458 DEER CROSSING Road, St. Augustine, FL 32086
458 DEER CROSSING Road, St. Augustine, FL 32086
Sources: realMLS (listings + 12-mo closed sales), FEMA, modeled insurance. Interpretation: Momentum Research. Data notes
- No CDD assessment on record
- Built 2016 · 10 yrs
- 1,895 sq ft of living area
- 3-car garage
- Listed at $475,000 — recent neighborhood median sale price ~$384,750 (nearby sales; deemed reliable, not an appraisal)
- 8 days on market
- HOA ~$50/mo (estimate; confirm)
Pricing & the Deerfield Preserve market
How this home is priced against recent nearby sales, and where Deerfield Preserve has been over 25 years. Momentum Research analysis of realMLS records; closed sales, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Estimates only; see data notes.
This home’s $/sq ft vs. nearby sales
List $/sq ft against recent nearby closed sales; the community median is marked.
Price vs. size in Deerfield Preserve
Each dot is a closed sale since 2015 (260 total). This home is the gold marker.
Sale price (y) by living area in sq ft (x). realMLS closed sales.
Median $/sq ft by year
Community sold $/sq ft, 2016–2026. This home lists at $251/sq ft.
Median sale price by year
12-month median closed price, 2016–2026.
Market Heat by year (0–100)
Momentum Market Heat, 2016–2026. Now 48 (normal).
This home’s history
- 2016BuiltPer public record
- Jul 10, 2026First trackedObserved at $475,000
- NowActiveCurrently for sale
Build year is from public record. Listing milestones reflect movewithmomentum.com’s own observations since we began tracking this listing and are not the MLS listing history; dates and prices are deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Estimated monthly payment
- Principal & interest $2,407/mo 81%
- Taxes $340/mo 12%
- Insurance $158/mo 5%
- HOA $50/mo 2%
$2,955/mo at 20% down, 30-yr @ 6.52% · edit any field to update.
Editable estimate — not a loan offer. Estimates only; see data & estimate notes.
Momentum Property Score
46/100 is below average across the objective indicators below. It reflects only those measures — not the home’s quality, condition, or desirability.
A 0-100 score built from objective property and market data: flood risk, insurance, pricing, supply, affordability, and recent sales. Higher means more measures line up in a buyer’s favor. It reflects only the factors below.
Momentum Scores are objective, rules-based indicators computed from listing facts, public records, and recent nearby sales. They are not appraisals, valuations, investment advice, or judgments about a neighborhood or who should live there. Verify independently.
The Momentum read
🟠 Seller-leaning conditions around this listing. 2.4 months of supply in the surrounding market and 8 days on market for this home, against a 50-day area median.Days on market:this home 8Area median: 50 daysWhy it matters: above-median time on market, together with the level of supply, is a clear sign of how much leverage sits with buyers.Momentum Research interpretation of the MLS facts in the snapshot above. Source: Data provided by realMLS. As of July 14, 2026.
🟡 Asking $251 per square foot, about 18% above the community’s $213 median. Deerfield Preserve’s 12-month median sold price per square foot is $213. Median sold price per square foot is down 7.3% year over year. Confidence: Medium · 10 closed sales in 12 monthsMLS facts: realMLS closed sales. A per-square-foot gap is context, not an appraisal; condition, lot, and view set the final number here.
Recent Deerfield Preserve sales closed near 95.9% of original asking. Cash paid for about 67% of recent closings here.Why it matters: the community’s own record shows how far opening prices typically move, and how often buyers compete without financing.Momentum Research analysis of realMLS records, community-level, 12 months ending July 14, 2026. Aggregates only; deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
What’s unique here: one of only 2 active listings in Deerfield Preserve, no CDD assessment.
Jump to: About this home · Every number, sourced · Monthly cost · Flood & risk · History · FAQ
Updated July 15, 2026 · MLS facts carry their source; interpretation lines are Momentum Research · Data sources & freshness
About this home
458 Deer Crossing Road represents an upper echelon opportunity within the highly desirable Deerfield Preserve community, offering one of the largest homesites in the neighborhood with more than 100 feet of tranquil lake frontage, unobstructed water views, an expansive backyard, a large paver driveway, a rare three car garage, and the added peace of mind of a newer roof. Beautifully maintained and thoughtfully upgraded, this move in ready home combines quality craftsmanship with an ideal floor plan designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The open concept kitchen, dining, and living areas flow seamlessly together while showcasing breathtaking lake views, filling the home with natural light and beautiful morning sunrises.
Elegant tray ceilings, crown molding, and tasteful finishes enhance the home's spacious feel, while the dedicated flex room provides the perfect space for a home office, playroom, fitness room, or additional living area. The generous primary suite offers peaceful water views, a spacious walk in closet, and a well appointed en suite bath, while the split bedroom layout provides exceptional privacy and functionality for family and guests alike. Step outside to the expansive screened lanai and adjoining patio where you can enjoy your morning coffee overlooking the lake, evening dinners under the stars, and refreshing afternoon ocean breezes.
