FY2023-24Transportation: $112.3M. FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M (4%). FY2023-24Economic environment: $24.5M. FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M (4%). FY2023-24Human services: $22.1M. FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M (15%). FY2023-24Culture and recreation: $91.1M. FY2023-24Operating revenue after the estimated change: $635.8M$635.8MProperty tax $172.7MUtility charges $120.0MImpact fees $49.7MState grants $48.1MFederal grants $39.9MHalf-cent sales tax $30.5MTourist development tax $23.2MOther operating revenue $151.6M$255.2M Public safety$104.7M Physical environment$112.3M Transportation$24.5M Economic environment$22.1M Human services$91.1M Culture and recreationShortfall FY2029-30: $152.5MShortfall FY2029-30 $152.5M

Illustration, not a forecast. Today's budget (FY2023-24) with the state estimate for FY2029-30 taken out of property tax: $152.5M (Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026)). Tax rates, other revenue and spending are held at today's levels; growth in the tax base is not modeled. The dashed block is the shortfall the county would have to close with cuts, reserves, other revenue or a higher rate.

Shortfall by year

Show the numbers in a table
Fiscal yearShortfall (state EDR estimate)Share of today's operating revenueFAC estimateOperating revenue left, all else equal
FY2027-28$68.3M8.7%$58.2M$720.0M
FY2028-29$136.1M17.3%$109.4M$652.2M
FY2029-30$152.5M19.3%no FAC estimate for this year$635.8M
FY2030-31$171.2M21.7%no FAC estimate for this year$617.2M
FY2031-32$191.6M24.3%no FAC estimate for this year$596.7M
Shortfall by year, St. Johns County government (state EDR estimate)

It grows from $68.3M in FY2027-28 to $191.6M in FY2031-32.

$0$50M$100M$150M$200MFY2027-28: $68.3M$68.3MFY2027-28FY2028-29: $136.1M$136.1MFY2028-29FY2029-30: $152.5M$152.5MFY2029-30FY2030-31: $171.2M$171.2MFY2030-31FY2031-32: $191.6M$191.6MFY2031-32

At current tax rates. Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026). FAC: Florida Association of Counties, Fiscal Impact Readers Guide and Backgrounder (June 2026).

Where the money comes from

  • Property tax (county levies, 2023 roll)$325.2M
    2023 roll (FY2023-24)
  • Utility charges (water, sewer, solid waste)$120.0M
    FY2023-24
  • Impact fees$49.7M
    FY2023-24
  • State grants$48.1M
    FY2023-24
  • Federal grants$39.9M
    FY2023-24
  • Half-cent sales tax (state-shared)$30.5M
    FY2023-24
  • Tourist development tax$23.2M
    FY2023-24
  • Other operating revenue (remainder)$151.6M
    Operating revenue minus the sources listed

Where the money goes

  • Public safety$255.2M
    FY2023-24
  • Physical environment$104.7M
    FY2023-24
  • Transportation$112.3M
    FY2023-24
  • Economic environment$24.5M
    FY2023-24
  • Human services$22.1M
    FY2023-24
  • Culture and recreation$91.1M
    FY2023-24

Strengths on the books

Pressures

Financial health score: before and after Amendment 3

A report card from 0 to 100 that compares St. Johns with the other 66 counties on seven money measures. Higher is stronger. St. Johns scores 69.2 today and 48.3 after Amendment 3.

Before Amendment 369.2rank 10 of 67Strongest fifth
After, state estimate48.3rank 31 of 67Middle
After, counties' association estimate53.8rank 21 of 67Above average
Management measures87.3rank 10 of 67
Health score before Amendment 3: St. Johns among all 67 counties

56 of the other 66 counties score lower than St. Johns. 10 score the same or higher.

Alachua: 52.3Baker: 57.1Bay: 57.9Bradford: 49.5Brevard: 79.7Broward: 60.4Calhoun: 69.2Charlotte: 67.5Citrus: 61.5Clay: 46.9Collier: 57.2Columbia: 65.0DeSoto: 56.9Dixie: 47.2Duval: 43.6Escambia: 58.8Flagler: 59.6Franklin: 63.1Gadsden: 52.3Gilchrist: 48.9Glades: 60.0Gulf: 54.8Hamilton: 53.8Hardee: 55.0Hendry: 62.0Hernando: 57.2Highlands: 52.2Hillsborough: 67.0Holmes: 63.2Indian River: 67.2Jackson: 57.8Jefferson: 53.2Lafayette: 52.7Lake: 74.3Lee: 70.0Leon: 58.0Levy: 60.2Liberty: 46.5Madison: 51.8Manatee: 52.2Marion: 61.9Martin: 50.1Miami-Dade: 59.9Monroe: 64.5Nassau: 53.8Okaloosa: 66.7Okeechobee: 44.3Orange: 70.4Osceola: 65.3Palm Beach: 58.2Pasco: 44.9Pinellas: 74.7Polk: 67.8Putnam: 54.4Santa Rosa: 66.7Sarasota: 69.2Seminole: 68.7St. Lucie: 71.4Sumter: 69.2Suwannee: 65.8Taylor: 67.7Union: 60.4Volusia: 74.2Wakulla: 53.9Walton: 68.9Washington: 52.7median 59.9St. Johns 69.243.679.7

One mark per county; the gold mark is this county. Hover or tap a mark for the county name.

Health score after Amendment 3 (EDR estimate): St. Johns among all 67 counties

36 of the other 66 counties score lower than St. Johns. 30 score the same or higher.

Alachua: 32.0Baker: 43.9Bay: 49.9Bradford: 36.4Brevard: 64.2Broward: 50.4Calhoun: 62.9Charlotte: 55.5Citrus: 43.7Clay: 24.6Collier: 52.1Columbia: 53.0DeSoto: 47.2Dixie: 41.7Duval: 30.8Escambia: 44.5Flagler: 32.4Franklin: 59.5Gadsden: 42.5Gilchrist: 33.9Glades: 49.1Gulf: 49.6Hamilton: 46.5Hardee: 48.1Hendry: 49.7Hernando: 38.0Highlands: 38.1Hillsborough: 46.9Holmes: 50.6Indian River: 53.4Jackson: 50.1Jefferson: 40.7Lafayette: 48.5Lake: 48.1Lee: 59.7Leon: 40.1Levy: 48.7Liberty: 43.0Madison: 43.8Manatee: 39.9Marion: 38.7Martin: 34.4Miami-Dade: 52.5Monroe: 61.9Nassau: 31.6Okaloosa: 58.7Okeechobee: 33.1Orange: 60.9Osceola: 47.9Palm Beach: 46.6Pasco: 23.2Pinellas: 60.7Polk: 50.5Putnam: 44.1Santa Rosa: 45.6Sarasota: 62.7Seminole: 46.3St. Lucie: 49.9Sumter: 39.7Suwannee: 55.5Taylor: 58.9Union: 55.4Volusia: 52.4Wakulla: 40.5Walton: 63.5Washington: 44.0median 47.9St. Johns 48.323.264.2

One mark per county; the gold mark is this county. Hover or tap a mark for the county name.

Points on each measure, before and after Amendment 3

The biggest drop after Amendment 3 is in room left to raise the tax rate: from 74 points to 14.

