Cutler Bay, FL ZIP Codes
Cutler Bay, FL has 3 ZIP codes: 33157, 33189, 33190. Between them, 67 homes are for sale as of 2026-09-06; 33190 has the most listings (40), 33157 is the least expensive by asking price (median $225,000) and 33190 the most (median $322,495).
Every Cutler Bay ZIP code with prices and what is for sale
All 3 ZIP codes for Cutler Bay, FL: the neighborhoods each one covers, homes actively listed today with the median asking price, what homes sold for over the last 12 months, and days on market. Rows marked PO/partial are ZIPs whose USPS city is Cutler Bay but where current listings sit in a neighboring city.
| ZIP | Neighborhoods | For sale | Median list | Median sold (12 mo) | DOM | ZIP pages |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33157 PO/partial | BEL AIRE, CUTLER CAY, SOUTH MIAMI HEIGHTS ADDN | 5 | $225,000 | $625,000 | 56 | scorecard · market data |
| 33189 PO/partial | LAKES BY THE BAY, BEL AIRE, SOUTH MIAMI HEIGHTS ADDN | 22 | $265,000 | $574,990 | 48 | scorecard · market data |
| 33190 PO/partial | LAKES BY THE BAY, ENCLAVE SOUTH, THE COURTS AT BAYSHORE II | 40 | $322,495 | $540,000 | 57 | scorecard · market data |
Homes for sale in Cutler Bay by ZIP
The live listings behind these counts, with photos, are on the Cutler Bay homes for sale page, grouped by price and by ZIP.
Explore Cutler Bay
Common questions
What are the ZIP codes in Cutler Bay, FL?
Which Cutler Bay ZIP code has the most homes for sale?
What is the cheapest ZIP code in Cutler Bay?
What is the median home price in Cutler Bay by ZIP?
How many homes are for sale in Cutler Bay right now?
Listing counts and asking prices are active residential listings in Momentum Realty’s MLS record as of 2026-09-06; sold medians and days on market are 12-month figures from the same record. ZIP-to-city assignment follows USPS for Florida and listing addresses for Georgia. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity.