Nocatee vs. Julington Creek Plantation: The Numbers, Side by Side
Two of St. Johns County’s most-compared master-planned communities, from MLS closings and district-verified CDD assessments — not opinions. Windows ending 2026-08-05 (Nocatee) and 2026-08-05 (Julington Creek Plantation).
The comparison
| Nocatee | Julington Creek Plantation | |
|---|---|---|
| Median sold price | $661,672 | $520,000 |
| Median $ / sq ft | $282 | $224 |
| Median days on market | 150 days | 29 days |
| Sale-to-original-list | 95.8% | 96.7% |
| New-construction share | 86.2% | 0.0% |
| Closings in window | 152 | 169 |
| Annual CDD assessment (verified) | $1,770–$2,420 (Tolomato CDD SJC FY2025; Duval-side $1,786–$2,197 FY2026) | $1,385 SF / $846 TH (FY2025, secondary source — pending district verification) |
MLS community medians for the stated windows; sample sizes shown. CDD figures from our district-sourced databases: Nocatee CDD fees and the St. Johns County CDD database. Assessments vary by lot width, product, and bond series.
Reading it honestly
Neither community “wins” — they price different products. The table shows what buyers actually paid, how fast homes moved, how much negotiation happened (sale-to-original-list), how much builder inventory competes with resales, and what the annual district assessment adds to carrying cost. Full guides: Nocatee · Julington Creek Plantation. Selling in either? St. Johns County sell-now data.
Community medians move month to month and mix product types; the Nocatee row aggregates its flagship record while individual villages vary widely (see the per-village CDD table). Julington Creek Plantation’s CDD figure is secondary-sourced pending district verification. Verify everything for a specific address before offering.
Market figures are per-community MLS snapshot medians for the stated windows, compiled from the feeds Momentum Realty licenses; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. CDD figures transcribed from adopted district budgets and official assessment schedules as documented on the linked database pages. Updated monthly as snapshots refresh.