Big Pine Key neighborhoods with the market data that actually moves a decision.
28 Big Pine Key community guides, each with real pricing, HOA/CDD reality, and flood/insurance posture. Below: the Big Pine Key market snapshot, then every community we cover.
Big Pine Key market snapshot
$818,200Median sale price
$750.3Median $/sq ft
75Median days on market
35Communities with sales data
Aggregated from MLS closed-sale records across 35 Big Pine Key communities; latest data 2026. Aggregate statistics only, deemed reliable but not guaranteed; not an appraisal. Refreshes with each MLS data update.
All Big Pine Key communities (28)
Big Pine Key IncBig Pine Key Inc in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $535K (2024), 57 sales since 2006, 82 homes, built 1928-2022. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Big Pine ShoresBig Pine Shores in Big Pine Key, FL: 44 homes, built 1958-2022. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Breezy Pines RV EstatesBreezy Pines RV Estates in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 5 MLS sales on record since 2017. Live Florida Keys…Cahill Pines & PalmsCahill Pines & Palms in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $625K (2026), 146 homes, built 1963-2023, median 109 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS…DariosDarios in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $370K (2023), 33 sales since 2008. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Doctors ArmDoctors Arm in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $1.14M (2026), 211 homes, built 1953-2024, median 25 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Dolphin EstatesDolphin Estates in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 1 MLS sale on record since 2016. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Eden Pines ColonyEden Pines Colony in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $880K (2026), 649 homes, built 1928-2024, median 58 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…GrieserGrieser in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 8 MLS sales on record since 2008. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…HollerichHollerich in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $835K (2025), 27 sales since 2010. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.KoehnsKoehns in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 27 MLS sales on record since 2007. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Kyle DyreKyle Dyre in Big Pine Key, FL: 32 homes, built 1958-2020. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Long Beach EstatesLong Beach Estates in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $2.35M (2023), 46 sales since 2006, 39 homes, built 1967-2020. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Palm VillaPalm Villa in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $660K (2026), 268 homes, built 1929-2024, median 117 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Pine Channel EstatesPine Channel Estates in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $1.17M (2026), 251 homes, built 1963-2023, median 76 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Pine HeightsPine Heights in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 34 MLS sales on record since 2007. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Pine Key AcresPine Key Acres in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $825K (2023), 42 sales since 2007, 36 homes, built 1963-2019. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Pine Key Yacht Club EstatesPine Key Yacht Club Estates in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $515K (2023), 22 sales since 2000. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Piney PointPiney Point in Big Pine Key, FL: 1 home for sale from $175K, 1 sold on record. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Port Pine HeightsPort Pine Heights in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $824K (2026), 416 homes, built 1928-2024, median 126 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Punta BrisaPunta Brisa in Big Pine Key, FL: 85 homes, built 1948-2023. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Ross HavenRoss Haven in Big Pine Key, FL: 93 homes, built 1955-2024. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.SandsSands in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $630K (2026), median 87 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Sea ViewSea View in Big Pine Key, FL: 92 homes for sale in ZIP 33043 (12% under contract), 6 MLS sales on record since 2010. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Tropical BayTropical Bay in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $1.09M (2026), 138 homes, built 1948-2024, median 143 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Tropical Key ColonyTropical Key Colony in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $684K (2025), 71 sales since 2006, 90 homes, built 1968-2022. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Whispering PinesWhispering Pines in Big Pine Key, FL: Median sale $947K (2026), 195 homes, built 1943-2024, median 70 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Wickfield AcresWickfield Acres in Big Pine Key, FL: Recent sales median $725K (2025), 23 sales since 2007, 54 homes, built 1943-2021. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…