BeforeAfter (EDR estimate)
0255075100debt repaid from taxes, per residentweight 15debt repaid from taxes, per resident before: 90.0 pointsdebt repaid from taxes, per resident after: 90.0 points90 / 90pension debt per residentweight 15pension debt per resident before: 47.0 pointspension debt per resident after: 47.0 points47 / 47spending growth per resident, after inflweight 15spending growth per resident, after inflation before: 47.0 pointsspending growth per resident, after inflation after: 47.0 points47 / 47how much the budget leans on property taweight 10how much the budget leans on property tax before: 19.7 pointshow much the budget leans on property tax after: 19.7 points20 / 20property value per residentweight 15property value per resident before: 81.8 pointsproperty value per resident after: 59.1 points82 / 59room left to raise the tax rateweight 10room left to raise the tax rate before: 73.8 pointsroom left to raise the tax rate after: 13.8 points74 / 14revenue lost to Amendment 3weight 20revenue lost to Amendment 3 before: 100.0 pointsrevenue lost to Amendment 3 after: 42.5 points100 / 42

Each measure is scored 0 to 100 against the other counties; the health score is the weighted average. The table below has the values behind the points.

Health score history, St. Johns County

Health score was 76 in 2024-25, up 10 points from 66 in 2014-15.

0255075100FY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Health score, FY14-15: 66.5 (partial inputs)Health score, FY15-16: 66.6 (partial inputs)Health score, FY16-17: 65.9 (partial inputs)Health score, FY17-18: 63.3 (partial inputs)Health score, FY18-19: 61.8Health score, FY19-20: 66.1Health score, FY20-21: 67.5Health score, FY21-22: 68.4Health score, FY22-23: 65.3Health score, FY23-24: 64.8Health score, FY24-25: 76.5Health score

Derived; same percentile method and weights each year, recomputed against all counties with data that year. Hollow points mark years with partial inputs. The yearly series leaves out pension (no consistent yearly data) and treats the Amendment 3 measure as 100, so it is not on the same scale as the current score above.

View as table
Fiscal yearHealth score
FY14-1566.5*
FY15-1666.6*
FY16-1765.9*
FY17-1863.3*
FY18-1961.8
FY19-2066.1
FY20-2167.5
FY21-2268.4
FY22-2365.3
FY23-2464.8
FY24-2576.5

* partial inputs for that year.

Show how the score is worked out

How the score is worked out

The score compares St. Johns with the other 66 counties on seven measures. Higher is stronger. The same method and thresholds apply to every county. Full method.

MeasureWeightValue beforePoints beforeValue afterPoints after
Tax-supported debt per resident (GO + special revenue debt, Sept 30, 2025)15$090.0$090.0
Pension liability per resident (net pension liability, 2025)15$74547.0$74547.0
Growth in inflation-adjusted core spending per resident (3-yr avg FY2015-17 vs FY2022-24)1512.9%47.012.9%47.0
Reliance on property tax (2023 county levy / FY2023-24 operating revenue)1041.3%19.741.3%19.7
Tax base per resident (2025 taxable value / 2025 population); after A3: reduced by the share of the levy lost15$170K81.8$112K59.1
Room under the 10-mill county operating cap (2025); after A3: minus the mills needed to replace the FY2028-29 loss104.673.81.213.8
Amendment 3 loss in FY2028-29 as a share of FY2023-24 operating revenue: 0% = 100 points, 30% or more = 0 points (before A3 every county scores 100)200.0%100.017.3%42.5

Management measures

A separate score from the health score; wealth and Amendment 3 exposure do not drive it; strongest/weakest on these measures only, not an overall judgment.

MeasureSt. Johns
Latest audit filed on timeYes
No material weakness in the latest auditYes
No finding repeated in three straight auditsYes
General fund unrestricted balance, % of spending42.9%
General fund balance change, latest year18.1%
Real core spending growth per resident13%
Tax-supported debt per resident$0
Pension liability per resident$745

Coverage 100% of measures. Sources: Auditor General audit filings, county audits, EDR county data set (Sept 30, 2025), FRS (June 30, 2025).

Estimated property-tax revenue change

By budget year 2028-29 the county is estimated to take in $109.4M to $136.1M less each year. The lower and higher numbers come from two different groups that did the math.

The state's estimate, year by year: St. Johns County government

It grows from $68.3M in FY27-28 to $191.6M in FY31-32.

$0$50M$100M$150M$200MFY27-28: $68.3M$68.3MFY27-28FY28-29: $136.1M$136.1MFY28-29FY29-30: $152.5M$152.5MFY29-30FY30-31: $171.2M$171.2MFY30-31FY31-32: $191.6M$191.6MFY31-32

Property-tax revenue the county government is estimated to collect less of, at current tax rates. Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026).

Out of every dollar St. Johns County takes in

Picture every dollar the county takes in as 100 pennies. Amendment 3 takes away about 17 of them.

Each coin is one cent of FY2023-24 operating revenue; the crossed-out coins are the state's estimate for 2028-29. Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026); Florida EDR, county revenues and expenditures from Annual Financial Reports (LGFR), FY2005-06 to FY2023-24.

Share of yearly revenue lost by 2028-29 (state estimate): St. Johns among all 67 counties

St. Johns loses a bigger share than 55 of the other 66 counties.

Alachua: 19.6%Baker: 10.2%Bay: 7.5%Bradford: 16.6%Brevard: 12.0%Broward: 9.4%Calhoun: 7.1%Charlotte: 8.1%Citrus: 16.0%Clay: 17.9%Collier: 6.5%Columbia: 9.9%DeSoto: 5.6%Dixie: 5.7%Duval: 12.1%Escambia: 9.5%Flagler: 27.5%Franklin: 3.9%Gadsden: 11.5%Gilchrist: 15.4%Glades: 10.5%Gulf: 5.2%Hamilton: 4.5%Hardee: 4.6%Hendry: 7.2%Hernando: 15.0%Highlands: 11.8%Hillsborough: 13.9%Holmes: 17.4%Indian River: 12.7%Jackson: 6.1%Jefferson: 9.4%Lafayette: 5.6%Lake: 20.8%Lee: 9.4%Leon: 17.8%Levy: 11.9%Liberty: 3.5%Madison: 6.8%Manatee: 9.9%Marion: 16.6%Martin: 15.2%Miami-Dade: 5.2%Monroe: 3.8%Nassau: 20.8%Okaloosa: 6.7%Okeechobee: 8.0%Orange: 8.9%Osceola: 11.9%Palm Beach: 13.0%Pasco: 18.4%Pinellas: 11.9%Polk: 12.8%Putnam: 8.8%Santa Rosa: 16.3%Sarasota: 7.3%Seminole: 16.7%St. Lucie: 18.5%Sumter: 25.0%Suwannee: 10.0%Taylor: 5.8%Union: 7.2%Volusia: 18.3%Wakulla: 11.6%Walton: 7.2%Washington: 7.6%median 10.2%St. Johns 17.3%3.5%27.5%

One mark per county; the gold mark is this county. Hover or tap a mark for the county name.

Show the detailed estimates, side by side

The three estimates below come from different sources and are shown side by side. They are not merged.

The state's estimate (EDR)

Fiscal yearCounty government
2026-27$0
2027-28$68.3M
2028-29$136.1M
2029-30$152.5M
2030-31$171.2M
2031-32$191.6M

County government levies, including MSTUs and dependent districts, at current tax rates. All local governments in the county, FY2028-29: $151.3M. Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026).

The counties' association estimate (FAC)

ComponentFY2027-28FY2028-29
Homestead exemption$54.9M$102.6M
Non-homestead cap$3.3M$6.8M
Total$58.2M$109.4M

Florida Association of Counties, Fiscal Impact Readers Guide and Backgrounder (June 2026).

The county's own figure

$68.3M (FY2028), $136.1M (FY2029) and $191.6M by FY2032, about 45% of FY2027 property tax (county projection presented Nov 17, 2026, as reported by St. Johns Citizen) Source.

How much the tax rate would have to rise to make it up

MeasureValue
Share of county property tax lost by 2028-29 (state estimate)34.0%
Loss per resident by 2028-29 (state estimate)$391
Tax-rate increase needed to replace it3.5 mills
Room left under the state's 10-mill limit (2025)4.6 mills

Levy and millage: Florida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Data Book: Millage Rates and Taxes Levied, 2025. School taxes are not affected by Amendment 3.

In plain words

The state's economists expect St. Johns County to collect $68.3M less property tax in 2027-28 and $136.1M less in 2028-29, if tax rates stay the same. That is about 34 cents of every dollar of county property tax. The counties' association did its own math and got $58.2M and $109.4M. School taxes do not change. Homeowners keep that money. The typical homesteaded owner here saves about $1,529 a year in 2028. To make up the loss by raising the tax rate, the county would need about 3.5 more mills. It has 4.6 mills of room under the state limit.

The same, in the data team's technical wording

State economists (EDR, July 10, 2026) estimate the county government's levies, including MSTUs and dependent districts, collect $68.3M less in FY2027-28 and $136.1M less in FY2028-29 at current tax rates. That is 34% of the 2025 county levy and 17.3% of FY2023-24 operating revenue. The Florida Association of Counties' separate estimate is $58.2M and $109.4M, so the FY2028-29 range is $109.4M to $136.1M. Across all local governments in the county (county, cities and independent districts) EDR estimates $151.3M in FY2028-29. School taxes are not affected. The same dollars stay with property owners. The StepUp model puts the median homestead's non-school tax saving at $1,529 in 2028 (middle half $1,336 to $1,529) across 96,532 homesteads, and about 31% of homesteads would owe no non-school property tax in 2028 at 2025 rates. For scale: replacing the FY2028-29 amount through the county operating rate alone would take about 3.49 more mills on the smaller tax base, which would stay within the 10-mill cap.

The homeowner side: a typical homestead bill

The other side of the same change: the typical homesteaded owner here pays about $1,529 less a year in 2028.

The same dollars that leave the county budget stay with property owners.

What a typical homesteaded owner saves each year, St. Johns County

It grows from $759 in 2027 to $1,529 in 2028.

$0$500$1K$1.5K$2K2027: $759$75920272028: $1,529$1,5292028

Median saving on non-school property tax, at 2025 tax rates. Half of owners save between $1,336 and $1,529 in 2028. StepUp Law, Florida Amendment 3 homestead database (third-party model on 2026 preliminary rolls and 2025 millage).

Show the numbers in a table
MeasureValue
Homestead parcels96,532
Median assessed value$330K
Median non-school tax saving, 2027$759
Median non-school tax saving, 2028$1,529
Middle half of homesteads, 2028$1,336 to $1,529
Homesteads owing no non-school tax in 202830.7%
Non-school millage, 20257.7 mills

Modeled at 2025 tax rates. StepUp Law, Florida Amendment 3 homestead database (third-party model on 2026 preliminary rolls and 2025 millage).

Where each $1 of St. Johns County spending goes

The biggest share, 42 cents of each dollar, goes to public safety.

Cents of each dollar, St. Johns County, FY2023-24
Public safety: 42 cents of each dollarPublic safety42¢Transportation: 18 cents of each dollarTransportation18¢Parks, libraries, culture: 15 cents of each dollarParks, libraries, culture15¢Debt service: 6 cents of each dollarDebt service6¢Environment (solid waste, conservation, stormwater): 6 cents of each dollarEnvironment (solid waste, conservation, stor6¢Health and human services: 4 cents of each dollarHealth and human services4¢All other areas: 10 cents of each dollarAll other areas10¢$1.00of spending

The six largest areas and everything else. The full list of ten areas is below.

  • Public safety42 cents
  • Transportation18 cents
  • Parks, libraries, culture15 cents
  • Debt service6 cents
  • Environment (solid waste, conservation, stormwater)6 cents
  • Health and human services4 cents
  • General government and admin4 cents
  • Economic development and housing4 cents
  • Courts2 cents
  • Pensions paid directly0 cents

Cents per dollar of $608.1M in operating spending, FY2023-24, state annual financial report (Florida EDR, county revenues and expenditures from Annual Financial Reports (LGFR), FY2005-06 to FY2023-24). Excluded: accounts 513 (financial and administrative) and 519 (other general government), because counties code tax collector, clerk and other pass-through money to one or the other (e.g., Sarasota reports $1.9B in 519, Alachua $758M in 513), interfund transfers and other non-operating uses (58x-59x), and fee-funded utilities, airports, ports and parking (531-533, 535-536, 542-543, 545). After an audit check, Sumter account 512 ($513.8M vs $30.0M of audited general-government spending, FY2025) and Columbia account 511 ($87.8M vs $15.0M) are also excluded as coding or pass-through amounts.

How the St. Johns County budget has changed since FY2014-15

Spending rose 74% in nine years. More residents and inflation explain $397.2M of it. Spending actually grew $120.2M less than those two would explain.

Population, inflation and real growth

From FY2014-15 spending to FY2023-24 spending, St. Johns County
$0$200M$400M$600M$800MFY2014-15 spending: $376.8M$376.8MFY2014-15spendingMore people: $208.0M+$208.0MMorepeopleInflation: $189.2M+$189.2MInflationGrowth beyond both: -$120.2M-$120.2MGrowth beyondbothFY2023-24 spending: $653.8M$653.8MFY2023-24spending

White columns are total spending; colored columns are the change from each cause (orange is a decrease).

Population 213,566 (FY2014-15) to 331,479 (FY2023-24). Real change per resident: -15.5%. Inflation: CPI-U. Source: state annual financial reports via EDR (Florida EDR, 2025 Local Government Financial Reporting data set with metrics (counties)). A data check applies to these figures; see the note below.

Data check, done. The high FY2014-15 figure was a one-time bond refunding, not regular spending. The county's ten-year schedule shows ordinary debt service of $17.7M in FY2015 (principal $9,267,834, interest $8,466,488), an $86,204,222 payment to a refunding escrow agent and $1,066,394 of issuance costs. Together those equal the $105.0M in the state file. FY2014-15 debt service in the state file was $105.0M, far above FY2023-24 ($36.2M). That one line pulls the county total down. Leaving debt service out, the other areas together changed $59.3M beyond population and inflation. Source: St. Johns County Clerk, FY2024 statistical section, Schedule 4.

What stands out and should be looked at

3 areas grew much faster than more people and inflation explain, with no explanation gathered yet. That does not prove the money was misspent. It marks where to ask questions first.

Extra spending by area beyond more people and inflation, St. Johns County

The biggest: parks and recreation, at $54.0M.

Parks and recreationParks and recreation: $54.0M$54.0MEconomic environmentEconomic environment: $31.3M$31.3MCulture and recreationCulture and recreation: $24.8M$24.8MRoads and streetsRoads and streets: $22.1M$22.1MOther public safety (inspections, medicaOther public safety (inspections, medical examiner, other): $18.1M$18.1M

Dollars per year, FY2023-24 compared with FY2014-15. Top drivers are measured against more people and inflation; other areas against a review line of 25% growth per resident after inflation. State annual financial reports.

  • Parks and recreationMay be a bookkeeping change
    $54.0M a year more than extra people and inflation explainA top driver of the growth

    The state file may have moved this spending between accounts; check the county audit before reading it as growth.

  • Economic environmentNeeds a closer look
    $31.3M a year above the review line (25% growth per resident after inflation)Up 321% per resident after inflation

    No explanation has been gathered from county budget documents yet.

  • Culture and recreationNeeds a closer look
    $24.8M a year above the review line (25% growth per resident after inflation)Up 63% per resident after inflation

    No explanation has been gathered from county budget documents yet.

  • Roads and streetsNeeds a closer look
    $22.1M a year more than extra people and inflation explainA top driver of the growth

    No explanation has been gathered from county budget documents yet.

  • Other public safety (inspections, medical examiner, other)May be a bookkeeping change
    $18.1M a year more than extra people and inflation explainA top driver of the growth

    The state file may have moved this spending between accounts; check the county audit before reading it as growth.

Top drivers

AreaAbove population and inflationCoding check
Parks and recreation$54.0MYes
Roads and streets$22.1M
Other public safety (inspections, medical examiner, other)$18.1MYes

Spending by area

Change beyond population and inflation by area, St. Johns County

The area that grew the most beyond more people and inflation: culture and recreation, at $33.1M.

Culture and recreationCulture and recreation: $33.1M$33.1MTransportationTransportation: $29.9M$29.9MPublic safetyPublic safety: $23.2M$23.2MEconomic development, housing and veteraEconomic development, housing and veterans: $13.4M$13.4MPensions paid directlyPensions paid directly: $0$0Legal, planning and ITLegal, planning and IT: -$3.5M-$3.5MHealth and human servicesHealth and human services: -$13.4M-$13.4MUtilities and environment (mostly fee-fuUtilities and environment (mostly fee-funded): -$23.3M-$23.3MDebt serviceDebt service: -$179.5M-$179.5M

FY2014-15 to FY2023-24. Blue areas grew more than extra people and inflation explain; orange areas grew less.

Show the numbers in a table
AreaFY2014-15FY2023-24Above population and inflation
Public safety$112.9M$255.2M$23.2M
Utilities and environment (mostly fee-funded)$62.3M$104.7M-$23.3M
Transportation$40.1M$112.3M$29.9M
Economic development, housing and veterans$5.4M$24.5M$13.4M
Health and human services$17.3M$22.1M-$13.4M
Culture and recreation$28.3M$91.1M$33.1M
Debt service$105.0M$36.2M-$179.5M
Pensions paid directly$0$0$0
Legal, planning and IT$5.5M$7.7M-$3.5M

What county budget documents and audits say about these drivers

Still being researched for this county.

Spending to review

The largest place to look is parks, libraries, culture, at $64.8M a year. These are places to review, not proof that money was misspent.

Each item is worth a closer look, not a finding. Items can overlap and must not be added together.

Spending to review, dollars per year, St. Johns County

The largest place to look: parks, libraries, culture, at $64.8M.

Parks, libraries, cultureParks, libraries, culture: $64.8M$64.8MGeneral government and adminGeneral government and admin: $9.4M$9.4MEconomic development and housingEconomic development and housing: $6.6M$6.6MBusiness tax breaks (job results not yetBusiness tax breaks (job results not yet reviewed): $539K$539K

The ten largest items. Reasons and evidence are in the table.

Item$ per yearWhy it is listedEvidence
Parks, libraries, culture: spending above similar counties$64.8M$262 per resident vs $76 median for counties of 200K-500K people (3.4x), FY2023-24 annual financial reportPeer comparison
General government and admin: spending above similar counties$9.4M$60 per resident vs $33 median for counties of 200K-500K people (1.8x), FY2023-24 annual financial reportPeer comparison
Economic development and housing: spending above similar counties$6.6M$70 per resident vs $51 median for counties of 200K-500K people (1.4x), FY2023-24 annual financial reportPeer comparison
Business tax breaks (job results not yet reviewed)$539K$539,465 in FY2025: reimbursements of property tax, impact and utility fees to 7 businesses; 12 active agreements, paid only after growth or job criteria are metIncentives: low or unproven return
Review item R17: State filing differs materially from the auditnot availableState filing shows $0 tax-supported debt at Sept 30, 2025 ($70.0M in 2024); the FY2025 audit shows $231.2M of governmental revenue bonds and notes, plus $33.6M of loans, financed purchases, leases and subscriptionsPublished threshold

Savings options to review

Where the county spends more per resident than counties of similar size, and what cutting there would trade away.

Spending per resident: St. Johns County and similar-size counties

St. Johns spends 3.4 times what a typical similar-size county spends on parks, libraries, culture.

St. Johns CountyTypical similar-size county
Parks, libraries, cultureSt. Johns County: $262$262Typical similar-size county: $76$76General government and adminSt. Johns County: $60$60Typical similar-size county: $33$33Economic development and housingSt. Johns County: $70$70Typical similar-size county: $51$51

Dollars per resident, FY2023-24 annual financial report. Higher spending can reflect services that other counties do not provide.

Show the numbers in a table
ItemTypeMeasureAmountTrade-offLegal limits
Parks, libraries, culturefunction above peers$262 vs $76 peer median (3.4x)$64.8MHours, programs and upkeep at parks and libraries; some are paid from dedicated levies or tourist tax.Board discretion; dedicated levies and TDT limits
General government and adminfunction above peers$60 vs $33 peer median (1.8x)$9.4MAdministrative capacity, legal, IT and planning; counties code these accounts differently.Board discretion
Economic development and housingfunction above peers$70 vs $51 peer median (1.4x)$6.6MOften tourism promotion paid from the tourist development tax and federal housing grants, which cannot pay for general services.Partly restricted (s.125.0104, grant terms)
Property tax abated for businesses (GASB 77 note)business tax abatement$ vs $ peer median (x)$539K$539,465 in FY2025: reimbursements of property tax, impact and utility fees to 7 businesses; 12 active agreements, paid only after growth or job criteria are met
Economic environmentgrowth above population plus inflationup 321% per resident after inflation$31.3MGrowth may reflect new services, storm recovery or grant-funded programs; needs the budget detailBoard discretion, subject to grants and contracts
Culture and recreationgrowth above population plus inflationup 63% per resident after inflation$24.8MGrowth may reflect new services, storm recovery or grant-funded programs; needs the budget detailBoard discretion, subject to grants and contracts

Peer tier: 200K-500K residents. FY2023-24 annual financial report; growth compares FY2015-17 and FY2022-24 averages.

