Momentum Housing Data · Seller Diagnostics · Statewide

Why Isn’t My House Selling? Florida’s Failure Data, County by County

73,800 Florida listings came off the market unsold in the trailing 12 months — about 20 for every 100 new listings. Nobody advertises this number. It is the honest starting point for any seller whose home is sitting: failure is common, measurable, and in the recorded data, mostly about price behavior.

SOURCE  Licensed MLS feeds, off-market transition records SCOPE  34 counties, each from its authoritative feedCOMPILED  August 27, 2026

Failure rates by county

CountyFailed per 100 newFailed (12 mo)Median days before giving up (sample)Never cut price (sample)
Broward County3214,99117143%
Palm Beach County2811,76515640%
St. Lucie County272,90417326%
Putnam County27345
Charlotte County251,99117947%
Martin County2593917449%
Nassau County24544
Volusia County231,89618245%
Flagler County23243
Duval County214,078
Sarasota County202,92717947%
Highlands County20125
Osceola County192,24919053%
Levy County19128
St. Johns County181,662
Baker County1863
Citrus County18635
Brevard County182,84817340%
Marion County172,09118149%
Clay County17844
Pinellas County173,83817545%
Bradford County1747
Polk County162,71818161%
Manatee County162,06417847%
Sumter County14362
Lake County141,40417849%
Orange County132,75117249%
Hernando County1364918439%
Santa Rosa County12584107
Hillsborough County122,94817752%
Pasco County121,94917849%
Alachua County1147218153%
Seminole County1066017756%
Bay County15431%
Collier County17438%
Escambia County77
Hendry County15055%
Lee County15341%
Miami-Dade County17256%
Okaloosa County11327%
Walton County17432%

Failed = expired + withdrawn only; canceled listings are excluded as relist churn. Days-listed and never-cut figures come from our 2026 record sample and appear only where the county sample is large enough to be meaningful.

What the failed listings have in common

Across the 2026 sample, roughly four in ten failed listings never reduced their price, and the ones that did cut a median of about 6% — late and in small steps. Meanwhile successful sales in most counties close within a few percent of original ask in their first weeks. The gap between those two behaviors is the diagnosis. Each county page runs it with local numbers: Broward County, Palm Beach County, and every county in the table above.

Run your numbers

What selling would actually net you · Should you sell now or wait — the data verdict · How much of Florida’s inventory has already cut price · A Momentum agent can pull your street’s closed comparables and tell you honestly whether the problem is price, presentation, or patience.

What this page won’t do

No fear-bait and no false comfort. These are recorded counts from licensed feeds with the method stated, published because sellers deserve the same data agents see.

Methodology

Failure rate: expired + withdrawn listings relative to new listings entering, trailing 12 months, per county from its authoritative MLS feed only (no cross-feed double counting); counties floor at 100 new listings. Behavior sample: expired/withdrawn records with 2026 terminal dates from feed event logs. General information, not advice; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity.