← Back to Blog

Rent or Buy in Florida at 7.11%? The Monthly Gap in 45 Counties and the Rate That Flips It

Two numbers moved for Florida renters this fall. Mortgage rates fell for a fourth straight week, to a 7.11% average on a 30-year fixed loan in Freddie Mac’s survey for the week of November 12, 2026. And Amendment 3, approved November 3, will cut the city and county tax on homesteads in 2027 and again in 2028. If you rent today, the question is whether either one is enough to make owning cheaper than renting where you live.

So we priced the monthly decision in every Florida county that has a published rent index, using the same inputs as our rent vs buy calculator by county, which we updated today with September 2026 values and rents, the 7.11% rate, a break-even rate for every county and the 2028 Amendment 3 tax line.

The short version: at 7.11% with 10% down, owning the typical home costs more each month than the typical asking rent in all 45 Florida counties that have a Zillow rent index. In the median county the gap is about $1,042 a month (about $2,946 to own against $1,881 to rent). The gap is smallest in Jackson County ($302), Putnam ($479), Highlands ($487) and Citrus ($498), and largest in Monroe ($4,004), Walton ($3,197) and St. Johns ($2,000). In Duval County it is about $907. Roughly $261 of the median owner’s monthly payment in year one repays principal, and Amendment 3 trims the median gap by about $148 a month by 2028.

How we priced owning and renting

Owning starts with each county’s typical home value, Zillow’s Home Value Index (ZHVI) for September 2026. We added four monthly costs:

  • Principal and interest on a 30-year fixed loan at 7.11% with 10% down.
  • Property tax at the county’s typical FY2025-26 millage, split into school and non-school levies, with the 2026 homestead exemptions: $25,000 off every levy plus up to $26,411 more off non-school levies. We used the price as the assessed value, which is close for a recent purchase.
  • Insurance at the county’s average Citizens Property Insurance premium (April 2026). Private-market quotes can be higher or lower.
  • Maintenance reserved at 1% of the home’s value a year.

Renting is the county’s typical asking rent, Zillow’s Observed Rent Index (ZORI) for September 2026. Zillow publishes it for 45 of Florida’s 67 counties; the other 22 are left out rather than guessed.

Two limits are worth saying plainly. First, the typical rental and the typical home are not the same property: the rent index includes apartments, so the typical rental is often smaller than the typical home, and that widens the gap. For a like-for-like answer, enter the rent on the actual house you would otherwise rent in the calculator. Second, this is monthly cost, not long-run wealth. It leaves out PMI, HOA and CDD fees, closing costs, price changes, rent increases and what a down payment could earn elsewhere.

The gap in every county with a rent index

Sorted from the smallest monthly gap to the largest, at 7.11% and 10% down. “Gap 2028” applies Amendment 3’s $250,000 non-school homestead exemption with today’s millage. “Break-even rate” is the mortgage rate at which owning the typical home would cost the same as the typical rent; “none” means even a 0% loan would not get there. Each county name opens the calculator with that county loaded.