Items to review

1 of 17 checks came up for this county.

Show the checks and notes
RuleItemThis countyThresholdAs ofSource
R17State filing differs materially from the auditState filing shows $0 tax-supported debt at Sept 30, 2025 ($70.0M in 2024); the FY2025 audit shows $231.2M of governmental revenue bonds and notes, plus $33.6M of loans, financed purchases, leases and subscriptionsA figure reported to the state differs by more than 25% from the same item in the audited financial statements, where hand-checked; data-quality flag; scores keep the state figureFY2024-25EDR 2025 county financial reporting data vs county audit

Data check, done. Checked against the county audit. The state filing shows $0 of tax-supported debt on Sept 30, 2025. The FY2024-25 audit shows $264.8M of governmental debt (bonds, notes, loans and leases), or $760 per resident. The state filing understates this county's debt. The score uses the state filing for every county. Source: St. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25.

Audit and reserves

What the county's latest outside audit found, and how much cash cushion it keeps.

Show the audit and reserve figures
MeasureValue
Latest audit screenedFY2025
Material weaknessNone reported
Finding repeated in three auditsNone reported
General fund unrestricted balance, % of spending and transfers out42.9%
General fund balance, start to end of year$135.88M to $160.49M (18.1%)

County audit as filed with the Auditor General.

How St. Johns County is responding

What county leaders have said or done about the lost revenue so far.

Show the numbers in a table
TypeProposalEstimateWhoDateStatusState lawSource
revenueLocal option gas tax, a sales surtax and higher fees for some services listed as options to study; staff to check whether tourist tax can pay for eligible servicesNot estimated (no rates proposed)County Administrator Joy AndrewsNov 17, 2026Workshop; staff study, no voteFuel tax: board vote within statutory caps (s.336.025); sales surtax: referendum (s.212.055) held at a general election; fees: allowed if tied to the cost of the serviceNews (St. Johns Citizen); agenda item 8, Nov 17, 2026
cutBoard asked to revisit $34.3M budgeted for outside agencies and nonprofits (about $5M for human-services nonprofits)Up to $34.3M a year (gross)County Administrator; chair to review contracts with county attorneyNov 17, 2026Discussed; review assignedBoard discretion, subject to contract termsMeeting summary (Florida Record)
cutHiring freeze made indefinite; a fire station put on hold; staff cuts plannedNot statedBoard of County CommissionersNov 9, 2026In effect (freeze)Board discretionNews (News4Jax)

History, FY2014-15 to latest

How the county's revenue, spending, debt and property values moved year by year since 2014-15.

Nominal dollars. Missing years are left blank, never estimated.

Operating revenue and property tax

Operating revenue was $789.7M in 2024-25, up 138% from $331.5M in 2014-15.

Operating revenueProperty tax
$0$200M$400M$600M$800MFY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Operating revenue, FY14-15: $331.5MOperating revenue, FY15-16: $351.7MOperating revenue, FY16-17: $371.0MOperating revenue, FY17-18: $428.8MOperating revenue, FY18-19: $444.3MOperating revenue, FY19-20: $518.0MOperating revenue, FY20-21: $521.4MOperating revenue, FY21-22: $624.9MOperating revenue, FY22-23: $728.2MOperating revenue, FY23-24: $788.4MOperating revenue, FY24-25: $789.7MProperty tax, FY14-15: $130.2MProperty tax, FY15-16: $142.0MProperty tax, FY16-17: $154.6MProperty tax, FY17-18: $167.4MProperty tax, FY18-19: $181.8MProperty tax, FY19-20: $199.7MProperty tax, FY20-21: $208.5MProperty tax, FY21-22: $228.0MProperty tax, FY22-23: $269.0MProperty tax, FY23-24: $313.4MProperty tax, FY24-25: $354.3MOperating revenueProperty tax

Source: EDR county (and Jacksonville) revenues/expenditures by account code and fund type, LFY2005-06 to LFY2024-25. Hollow points mark years with partial inputs.

View as table
Fiscal yearOperating revenueProperty tax
FY14-15$331.5M$130.2M
FY15-16$351.7M$142.0M
FY16-17$371.0M$154.6M
FY17-18$428.8M$167.4M
FY18-19$444.3M$181.8M
FY19-20$518.0M$199.7M
FY20-21$521.4M$208.5M
FY21-22$624.9M$228.0M
FY22-23$728.2M$269.0M
FY23-24$788.4M$313.4M
FY24-25$789.7M$354.3M

* partial inputs for that year.

Operating revenue by source

The biggest piece in 2024-25 is property tax: 45% of the total.

Property taxSales taxesState sharedGrantsCharges for servicesPermits, fees, assessmentsOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc.year with an event (see Events)
$0$200M$400M$600M$800M14-15Property tax, FY14-15: $130.2MSales taxes, FY14-15: $16.1MState shared, FY14-15: $14.7MGrants, FY14-15: $16.4MCharges for services, FY14-15: $100.8MPermits, fees, assessments, FY14-15: $17.2MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY14-15: $36.2M15-16Property tax, FY15-16: $142.0MSales taxes, FY15-16: $17.1MState shared, FY15-16: $13.9MGrants, FY15-16: $19.7MCharges for services, FY15-16: $108.2MPermits, fees, assessments, FY15-16: $21.7MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY15-16: $29.2M16-17Property tax, FY16-17: $154.6MSales taxes, FY16-17: $17.9MState shared, FY16-17: $15.2MGrants, FY16-17: $14.3MCharges for services, FY16-17: $114.6MPermits, fees, assessments, FY16-17: $24.2MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY16-17: $30.1MFEMA major disaster DR-4283: Hurricane Matthew ($53.7M); FEMA major disaster DR-4337: Hurricane Irma ($29.4M)17-18Property tax, FY17-18: $167.4MSales taxes, FY17-18: $19.6MState shared, FY17-18: $15.4MGrants, FY17-18: $40.3MCharges for services, FY17-18: $121.2MPermits, fees, assessments, FY17-18: $30.4MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY17-18: $34.4M18-19Property tax, FY18-19: $181.8MSales taxes, FY18-19: $20.1MState shared, FY18-19: $16.5MGrants, FY18-19: $17.2MCharges for services, FY18-19: $126.0MPermits, fees, assessments, FY18-19: $33.2MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY18-19: $49.5M19-20Property tax, FY19-20: $199.7MSales taxes, FY19-20: $19.5MState shared, FY19-20: $12.7MGrants, FY19-20: $78.3MCharges for services, FY19-20: $130.2MPermits, fees, assessments, FY19-20: $39.6MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY19-20: $38.0MFEMA major disaster DR-4468: Hurricane Dorian ($2.0M); FEMA major disaster DR-4486: Covid-19 Pandemic ($3.5M)20-21Property tax, FY20-21: $208.5MSales taxes, FY20-21: $24.5MState shared, FY20-21: $14.6MGrants, FY20-21: $47.7MCharges for services, FY20-21: $140.3MPermits, fees, assessments, FY20-21: $49.9MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY20-21: $36.0MARPA State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds: county government allocation ($51.4M)21-22Property tax, FY21-22: $228.0MSales taxes, FY21-22: $28.2MState shared, FY21-22: $17.5MGrants, FY21-22: $98.3MCharges for services, FY21-22: $170.0MPermits, fees, assessments, FY21-22: $57.3MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY21-22: $25.6MFEMA major disaster DR-4673: Hurricane Ian ($16.6M)22-23Property tax, FY22-23: $269.0MSales taxes, FY22-23: $29.9MState shared, FY22-23: $19.1MGrants, FY22-23: $70.4MCharges for services, FY22-23: $192.5MPermits, fees, assessments, FY22-23: $60.8MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY22-23: $86.6MFEMA major disaster DR-4680: Hurricane Nicole ($17.2M)23-24Property tax, FY23-24: $313.4MSales taxes, FY23-24: $30.5MState shared, FY23-24: $19.6MGrants, FY23-24: $89.1MCharges for services, FY23-24: $166.8MPermits, fees, assessments, FY23-24: $65.1MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY23-24: $103.8MFEMA major disaster DR-4806: Hurricane Debby ($2.6M)24-25Property tax, FY24-25: $354.3MSales taxes, FY24-25: $31.5MState shared, FY24-25: $20.1MGrants, FY24-25: $70.6MCharges for services, FY24-25: $182.1MPermits, fees, assessments, FY24-25: $45.6MOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc., FY24-25: $85.4MFEMA major disaster DR-4834: Hurricane Milton ($25.4M)

