Momentum Housing Data · Home Values · Collier County

Sutton Cay Home Values: What Homes Actually Sell For

Buying here? See Sutton Cay homes for sale and the Sutton Cay community guide (Naples).

Sutton Cay (Naples, FL): 4 recorded closings in the 12 months ending 2026-07-29, a 6-year price record, and the year-by-year record — every number from recorded MLS closings, none from an estimate model.

In the current window, sellers accepted a median 90.6% of original asking; the median sale took 75 days (window ending 2026-07-29).

The 6-year recorded price history

Over the recorded series, Sutton Cay’s median sold price moved from $606,495 (2020) to $911,250 (12 months ending 2026-07-29) — +50% over that span, with every year’s figure from recorded closings, not a model.

The last decade in Sutton Cay, briefly

The recorded series starts in 2020 at $606,495. Against the 2023 peak of $1,532,500, the current median stands at -41%. Annual sales volume here has ranged from 2 to 28 closings a year (10-yr average 8.1). With roughly 8.1 closings a year, Sutton Cay’s medians move in steps, not curves — a handful of unusual sales can swing a year, which is why the sales count sits next to every figure above.

What actually trades here: 100% single-family residence, with a median of 2,235 sq ft and a median price per square foot of $408 in the current window.

The Sutton Cay housing stock, from the live feed

From the live MLS feed as of 2026-09-02: The homes listed or recently sold were built between 2020 and 2021 (median 2020); 3 of 4 listed or recently sold homes report an HOA, median $551/mo; 4 of 4 geocoded listed or recently sold homes sit inside a FEMA special flood hazard zone (A/V), which buyers’ lenders will price into insurance; median elevation 9 ft. See the current Sutton Cay listings →

At Sutton Cay’s $911,250 median and Collier County’s adopted 11.05 mills (FY2025-26), a home assessed at that price carries roughly $10,070 a year in property tax before exemptions, or about $9,640 with the full Florida homestead exemption — a buyer’s first-year figure; a long-time owner’s Save Our Homes cap can be far lower, which is one reason resale taxes jump at closing. Municipal and special-district millage varies inside the county; see the Collier County tax page.

Selling in Sutton Cay right now: what the record says

Cash bought 50% of recorded Sutton Cay sales in the window ending 2026-07 (2 of 4) — a fact worth knowing before assuming every buyer needs an appraisal to close. The table above is the closed-sale record to price a Sutton Cay home against; asking prices are an opening position, recorded closings are the value.

How Sutton Cay compares with its neighbors

Communities buyers shopping Sutton Cay are also weighing (nearest by map distance), each on its own recorded 12-month closings. A median well above the neighbors is a ceiling to price against; well below is where the value argument lives.

More Sutton Cay: full community guide & homes for sale · choosing an agent here · should you sell now (statewide data) · what selling costs · cash offer vs. listing

Listing information provided by the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS to be accurate. Compiled from recorded MLS closings; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Figures are medians for the stated windows and change as new sales record; individual homes vary widely. No automated valuation for any specific property appears on this page. Equal Housing Opportunity. © 2026 Move With Momentum LLC — brokerage licensed in FL and GA. Disclosures