Pine Island Homes for Sale in St James City, FL
Pine Island is one community to a buyer and 4 to the MLS: each phase, tract or condominium was platted and recorded separately, so its listings, sales and HOA facts sit on separate records. This page adds them up and links every section, so you can compare prices across Pine Island before you narrow to one street.
Pine Island in St James City, FL is 4 MLS subdivisions, with 23 homes for sale or pending across them as of September 11, 2026. Asking prices run $109,900 to $1,700,000 (median $359,000). Over the last 12 months the sections recorded 44 closed sales at a median of $284,250, $229 per square foot, a median 65 days on market. Homes listed today were built 1959–2025. The MLS holds 490 closed sales for Pine Island in total, the most recent in July 2026.
Pine Island homes for sale by section
Click a section for its own page: the homes for sale there, its sales history, HOA and flood facts.
| Section | For sale | Median asking | Sold / 12 mo | Median sold | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pine Island Cove | 10 | $155,750 | 15 | $167,500 | 65 |
| Pine Island Shores | 7 | $725,000 | 17 | $695,000 | 41 |
| Pine Island Tropical Homesites | 4 | $359,000 | 10 | $284,250 | 193 |
| Pine Island Village | 2 | $437,500 | 2 | — | — |
How to read Pine Island prices
Sections of one community can price very differently: build year, lot size, water or golf frontage and HOA scope all move the median. Compare the section medians above before judging a single listing, and treat the community-wide median as the reference point, not a value for any specific home.
Common questions
How many homes are for sale in Pine Island?
What do homes in Pine Island cost?
Why does Pine Island have 4 pages?
Keep exploring
Live data: Florida Gulf Coast MLS, refreshed with every MLS pull; this page rebuilds on every ship. Community-level aggregates only for the 4 MLS sections of Pine Island; no individual listing is displayed here. Prices are asking or recorded sale prices, not values. Property facts only; nothing on this page describes residents. Equal Housing Opportunity.