Source: EDR county (and Jacksonville) revenues/expenditures by account code and fund type, LFY2005-06 to LFY2024-25.

View as table
Fiscal yearProperty taxSales taxesState sharedGrantsCharges for servicesPermits, fees, assessmentsOther local taxes, other intergovernmental, fines and misc.
FY14-15$130.2M$16.1M$14.7M$16.4M$100.8M$17.2M$36.2M
FY15-16$142.0M$17.1M$13.9M$19.7M$108.2M$21.7M$29.2M
FY16-17$154.6M$17.9M$15.2M$14.3M$114.6M$24.2M$30.1M
FY17-18$167.4M$19.6M$15.4M$40.3M$121.2M$30.4M$34.4M
FY18-19$181.8M$20.1M$16.5M$17.2M$126.0M$33.2M$49.5M
FY19-20$199.7M$19.5M$12.7M$78.3M$130.2M$39.6M$38.0M
FY20-21$208.5M$24.5M$14.6M$47.7M$140.3M$49.9M$36.0M
FY21-22$228.0M$28.2M$17.5M$98.3M$170.0M$57.3M$25.6M
FY22-23$269.0M$29.9M$19.1M$70.4M$192.5M$60.8M$86.6M
FY23-24$313.4M$30.5M$19.6M$89.1M$166.8M$65.1M$103.8M
FY24-25$354.3M$31.5M$20.1M$70.6M$182.1M$45.6M$85.4M
Spending by function, all funds, without general government

The biggest piece in 2024-25 is public safety: 44% of the total.

Public safetyPhysical environmentTransportationHuman servicesCulture and recreationEconomic environmentCourts
$0$200M$400M$600M$800M14-15Public safety, FY14-15: $112.9MPhysical environment, FY14-15: $62.3MTransportation, FY14-15: $40.1MHuman services, FY14-15: $17.3MCulture and recreation, FY14-15: $28.3MEconomic environment, FY14-15: $5.4MCourts, FY14-15: $9.4M15-16Public safety, FY15-16: $121.6MPhysical environment, FY15-16: $65.7MTransportation, FY15-16: $38.8MHuman services, FY15-16: $12.3MCulture and recreation, FY15-16: $31.5MEconomic environment, FY15-16: $5.5MCourts, FY15-16: $9.8M16-17Public safety, FY16-17: $150.0MPhysical environment, FY16-17: $69.8MTransportation, FY16-17: $54.5MHuman services, FY16-17: $12.9MCulture and recreation, FY16-17: $35.5MEconomic environment, FY16-17: $4.5MCourts, FY16-17: $9.9M17-18Public safety, FY17-18: $147.3MPhysical environment, FY17-18: $79.6MTransportation, FY17-18: $43.1MHuman services, FY17-18: $13.9MCulture and recreation, FY17-18: $37.3MEconomic environment, FY17-18: $5.6MCourts, FY17-18: $8.2M18-19Public safety, FY18-19: $153.3MPhysical environment, FY18-19: $79.6MTransportation, FY18-19: $45.6MHuman services, FY18-19: $13.7MCulture and recreation, FY18-19: $38.8MEconomic environment, FY18-19: $5.3MCourts, FY18-19: $8.6M19-20Public safety, FY19-20: $177.7MPhysical environment, FY19-20: $77.8MTransportation, FY19-20: $43.0MHuman services, FY19-20: $14.9MCulture and recreation, FY19-20: $44.7MEconomic environment, FY19-20: $10.4MCourts, FY19-20: $8.3M20-21Public safety, FY20-21: $191.0MPhysical environment, FY20-21: $80.0MTransportation, FY20-21: $47.6MHuman services, FY20-21: $15.6MCulture and recreation, FY20-21: $33.7MEconomic environment, FY20-21: $24.4MCourts, FY20-21: $8.9M21-22Public safety, FY21-22: $181.4MPhysical environment, FY21-22: $90.5MTransportation, FY21-22: $54.3MHuman services, FY21-22: $15.6MCulture and recreation, FY21-22: $93.4MEconomic environment, FY21-22: $44.8MCourts, FY21-22: $10.0M22-23Public safety, FY22-23: $225.8MPhysical environment, FY22-23: $96.5MTransportation, FY22-23: $86.4MHuman services, FY22-23: $16.4MCulture and recreation, FY22-23: $92.3MEconomic environment, FY22-23: $45.3MCourts, FY22-23: $10.7M23-24Public safety, FY23-24: $255.2MPhysical environment, FY23-24: $104.7MTransportation, FY23-24: $112.3MHuman services, FY23-24: $22.1MCulture and recreation, FY23-24: $91.1MEconomic environment, FY23-24: $24.5MCourts, FY23-24: $11.8M24-25Public safety, FY24-25: $290.2MPhysical environment, FY24-25: $121.6MTransportation, FY24-25: $122.6MHuman services, FY24-25: $20.4MCulture and recreation, FY24-25: $67.6MEconomic environment, FY24-25: $22.6MCourts, FY24-25: $13.4M

Source: EDR county (and Jacksonville) revenues/expenditures by account code and fund type, LFY2005-06 to LFY2024-25. General government is left out of this chart: pass-through (custodial) money has been coded there since FY2020-21, which would look like growth.