CountyTypical homeTypical rentOwn / monthGap nowGap 2028Break-even rate
Jackson$179,815$1,230$1,532$302$2124.15%
Putnam$216,313$1,370$1,849$479$3413.09%
Highlands$231,284$1,517$2,004$487$3343.32%
Citrus$268,688$1,755$2,253$498$3543.81%
Wakulla$285,880$1,817$2,381$564$4283.58%
Marion$267,911$1,593$2,183$590$4983.12%
DeSoto$250,420$1,524$2,225$701$4921.84%
Columbia$267,659$1,499$2,219$720$5722.08%
Polk$295,509$1,814$2,537$723$5432.61%
Baker$314,146$1,850$2,585$735$5872.83%
Charlotte$298,906$1,851$2,614$763$5902.39%
Pasco$328,125$1,985$2,785$800$6362.63%
Escambia$280,027$1,646$2,474$828$6451.48%
Hernando$306,116$1,809$2,660$851$6501.88%
Alachua$298,912$1,640$2,501$861$7061.66%
Duval$294,079$1,603$2,510$907$7171.18%
Leon$291,390$1,473$2,408$935$7890.88%
Indian River$363,705$2,128$3,100$972$8242.12%
Clay$335,274$1,805$2,778$973$8281.60%
Santa Rosa$350,823$1,975$2,951$976$8531.88%
Okaloosa$352,929$1,957$2,987$1,030$9061.57%
Osceola$359,224$1,988$3,024$1,036$8891.65%
St. Lucie$370,781$2,329$3,371$1,042$7711.82%
Flagler$350,266$1,881$2,926$1,045$9051.42%
Lee$334,485$1,827$2,875$1,048$8721.06%
Brevard$342,346$1,887$2,946$1,059$9051.16%
Bay$343,009$1,735$2,833$1,098$9800.90%
Volusia$324,665$1,736$2,836$1,100$8690.43%
Lake$360,055$1,951$3,069$1,118$9501.13%
Sarasota$399,023$2,168$3,328$1,160$1,0311.59%
Hillsborough$375,501$1,978$3,177$1,199$1,0460.92%
Pinellas$368,917$2,028$3,227$1,199$9820.78%
Broward$422,344$2,457$3,667$1,210$9891.69%
Palm Beach$475,754$2,673$4,099$1,426$1,2241.38%
Orange$400,964$1,933$3,379$1,446$1,277none
Sumter$387,784$1,723$3,171$1,448$1,330none
Manatee$408,269$2,031$3,509$1,478$1,299none
Seminole$400,341$1,856$3,344$1,488$1,342none
Martin$448,233$2,262$3,828$1,566$1,4180.16%
Miami-Dade$523,240$2,789$4,468$1,679$1,4970.88%
Nassau$484,963$2,144$3,930$1,786$1,672none
Collier$552,087$2,607$4,453$1,846$1,7400.55%
St. Johns$492,987$2,020$4,020$2,000$1,879none
Walton$660,738$2,020$5,217$3,197$3,104none
Monroe$962,885$3,671$7,675$4,004$3,919none

Sources: Zillow Home Value Index and Zillow Observed Rent Index, September 2026 (data provided by Zillow); Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week of November 12, 2026; county-typical FY2025-26 millage, Momentum Realty data compiled June 2026 (verified for the larger counties, county averages elsewhere); Citizens Property Insurance average premium by county, April 2026. Estimates, rounded to the dollar.

What stands out

No county flips at today’s rate. Owning costs more than renting in every one of the 45 counties at 7.11% and 10% down. Putting 20% down lowers the median gap to about $794 a month, still well above zero everywhere.

A rate cut alone will not close it. Across the 37 counties where a break-even rate exists, the median is about 1.65%. The highest is Jackson County at about 4.15%, followed by Citrus (3.81%), Wakulla (3.58%) and Highlands (3.32%). In eight counties, Orange, Sumter, Manatee, Seminole, Nassau, St. Johns, Walton and Monroe, no rate works: taxes, insurance, upkeep and principal on the typical home add up to more than the typical rent even with a 0% loan. A full point off today’s rate, to 6.11%, moves the median gap only from $1,042 to about $822.

The price-to-rent ratio explains most of the ranking. The four counties with the smallest gaps all have a typical home priced at about 12 to 13 years of typical rent. St. Johns (20.3), Monroe (21.9) and Walton (27.3) are the only counties above 20, and they have the three largest gaps.

The two sides are drifting toward each other, slowly. Typical home values fell over the past year in 38 of 67 counties (median change about -0.3%), while typical asking rents rose a median 1.4% across the 42 counties with a year of rent data, and fell in 8. At that pace the gap narrows by tens of dollars a year, not hundreds.

