Lower Matecumbe neighborhoods with the market data that actually moves a decision.
18 Lower Matecumbe community guides, each with real pricing, HOA/CDD reality, and flood/insurance posture. Below: the Lower Matecumbe market snapshot, then every community we cover.
Community-level market data for this city is compiled from MLS closed sales and fills in here as sales history accrues; it refreshes with each data update.
All Lower Matecumbe communities (18)
Bay HarbourBay Harbour in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $1M (2026), median 209 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Davis ShoresDavis Shores in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 16 homes, built 1949-2012. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Fantasy HarborFantasy Harbor in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 2 MLS sales on record since 2023. Live Florida Keys MLS…Islamorada SouthIslamorada South in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $356K (2026), median 65 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Lower Mat BeachLower Mat Beach in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Recent sales median $1.36M (2025), 54 sales since 2006. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Lower Mat HarborLower Mat Harbor in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 19 MLS sales on record since 2008. Live Florida Keys…Mat Ocean BayMat Ocean Bay in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 51 MLS sales on record since 2007. Live Florida Keys MLS…Mat Ocean BeachMat Ocean Beach in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 25 MLS sales on record since 2007. Live Florida Keys…Mat Ocean ViewMat Ocean View in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $1.62M (2026), 55 homes, built 1953-2022, median 164 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Mat Sandy BeachMat Sandy Beach in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Recent sales median $4.63M (2023), 32 sales since 2008. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Matecumbe Ocean BayMatecumbe Ocean Bay in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 19 homes, built 1976-2021. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Port AntiguaPort Antigua in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $2.50M (2026), 374 homes, built 1946-2024, median 275 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and…Safety HarborSafety Harbor in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $4.08M (2026), 152 homes, built 1936-2024, median 109 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data…SandglassSandglass in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 5 MLS sales on record since 2013. Live Florida Keys MLS data…Sandy PointSandy Point in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 104 homes for sale in ZIP 33036 (17% under contract), 8 MLS sales on record since 2012. Live Florida Keys MLS…StillbeachStillbeach in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 55 homes, built 1953-2022. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.Toll Gate ShoresToll Gate Shores in Lower Matecumbe, FL: 39 homes, built 1958-2024. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.White Marlin BeachWhite Marlin Beach in Lower Matecumbe, FL: Median sale $2.20M (2026), median 22 days on market. Live Florida Keys MLS data and public records.