View as table
Fiscal yearPublic safetyPhysical environmentTransportationHuman servicesCulture and recreationEconomic environmentCourts
FY14-15$112.9M$62.3M$40.1M$17.3M$28.3M$5.4M$9.4M
FY15-16$121.6M$65.7M$38.8M$12.3M$31.5M$5.5M$9.8M
FY16-17$150.0M$69.8M$54.5M$12.9M$35.5M$4.5M$9.9M
FY17-18$147.3M$79.6M$43.1M$13.9M$37.3M$5.6M$8.2M
FY18-19$153.3M$79.6M$45.6M$13.7M$38.8M$5.3M$8.6M
FY19-20$177.7M$77.8M$43.0M$14.9M$44.7M$10.4M$8.3M
FY20-21$191.0M$80.0M$47.6M$15.6M$33.7M$24.4M$8.9M
FY21-22$181.4M$90.5M$54.3M$15.6M$93.4M$44.8M$10.0M
FY22-23$225.8M$96.5M$86.4M$16.4M$92.3M$45.3M$10.7M
FY23-24$255.2M$104.7M$112.3M$22.1M$91.1M$24.5M$11.8M
FY24-25$290.2M$121.6M$122.6M$20.4M$67.6M$22.6M$13.4M
Debt outstanding on Sept 30

Total debt was $561.0M in 2024-25, up 54% from $364.4M in 2014-15.

Total debtGovernmentalBusiness-type
$0$150M$300M$450M$600MFY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Total debt, FY14-15: $364.4MTotal debt, FY15-16: $400.6MTotal debt, FY16-17: $397.6MTotal debt, FY17-18: $389.8MTotal debt, FY18-19: $388.2MTotal debt, FY19-20: $391.4MTotal debt, FY20-21: $375.9MTotal debt, FY21-22: $359.0MTotal debt, FY22-23: $482.3MTotal debt, FY23-24: $459.1MTotal debt, FY24-25: $561.0MGovernmental, FY14-15: $188.0MGovernmental, FY15-16: $212.8MGovernmental, FY16-17: $208.9MGovernmental, FY17-18: $198.9MGovernmental, FY18-19: $189.0MGovernmental, FY19-20: $189.8MGovernmental, FY20-21: $176.6MGovernmental, FY21-22: $165.8MGovernmental, FY22-23: $161.7MGovernmental, FY23-24: $150.4MGovernmental, FY24-25: $264.8MBusiness-type, FY14-15: $176.4MBusiness-type, FY15-16: $187.8MBusiness-type, FY16-17: $188.6MBusiness-type, FY17-18: $190.9MBusiness-type, FY18-19: $199.2MBusiness-type, FY19-20: $201.6MBusiness-type, FY20-21: $199.2MBusiness-type, FY21-22: $193.1MBusiness-type, FY22-23: $320.6MBusiness-type, FY23-24: $308.7MBusiness-type, FY24-25: $296.2MTotal debtBusiness-typeGovernmental

Sources and basis for each year are in the table below. Hollow points mark years with partial inputs. Self-reported figures usually run lower than audited figures.

View as table
Fiscal yearTotal debtGovernmentalBusiness-type
FY14-15$364.4M$188.0M$176.4M
FY15-16$400.6M$212.8M$187.8M
FY16-17$397.6M$208.9M$188.6M
FY17-18$389.8M$198.9M$190.9M
FY18-19$388.2M$189.0M$199.2M
FY19-20$391.4M$189.8M$201.6M
FY20-21$375.9M$176.6M$199.2M
FY21-22$359.0M$165.8M$193.1M
FY22-23$482.3M$161.7M$320.6M
FY23-24$459.1M$150.4M$308.7M
FY24-25$561.0M$264.8M$296.2M

* partial inputs for that year.

Debt basis by year
Fiscal yearBasisTotal debtSource
FY14-15self-reported (EDR)$364.4MEDR Local Government Financial Reporting, debt outstanding by type
FY15-16audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$400.6MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY16-17audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$397.6MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY17-18audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$389.8MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY18-19audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$388.2MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY19-20audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$391.4MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY20-21audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$375.9MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY21-22audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$359.0MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY22-23audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$482.3MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY23-24audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$459.1MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
FY24-25audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)$561.0MSt. Johns County ACFR FY2024-25, statistical section, Ratios of Outstanding Debt by Type
Debt per resident

Debt per resident was $1,611 in 2024-25, down 6% from $1,708 in 2014-15.

$0$500$1K$1.5K$2KFY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Debt per resident, FY14-15: $1,708Debt per resident, FY15-16: $1,820Debt per resident, FY16-17: $1,732Debt per resident, FY17-18: $1,634Debt per resident, FY18-19: $1,527Debt per resident, FY19-20: $1,495Debt per resident, FY20-21: $1,317Debt per resident, FY21-22: $1,210Debt per resident, FY22-23: $1,530Debt per resident, FY23-24: $1,386Debt per resident, FY24-25: $1,611Debt per resident

Total debt divided by population; basis by year is in the table above. Hollow points mark years with partial inputs.

View as table
Fiscal yearDebt per resident
FY14-15$1,708
FY15-16$1,820
FY16-17$1,732
FY17-18$1,634
FY18-19$1,527
FY19-20$1,495
FY20-21$1,317
FY21-22$1,210
FY22-23$1,530
FY23-24$1,386
FY24-25$1,611

* partial inputs for that year.

Taxable value

Taxable value was $53.80B in 2024-25, up 190% from $18.58B in 2014-15.

$0$15B$30B$45B$60BFY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Taxable value, FY14-15: $18.58BTaxable value, FY15-16: $20.26BTaxable value, FY16-17: $22.07BTaxable value, FY17-18: $23.87BTaxable value, FY18-19: $25.97BTaxable value, FY19-20: $28.49BTaxable value, FY20-21: $31.68BTaxable value, FY21-22: $34.67BTaxable value, FY22-23: $40.84BTaxable value, FY23-24: $47.60BTaxable value, FY24-25: $53.80BTaxable value

Source: DOR Property Tax Data Portal, County Taxable Value History. Hollow points mark years with partial inputs.

View as table
Fiscal yearTaxable value
FY14-15$18.58B
FY15-16$20.26B
FY16-17$22.07B
FY17-18$23.87B
FY18-19$25.97B
FY19-20$28.49B
FY20-21$31.68B
FY21-22$34.67B
FY22-23$40.84B
FY23-24$47.60B
FY24-25$53.80B

* partial inputs for that year.

Population

Population was 348,131 in 2024-25, up 63% from 213,386 in 2014-15.

0100,000200,000300,000400,000FY14-15FY16-17FY18-19FY20-21FY22-23FY24-25Population, FY14-15: 213,386Population, FY15-16: 220,088Population, FY16-17: 229,523Population, FY17-18: 238,586Population, FY18-19: 254,267Population, FY19-20: 261,762Population, FY20-21: 285,406Population, FY21-22: 296,767Population, FY22-23: 315,209Population, FY23-24: 331,327Population, FY24-25: 348,131Population

Source: EDR/BEBR April 1 estimate (via EDR financial data sets). Hollow points mark years with partial inputs.

View as table
Fiscal yearPopulation
FY14-15213,386
FY15-16220,088
FY16-17229,523
FY17-18238,586
FY18-19254,267
FY19-20261,762
FY20-21285,406
FY21-22296,767
FY22-23315,209
FY23-24331,327
FY24-25348,131

* partial inputs for that year.