The fully fenced backyard, oversized side yards, and adjoining community green space create an exceptional sense of privacy while providing abundant room for pets, play, or future outdoor enhancements. The oversized three car garage offers outstanding space for vehicles, golf carts, tools, kayaks, and all of your Florida lifestyle essentials. Additional highlights include natural gas, a tankless water heater, gas fireplace, well irrigation, a water softener, whole house water filtration system, newer flooring and carpet, a gas range, updated dishwasher, and an electric washer and dryer.
Deerfield Preserve is a natural gas community known for its spacious homesites, abundant green space, and outstanding amenities including a zero entry pool, fitness center, playground, basketball court, and community gathering areas. Ideally located just minutes from shopping, dining, golf courses, beautiful beaches, top rated St. Johns County schools, Interstate 95, and the charm of Historic Downtown St.
Augustine, this home offers the perfect blend of luxury, convenience, and everyday Florida living. Opportunities to own one of the premier waterfront homes in Deerfield Preserve are exceptionally rare. Schedule your private showing today.
Description provided by THE NEWCOMER GROUP and reproduced from the MLS; not independently verified.
Every fact, sourced
Listing data, public records, our calculations, and what to verify — each fact shown once. Estimates and calculations shown are for general information only, are not appraisals or advice, and should be independently verified.
Listing facts MLS
Public records & third-party data
Calculated estimates
Buyer should verify Buyer verify
The Messtimate
This is a deliberately dumb estimate — living area times a range of recent neighborhood $/sq ft, and nothing else. It is not an appraisal, not market value, and not a valuation of this home. Even a tight range from comparable sales can’t price a specific home — here’s why.
Actual list price: $475,000 — compare it against the range above. The Messtimate is a blind sqft estimate; the list price reflects this specific home.
A 5% spread on the same house — and that gap is exactly what an automated guess can't see:
- Condition & updates — a renovated kitchen or new roof vs. dated finishes can swing value six figures; sq ft can't see it.
- The lot & views — a premium golf, water, or preserve lot vs. a road-facing one: same sq ft, very different price.
- Outliers skew it — one flip or distressed sale in the comps drags the whole $/sq ft up or down.
- Carrying costs & concessions — CDD, HOA, insurance, and seller-paid buydowns change what a buyer actually pays.
And here's what the live market is doing — which the number above ignores entirely:
- This home: 8 days on market vs. a 50-day community median
- 2 active listings competing, 2 under contract
- ≈2.4 months of supply
- 10 closed here in the last 12 months
For reference, this home is listed at $475,000 ($251/sq ft) — a number set with analysis a Messtimate can't do.
Selling your own home? Try the Messtimate on your address →
Methodology: 1,895 sq ft × $202–$213/sq ft from recent nearby closed sales (public records). Estimate for general information only; not an appraisal, valuation, or offer. Updated July 15, 2026.
Similar homes for sale near Deerfield Preserve
Active listings nearby at a comparable size and price. Listings held by brokerages other than Momentum Realty are marked with the listing broker. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Price & listing history
Building permits
- No CDD assessment on record
- FEMA Zone X — flood insurance generally not federally required
- Built 2016 · 10 yrs
- 1,895 sq ft of living area
- 3-car garage
- $251/sq ft — compared with the displayed median of $212 from recent nearby sales
- Listed at $475,000 — recent neighborhood median sale price ~$395,500 (nearby sales; deemed reliable, not an appraisal)
- New to market
- HOA ~$50/mo (estimate; confirm)
This listing is shown at $475,000, with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, and 1,895 square feet. The page displays an estimated monthly payment, FEMA flood-zone information, estimated ownership costs, a source-tagged Momentum Fact Check, and recent comparable-sale data where available. All estimates should be independently verified.
The whole picture, at a glance
Property
Financial
Risk
Market
Estimates and calculations shown are for general information only, are not appraisals or advice, and should be independently verified.
The numbers, at a glance
Estimated monthly payment
- Principal & interest $2,477/mo 82%
- Taxes $340/mo 11%
- Insurance $158/mo 5%
- HOA $50/mo 2%
Estimates and calculations shown are for general information only, are not appraisals or advice, and should be independently verified.
Momentum Property Score
A rules-based composite of the objective indicators below — each computed from listing facts, public records, and recent nearby sales, not opinion.
How to read it: a higher score means more of these objective measures line up in a buyer’s favor — for example, priced competitively against recent nearby sales, lower carrying costs, or lower flood risk. A lower score means fewer do. It reflects only the indicators below — not the home’s quality, condition, or desirability, and nothing about who should live there.
Momentum Scores are objective, rules-based indicators computed from listing facts, public records, and recent nearby sales. They are not appraisals, valuations, investment advice, or judgments about a neighborhood or who should live there. Verify independently.
The home
- Year built2016
- Per public record.
- Property typeSingle Family Residence
- Per the listing.
Costs
- HOA$50/mo
- Disclosure — confirm exact dues and inclusions.
