Community Details at a Glance
The Homes
Type
Single-family
Size
~1,400-2,400 sq ft
Built
1980s onward
Layout
3 to 4 bed typical
Costs & Fees
HOA
Confirm per home
Flood zone
Verify parcel
Insurance
Quote early
Amenities
Setting
Established streets
Yards
Mid-size lots
Schools
Brevard Public Schools
Parks
City parks nearby
Location
Setting
South Titusville
Job corridor
Kennedy Space Center reachable
Highway
US-1 and I-95 access
The Homes: Mid-Size and Settled
Hickory Hill's homes run from smaller plans around 1,400 square feet through larger four bedroom homes in the low 2,400s. Most are concrete-block single-family construction with garages and mid-size yards, the kind of practical Titusville housing that holds up when it is maintained.
Because the stock dates largely to the 1980s, the spread between homes is about condition, not floor plan. A home with a newer roof, updated HVAC and a clean flood designation can carry far cheaper and resell far easier than an otherwise similar home that has deferred those items. That is the single most important thing to read here.
For value buyers and Space Coast workers, that asymmetry is an opportunity: a smaller, well-maintained home on a good street can be a better long-term buy than a larger one with an aging roof and dated systems. We run both before you commit.
What Living Here Is Actually Like
The rhythm of Hickory Hill life, from the neighborhood and our time in south Titusville:
A typical week
The commute factor
The insurance reality
What residents grumble about
The Hickory Hill Buyer Checklist
- Pull the FEMA flood designation for the parcel before you offer.
- Get the roof age and system dates, HVAC, water heater, electrical, in writing.
- Quote insurance early on the specific home.
- Confirm any HOA and what it covers, or confirm there is none.
- Comp by street and condition, not the neighborhood average.
- Walk the lot for drainage, low spots and standing water tell a story.
- Drive your real commute to the job corridor at the time you would actually drive it.
Hickory Hill is the kind of honest, value-tier Titusville neighborhood I am happy to put buyers in, as long as they read the home the right way. The trap is falling for square footage on a home with a twenty-year-old roof and a flood zone nobody checked. The fix is simple: pull the roof date, the flood designation and an insurance quote before you offer, not after.
My other consistent advice is to weigh condition over cosmetics. A smaller, well-maintained home on a good street will treat you better over five years than a bigger one hiding deferred maintenance. We run both numbers every time.
Hickory Hill vs. the Alternatives
The honest comparison set for a Hickory Hill buyer in Titusville:
| Community | Type | Fees (approx.) | The trade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hickory Hill | Single-family resale | Confirm HOA (modest or none) | Value-tier single-family, condition-driven |
| Sherwood Forest | Deed-restricted, golf setting | Confirm HOA dues | Golf-course setting, deed restrictions, HOA |
| La Cita Towns | Townhomes in golf community | Confirm HOA dues | Lock-and-leave townhomes, golf community |
| Lakefront Estates | Smaller-plan single-family | Confirm HOA | Smaller, affordable plans, entry pricing |
The pattern: Hickory Hill wins on mid-size single-family value; Sherwood Forest wins on the golf-course setting; La Cita on townhome lock-and-leave; Lakefront Estates on entry price. There is no wrong answer, only a wrong match for your priorities.
The Honest Pros & Cons
What Hickory Hill gets right
- Established, owner-occupied single-family streets
- Mid-size homes at value-tier Titusville pricing
- Reasonable carrying costs, modest or no HOA
- Within reach of the Space Coast job corridor
- US-1 and I-95 access for commuting
- Practical concrete-block construction
What to go in eyes-open about
- Older stock means roof and system age matter
- Flood zone varies by parcel; verify before offering
- Insurance can run higher on aging roofs
- No clubhouse, gate or resort amenities
- A real commute to Orlando or Melbourne job centers
- Launch-day traffic on the causeways


