County operating millage

Show the numbers in a table
Fiscal yearMills
FY14-15no data
FY15-16no data
FY16-17no data
FY17-18no data
FY18-195.8671
FY19-205.8671
FY20-215.5141
FY21-225.5141
FY22-235.5141
FY23-245.5141
FY24-255.5141

Source: DOR Data Book, Millage Rates and Taxes Levied (roll years 2018-2025). Available from the 2018 roll onward.

Events

10 events since 2014 (disasters, federal relief, bonds, programs)
DateCategoryEventAmountSource
2016-10-08hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4283: Hurricane Matthew$53.7MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2017-09-10hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4337: Hurricane Irma$29.4MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2019-10-21hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4468: Hurricane Dorian$2.0MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2020-03-25federal relief (pandemic)FEMA major disaster DR-4486: Covid-19 Pandemic$3.5MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2021-05-10federal relief (pandemic)ARPA State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds: county government allocation$51.4MU.S. Treasury SLFRF Allocation for Counties (CSV, May 10, 20
2022-09-29hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4673: Hurricane Ian$16.6MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2022-12-13hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4680: Hurricane Nicole$17.2MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2023-08-31hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4734: Hurricane Idalia$264KOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2024-08-10hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4806: Hurricane Debby$2.6MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF
2024-10-11hurricaneFEMA major disaster DR-4834: Hurricane Milton$25.4MOpenFEMA DisasterDeclarationsSummaries and PublicAssistanceF

FEMA amounts are Public Assistance federal share obligated to local applicants in the county, not only county government.

American Rescue Plan (SLFRF) allocation to the county government: $51.4M. Source: U.S. Treasury allocation, as listed in the data downloads.

Economic development incentives

Money and tax breaks the county gave to businesses, and what was promised in return.

Show the incentive figures

State survey figures are self-reported by the county to EDR. A deal marked as warranting review published no results in the sources reviewed.

Debt and pension

The county owes $561.0M, about $1,611 for each resident, plus its pension obligations.

MeasureValueAs of / basis
Tax-supported debt$0Sept 30, 2025, self-reported to EDR (used by the health score)
Tax-supported debt per resident$0Sept 30, 2025
Total debt, audited or reported$561.0Maudited (ACFR ten-year schedule)
Total debt per resident$1,611audited (ACFR ten-year schedule)
Pension liability$259.4MFRS pension + HIS proportionate share (June 30, 2025) for county-government employers
Pension liability per resident$7452025

Debt: Florida EDR, 2025 Local Government Financial Reporting data set with metrics (counties) and county audits (basis shown). Pension: FRS (June 30, 2025) or JAX_ACFR for Duval.

What this means if you own, buy or sell a home in St. Johns County

County budgets and tax bills are two sides of the same change. These pages cover the homeowner side and the local market. This is not tax or legal advice.

Questions about a specific property? Talk with the Momentum Realty team at (904) 351-6461.

Questions about your property after Amendment 3?

Tell us what you are thinking about, whether that is buying, selling or understanding your own bill, and a Momentum Realty agent will follow up. Prefer to talk now? Call (904) 351-6461.

What’s my home worth?

Neighboring and similar-size counties

Neighbors: Clay County, Duval County, Flagler County, Putnam County.

Similar population (200K-500K residents): Escambia County, Leon County, St. Lucie County, Alachua County, Collier County.

Jacksonville region: Jacksonville and Amendment 3.

All 67 counties

Words used on this page

Words used on this page
Budget year (FY)
Florida counties budget from Oct 1 to Sep 30. FY2028-29 means Oct 1, 2028 to Sep 30, 2029.
Operating revenue
The money a county takes in during a year to run its services: taxes, fees and grants. Loans are not counted.
EDR
The Florida Legislature's Office of Economic and Demographic Research. Its economists made the state's official estimate of what Amendment 3 costs each county.
FAC
The Florida Association of Counties, which made its own, separate estimate.
Health score
A 0 to 100 score that compares each county with the other 66 on seven money measures. Higher is stronger. Rank 1 is the strongest county.
Fifths
The 67 counties sorted by score and split into five equal groups, from the strongest fifth to the weakest fifth.
Mill
A property-tax rate unit: 1 mill is $1 of tax for every $1,000 of taxable value. Counties may not go above 10 mills for operations.
Beyond population and inflation
Spending growth that is left after allowing for more residents and inflation.
Inflation
The general rise in prices, measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI-U): what households pay for things like groceries, rent and gas. It is the standard yardstick, also used by the state. It does not measure what counties pay for wages, construction or insurance, which in Florida often rose faster.

Sources, method and corrections

FigureSource
populationFlorida EDR/BEBR, April 1, 2025 population estimates by county (April 1, 2025)
a3Florida EDR Revenue Estimating Conference, CS/HJR 1F impact by county and taxing authority (July 10, 2026) (July 10, 2026); Florida Association of Counties, Fiscal Impact Readers Guide and Backgrounder (June 2026) (June 2026); county sources as listed
taxpayer sideStepUp Law, Florida Amendment 3 homestead database (third-party model on 2026 preliminary rolls and 2025 millage)
levy 2025Florida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Data Book: Millage Rates and Taxes Levied, 2025 (2025 tax roll)
levy 2023Florida Department of Revenue, 2023 Data Book: Millage Rates and Taxes Levied
taxable valueFlorida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Data Portal (county taxable value history)
operating revenueFlorida EDR, county revenues and expenditures from Annual Financial Reports (LGFR), FY2005-06 to FY2023-24 (FY2023-24, custodial and other non-operating funds removed)
spending by functionFlorida EDR, 2025 Local Government Financial Reporting data set with metrics (counties) (AFR FY2014-15..FY2023-24) + Florida EDR/BEBR, April 1, 2025 population estimates by county + U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U annual averages (series CUUR0000SA0)
debtFlorida EDR, 2025 Local Government Financial Reporting data set with metrics (counties) (Sept 30 each year, self-reported)
pensionFlorida Retirement System, GASB 68 schedules and audit report, fiscal year ended June 30, 2025 (June 30, 2025) or City of Jacksonville, Annual Comprehensive Financial Report FY2025 for Duval

Methodology · Corrections log · Download the data

Common questions

How much property-tax revenue could St. Johns County lose under Amendment 3?

Estimates for FY2028-29 range from $109.4M to $136.1M at current tax rates. The lower and higher figures come from the state Office of Economic and Demographic Research (July 10, 2026) and the Florida Association of Counties (June 2026).

Does Amendment 3 change school taxes?

No. The larger homestead exemption applies to non-school levies. The school-levy exemption stays at $25,000.

When does Amendment 3 take effect?

Voters adopted it on Nov 3, 2026 with 61.98% Yes, according to the Florida Division of Elections. It takes effect Jan 1, 2027 and first applies to the 2027 tax roll.

What is the financial health score for St. Johns County?

69.2 of 100 before Amendment 3 (rank 10 of 67) and 48.3 after, using the state estimate (rank 31). Rank 1 is the highest score. The score compares counties on seven measures with the same method for all.