Florida Housing Tools · Rent vs Buy by County

Rent vs Buy, County by County

The rent-versus-buy gap is the core decision in this market, and it is different in every Florida county. Pick a county and compare the true monthly cost of owning the typical home against the typical asking rent, with real taxes, insurance, and your own rate.

Your scenario

The comparison

Pick a county and press the button. Typical values load automatically.
Every Florida county with a rent index: the monthly gap, the 2028 gap and the break-even rate

Why this differs so much by county

Two Florida counties with similar home prices can have very different ownership costs, because millage rates and insurance premiums vary county to county, while rents follow their own market. Coastal counties often carry insurance premiums two or three times inland levels; some inland counties tax higher. That is why a statewide rent-vs-buy rule of thumb misleads, and why this tool prices each county separately.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy in Florida right now?

In most Florida counties the monthly cost of owning a typical home currently exceeds the typical rent, once taxes, insurance, and maintenance are counted. The gap varies a lot by county, which is exactly what this calculator shows.

What does the rent vs buy comparison include?

Owning: principal and interest at your rate and down payment, property taxes at the county's typical school and non-school millage with the 2026 homestead exemptions, the county's average Citizens insurance premium, and a 1% maintenance reserve. Renting: the county's typical asking rent (Zillow ZORI). It also shows the break-even rate, the break-even price, the principal you repay in year one, and the 2028 gap after Amendment 3. It does not model appreciation, rent growth, PMI or tax deductions.

What is the price-to-rent ratio and why does it matter?

It is the typical home value divided by a year of typical rent. Above roughly 20, renting tends to win on monthly cost; below 15, buying tends to win. Florida counties currently span a wide range.

What mortgage rate makes buying cheaper than renting in Florida?

It depends on the county. At the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.11% (November 12, 2026) and 10% down, owning the typical home cost more each month than the typical asking rent in all 45 Florida counties that have a Zillow rent index (September 2026). The calculator shows the break-even rate for each one: it is below about 4.2% in every one of them, and in eight counties no rate works because taxes, insurance and upkeep alone exceed the rent.

How does Amendment 3 change the rent vs buy math?

For a homestead, Amendment 3 raises the non-school exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. At typical Florida home values that trims roughly $90 to $270 a month from the tax line in 2028 if millage holds, which narrows but does not close the gap in any county. Rentals get no new exemption. Local governments can raise millage or add fees, so treat the 2028 figure as approximate.

Does this mean I should wait to buy?

Not necessarily. Monthly cost is one input; how long you will stay, price direction, rate buydowns, and negotiated credits can change the answer. In today's market, builders and sellers are offering meaningful concessions that this calculator lets you test with the price field.

Where does the data come from?

Typical home values and asking rents are Zillow's ZHVI and ZORI county indexes (September 2026, credit Zillow); millage is the FY2025-26 county-typical rate split into school and non-school levies (verified for the larger counties, county averages elsewhere); insurance is the average Citizens Property Insurance premium by county (April 2026); the default rate is the Freddie Mac weekly average. Every figure changes over time.

For every county side by side, with what the gap means in Northeast Florida and what Amendment 3 changes, read rent or buy in Florida at 7.11%: the monthly gap in 45 counties (November 18, 2026).

Digging deeper? Run the simple rent-vs-buy calculator, compare two counties end to end with the county move calculator, check insurance costs by county, or estimate a purchase with the mortgage payment calculator.

Using these figures? Link to this page as the source so readers can see the live numbers; they refresh from Momentum Realty’s MLS and county data (as of 2026-11-18). Suggested attribution:
<a href="https://movewithmomentum.com/tools/florida-rent-vs-buy-by-county">Florida Rent vs Buy Calculator by County (2026) — Momentum Realty</a>
Press and data requests: jon@movewithmomentum.com · Florida Housing Intelligence

Estimates only. Typical home value is Zillow’s ZHVI and typical asking rent is Zillow’s ZORI for each county (September 2026), credit Zillow; default rate is the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.11% (week of November 12, 2026); property tax uses each county’s FY2025-26 typical school and non-school millage with the 2026 homestead exemptions ($25,000 on all levies plus up to $26,411 more on non-school levies), purchase price used as assessed value (approximate); insurance is the average Citizens Property Insurance premium by county (April 2026) and private-market premiums differ; maintenance reserve assumed at 1% of price per year. Does not model appreciation, rent growth, HOA/CDD fees, PMI, or tax deductions. Amendment 3 (passed November 3, 2026) raises the homestead exemption from 2027 but gives rentals no new exemption; see what Amendment 3 means for rent, county by county. Not financial advice. Equal Housing Opportunity.