Northeast Florida, line by line

  • Duval County: typical home $294,079, typical rent $1,603 a month. Owning costs about $2,510, a gap of $907 ($717 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $710 with 20% down); break-even rate about 1.18%; about $219 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • Clay County: typical home $335,274, typical rent $1,805 a month. Owning costs about $2,778, a gap of $973 ($828 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $748 with 20% down); break-even rate about 1.60%; about $250 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • St. Johns County: typical home $492,987, typical rent $2,020 a month. Owning costs about $4,020, a gap of $2,000 ($1,879 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $1,668 with 20% down); no break-even rate; about $368 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • Nassau County: typical home $484,963, typical rent $2,144 a month. Owning costs about $3,930, a gap of $1,786 ($1,672 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $1,460 with 20% down); no break-even rate; about $362 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • Baker County: typical home $314,146, typical rent $1,850 a month. Owning costs about $2,585, a gap of $735 ($587 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $524 with 20% down); break-even rate about 2.83%; about $234 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • Putnam County: typical home $216,313, typical rent $1,370 a month. Owning costs about $1,849, a gap of $479 ($341 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $334 with 20% down); break-even rate about 3.09%; about $161 a month of year-one payments is principal.
  • Flagler County: typical home $350,266, typical rent $1,881 a month. Owning costs about $2,926, a gap of $1,045 ($905 in 2028 with Amendment 3, $810 with 20% down); break-even rate about 1.42%; about $261 a month of year-one payments is principal.

Baker and Putnam are where the monthly math is closest in our region, and both have break-even rates near 3%. In St. Johns and Nassau the gap comes from price, not rate: the typical home is about 19 to 20 years of typical rent. For the full cost of living side by side, see the county move calculator, and for local rents, the Jacksonville rent tracker.

Part of the payment is not a cost

A mortgage payment is not all expense. In year one at 7.11%, about $261 a month of the median county’s payment repays principal, which stays with the owner as equity. Net of that, the median gap is about $768 a month; in Duval it is about $688. Principal paydown grows every year of the loan.

What the monthly view cannot show is price change. When prices rise, owners gain and the rent-versus-buy answer tilts toward buying; when they fall, as they have in more than half of Florida counties over the past year, it tilts the other way. Longer-run studies that assume appreciation reach very different answers from a monthly comparison. For example, Florida Realtors reported on May 13, 2026 that AD Mortgage’s 10-year rent vs buy study projected a homeowner advantage of about $275,256 in Jacksonville and about $509,000 in Miami, assuming renters invest the difference in the S&P 500. Both views are useful, and they answer different questions: one asks what you can afford each month, the other what you might own in ten years.

What Amendment 3 changes, and what it does not

Amendment 3 raises the homestead exemption from non-school taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. With millage held where it is, that lowers the median county’s tax line by about $148 a month by 2028, from about $90 a month in Jackson County to about $271 in St. Lucie. It narrows the gap in every county and closes it in none. The 2028 column in the table shows each county.

Three cautions. The cut applies only to a homestead, so it helps an owner-occupant, not a landlord, and it does not lower anyone’s rent directly. School taxes are unchanged. And cities and counties can raise millage or add flat fees to replace lost revenue; our Amendment 3 fee break-even calculator shows how large a new fee would have to be to cancel the saving, and the Amendment 3 calculator estimates your own exemption.

If you are deciding now

  • Use your real numbers. The typical home and the typical rent are a starting point. Enter the price you are looking at and the rent you actually pay in the rent vs buy calculator; it also shows the price at which owning would match your rent at today’s rate (about $185,758 for the typical Duval rent of $1,603).
  • Price the concessions. Seller credits and rate buydowns are common in this market and change the monthly math directly. Test a temporary buydown with the buydown reset calculator and see what credits sellers are giving in our seller concessions report.
  • Count the move-in cash. Closing costs and prepaid escrow can run several percent of the price; the Florida buyer closing costs calculator estimates them by county and closing month. A short stay makes those costs harder to recover.
  • Check the full payment. Our typical house payment by county breaks down the owner’s side at 7.11% with income ratios for all 67 counties.

Momentum Realty is a real estate brokerage, not a lender or financial advisor, and this is not financial advice. Confirm rates and payments with a licensed loan officer and taxes with your county property appraiser. Data compiled November 18, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy in Florida right now?