- CDD assessmentNone on record
- Estimate/disclosure — confirm the parcel's actual CDD with the county.
- Est. first-year tax~$4,085/yr
- Opinion/estimate at typical county millage — your assessed bill will differ. Do not rely on this.
Site & risk
- FEMA flood zoneZone X · minimal hazard (FEMA)
- From the FEMA flood map; verify the parcel.
- Ground elevation~37 ft
- Approximate parcel elevation (USGS).
- WindstormModerate
- Coastal exposure varies; obtain an insurer quote.
Please note. Figures such as estimated taxes, insurance, CDD/HOA amounts, payments, and any market or comparable-sales summary are opinions and estimates for general information only, may be inaccurate, are not appraisals or advice, and should not be relied upon. Verify everything independently before making any decision.
Pricing & market trend in Deerfield Preserve
How this home's list $/sq ft compares with recent nearby closed sales, and how prices in the community have moved. Public-record reference only — not an appraisal or a statement of value.
This home's $/sq ft vs. nearby sales
Recent sold prices in this community
The Messtimate: $382,790 – $411,215
This is a deliberately dumb estimate — living area times a range of recent neighborhood $/sq ft, and nothing else. It is not an appraisal, not market value, and not a valuation of this home. Even a tight range from comparable sales can’t price a specific home — here’s why.
Actual list price: $475,000 — compare it against the range above. The Messtimate is a blind sqft estimate; the list price reflects this specific home.
A 7% spread on the same house — and that gap is exactly what an automated guess can't see:
- Condition & updates — a renovated kitchen, new roof, or older interior finishes can swing value six figures. Sq ft can't see it.
- The lot — a premium waterfront, conservation, or cul-de-sac lot vs. a road-facing one: same sq ft, very different price.
- Outliers skew it — one flip or one distressed sale in the comps drags the whole $/sq ft up or down.
- Layout & beds/baths — two homes at 2,000 sq ft with 3/2 vs. 4/3 don't sell for the same number.
- Views & orientation — golf, water, or preserve views aren't in the square footage.
- Upgrades & systems — solar, pool, impact windows, new HVAC: real money, invisible to a calculator.
- Unpermitted or mismeasured sq ft — public records are often wrong, and unpermitted additions don't count.
- Carrying costs — CDD bonds, HOA dues, and flood-zone insurance change what a buyer will actually pay.
- Timing & concessions — the market moves monthly, and seller-paid rate buydowns hide the true price.
- School zoning & micro-location — one street over can mean a different school, and a different price.
And here's what the live market is doing — which the number above ignores entirely:
- This home: 3 days on market vs. a ~3-day neighborhood median
- 3 active listings competing in Deerfield Preserve
- 1 under contract now
- 25% of for-sale inventory is currently under contract (under contract + pending, as a share of all for-sale inventory)
- ≈3.3 months of supply (one market-context metric; should not be used alone)
- Median sale price is up 85% over the last 86 months
- Homes here sell at about 98.1% of list price
- 11 closed here in the last 12 months
For reference, this home is listed at $475,000 ($251/sq ft) — a number set with analysis a Messtimate can't do.
Selling your own home? Try the Messtimate on your address →
Methodology: 1,895 sq ft × $202–$217/sq ft from recent nearby closed sales (public records). Estimate for general information only; not an appraisal, valuation, or offer. Updated July 10, 2026.
Deerfield Preserve market analysis
Local market conditions - current inventory and, where available, recent trends. Reference only, not a forecast or valuation. Source: realMLS (Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service).
Current area inventory and velocity from live MLS counts. Reference only, not a forecast or valuation.
Median sale price
Median $/sq ft
Median days on market
Homes sold per month
This home’s history
- 2016BuiltPer public record
- NowActiveCurrently for sale
Build year is from public record. Listing milestones reflect movewithmomentum.com’s own observations since we began tracking this listing and are not the MLS listing history; dates and prices are deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Investment snapshot
Objective rental and cash-flow estimates for a buyer weighing this as an investment. Rough figures for general information only — not a guarantee of rent, an appraisal, or investment advice. Verify independently.
Every number, sourced
We separate what is listing data, what comes from public records, what we calculate or estimate, and what a buyer should verify. Estimates and calculations shown are for general information only, are not appraisals or advice, and should be independently verified.
Listing facts MLS
Public records & third-party data
Calculated estimates
Buyer should verify Buyer verify
Estimate a monthly payment
A tool to estimate a monthly payment. All values are editable estimates, not a loan offer or a statement about this property. Property tax, insurance, CDD, and HOA figures are approximations — verify each independently.
Down payment $95,000 · Loan $380,000. Estimate only — not a loan offer. We'll connect you with a local lender for an exact quote.
>>>>>>> origin/mainRequest a tour or info
Tell us how to reach you and a licensed Momentum Realty agent will follow up about 458 DEER CROSSING Road.
Sold price and details are from public records and the MLS, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Shown for comparison only — not an appraisal or a statement of this home's value.