On monthly cost, renting is cheaper in every Florida county we could measure. At the 7.11% average 30-year rate (Freddie Mac, November 12, 2026) and 10% down, owning the typical home costs more than the typical asking rent in all 45 counties with a Zillow rent index, by about $1,042 a month in the median county. About $261 of that payment is principal the owner keeps as equity.

What mortgage rate would make buying cheaper than renting in Florida?

Much lower than today in most counties. The median break-even rate across the 37 counties where one exists is about 1.65%. The highest is Jackson County at about 4.15%. In eight counties, including Orange, Seminole, St. Johns and Nassau, no rate works for the typical home because taxes, insurance, upkeep and principal alone exceed the typical rent.

Where in Florida is buying closest to renting?

In counties where the typical home costs about 12 to 13 years of typical rent: Jackson ($302 a month gap), Putnam ($479), Highlands ($487) and Citrus ($498), at 7.11% with 10% down. The largest gaps are in Monroe, Walton and St. Johns.

Is it cheaper to rent or buy in Jacksonville?

In Duval County the typical home (about $294,079) costs about $2,510 a month to own at 7.11% with 10% down, against a typical asking rent of about $1,603, a gap of about $907. About $219 of the owner’s payment is principal. Owning would match that rent at about a 1.18% rate, or at a price near $185,758 at today’s rate.

Does Amendment 3 make buying cheaper than renting?

It helps owners who homestead but does not close the gap anywhere. With millage unchanged, the 2028 exemption lowers the median county’s tax line by about $148 a month, narrowing the median gap from about $1,042 to about $872. Rentals get no new exemption, and local governments can raise rates or add fees.

Why doesn't this comparison count home price growth?

Because it compares monthly cost, which you can measure today, not future value, which you cannot. Price changes and the return on a down payment invested elsewhere decide the long-run answer, and values fell over the past year in 38 of 67 Florida counties. Use the monthly gap together with how long you expect to stay.

Sources

  • Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey, 30-year fixed average 7.11% (prior week 7.18%), week of November 12, 2026.
  • Zillow Research, Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) and Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), county series through September 2026 (data provided by Zillow), compiled by Momentum Realty November 16, 2026.
  • Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, policies and premium detail by county, April 2026.
  • County-typical FY2025-26 millage, Momentum Realty data compiled from county property appraisers, adopted budgets and Florida TaxWatch county averages (June 5, 2026).
  • Florida Department of Revenue, 2026 indexed homestead exemption; Amendment 3 exemption schedule as summarized by the Florida Policy Institute (July 21, 2026).
  • Florida Realtors, Amy Connolly, “Study: Buying may outpace renting in Florida,” May 13, 2026 (AD Mortgage 2026 10-Year Rent vs. Buy Wealth Study).

Keep reading

Buying or selling in Northeast Florida?

Turn this research into a real next step.

You’ve done the homework. Momentum is the team that closed $594M last year and gives you representation that’s actually yours. Tell us what you’re working on, and a real person follows up within one business day.

Top 1% in Florida by RealTrends · 10,000+ customers served · 5.0★ from 1,000+ reviews

What’s your home worth in Northeast Florida?

A real valuation with real comps from a local listing agent, not an instant algorithm. Response within one business day.

By submitting, you agree that EAB RE INVESTMENTS LLC (Momentum Realty) and its agents may call, email, and text you about your inquiry, which may involve automated means and prerecorded or artificial voices. You do not need to consent as a condition of buying any property, goods, or services. To opt out, reply STOP at any time or reply HELP for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. See our Privacy Policy and SMS Terms.or call (904) 351-6461

Thinking about buying in Northeast Florida?

Get matched with a Momentum agent who actually works this market, honest pricing, the off-market list, and representation that’s yours, not the builder’s.

By submitting, you agree that EAB RE INVESTMENTS LLC (Momentum Realty) and its agents may call, email, and text you about your inquiry, which may involve automated means and prerecorded or artificial voices. You do not need to consent as a condition of buying any property, goods, or services. To opt out, reply STOP at any time or reply HELP for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. See our Privacy Policy and SMS Terms.or call (904) 351-6461
CallTalk to an agent →