Market Brief
Sarasota County commissioners voted 3-2 on November 17, 2026 not to appeal a court order that lets an 864-apartment D.R. Horton project near Celery Fields proceed under the Live Local Act, a decision that clears the way for more than 7,600 proposed units across 18 projects.
Sarasota County will not appeal a Live Local ruling, opening review for 7,600+ proposed apartments in rural areas. What changed and where prices sit.

Sarasota County commissioners voted 3-2 on November 17, 2026 not to appeal a November 4 order from Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll, Suncoast Searchlight reported. The order lets D.R. Horton's plan for 864 apartments in 65-foot buildings on a 51-acre site near Celery Fields move through county review under the state's Live Local Act. The decision clears the way for more than 7,600 proposed units across 18 projects in rural parts of the county. Single-family homes in Sarasota ZIP 34240, which takes in the area east of Interstate 75, sold at a median $798,000 from August to October, according to our Market Pulse.
This piece covers what the court decided, what the county did next and where home prices stand near the proposed sites. Monthly Sarasota and Manatee prices, pace and sales are on the Sarasota market data hub.
What did the judge rule on Live Local in Sarasota County?
The Live Local Act, passed in 2023, lets developers skip traditional public hearings and some local zoning rules when rents on part of a project are tied to households earning under 120% of area median income, Sarasota Magazine reported. A later amendment requires those projects to be allowed in any zoning district that permits some commercial or industrial use.
Sarasota County had argued that limited commercial uses in its rural districts, such as veterinary clinics and plant nurseries, are part of the rural character of those areas and do not open them to Live Local apartments. Rural zoning there generally allows one home per 5 acres, and some areas allow as few as one home per 10 acres. Judge Carroll rejected the county's argument and ruled that the Celery Fields project must be allowed to proceed through review.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Court order | November 4, 2026, Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll |
| County vote not to appeal | November 17, 2026, 3-2 |
| Lead project | D.R. Horton, 864 apartments, 65-foot buildings |
| Site | 51 acres south of Fruitville Road, east of I-75, near Celery Fields |
| Earlier plan on the site | 85 single-family homes, rejected by the county |
| Proposed Live Local projects countywide | 18, more than 7,600 units |
| Other pending suits | Four, before the same judge |
Sources: Suncoast Searchlight, November 17, 2026; Sarasota Magazine, November 6, 2026.
The ruling covers only the Celery Fields project. Five other developers filed similar suits, and four were still pending before Judge Carroll when the order was issued. Suncoast Searchlight reported that his reasoning is expected to apply to those cases.
What happens next for the Celery Fields site?
The project still has to meet every other requirement of the county land development code, and commissioners voted after the decision to let the county attorney try to buy the property, Suncoast Searchlight reported. Commissioner Teresa Mast, whose district includes Celery Fields, cited flooding from 2024 storms. The site sits beside a county stormwater facility.
An attorney for D.R. Horton told commissioners the builder would drop the Live Local application if the county approved a 126-home plan it had rejected before.
Under the act, a winning party can recover court costs of up to $250,000, according to Sarasota Magazine. County Attorney Joshua Moye had warned in a memo that defending the rural exclusion would be "an uphill battle."
Where do Sarasota home prices stand near the proposed sites?
The 18 proposals are in rural parts of the county. Our Pulse tracks single-family closings by ZIP code in and around those areas:
| Area | Period | Sales | Median price | Median days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sarasota County | Oct 2026 | 591 | $490,000 | 35 |
| Manatee County | Oct 2026 | 552 | $499,450 | 44 |
| ZIP 34240, Sarasota | Aug to Oct 2026 | 109 | $798,000 | 30 |
| ZIP 34241, Sarasota | Aug to Oct 2026 | 94 | $673,750 | 60.5 |
| ZIP 34243, Sarasota | Aug to Oct 2026 | 85 | $480,000 | 14 |
| ZIP 34232, Sarasota | Aug to Oct 2026 | 65 | $387,000 | 21 |
| ZIP 34202, Lakewood Ranch | Aug to Oct 2026 | 139 | $735,000 | 59 |
Source: Momentum Market Pulse, Stellar, October 2026 edition, single-family closings. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
ZIP 34240's median is about 63% above the county's October single-family median, while ZIP 34232, west of the interstate, sold about 21% below it. Houses in ZIP 34243 sold in a median 14 days, the quickest of the group, while ZIP 34241 took 60.5 days.
Apartments approved under Live Local add rental supply rather than homes for sale, so the effect on these sale prices, if any, would come over years as projects are built.
Our Amendment 3 budget piece covers how the new homestead exemption affects county budgets, and our Sarasota and Manatee ZIP codes piece ranks every ZIP by sale pace. The Sarasota and Lakewood Ranch pages carry current listings.
People also ask
What is the Live Local Act? A 2023 Florida law that lets developers bypass traditional public hearings and some local zoning rules when rents on part of a project are tied to households earning under 120% of area median income.
Why did Sarasota County drop its Live Local appeal? Commissioners voted 3-2 on November 17, 2026 not to appeal Judge Hunter W. Carroll's November 4 order, which held that the county could not exclude its rural districts from the act.
How many apartments are proposed under Live Local in Sarasota County? More than 7,600 units across 18 projects, according to Suncoast Searchlight, including 864 apartments proposed by D.R. Horton near Celery Fields.
What is the median home price in Sarasota ZIP 34240? Single-family homes in ZIP 34240 sold at a median $798,000 from August to October 2026 on 109 sales, according to the Momentum Market Pulse.
Limitations
Project and court details come from two news reports by the same nonprofit newsroom; unit counts, designs and timing can change during county review, and the county may still try to buy the Celery Fields site. Rents for the proposed apartments have not been published. Market Pulse figures are computed by Momentum from Stellar MLS single-family closings; county figures cover October 2026 only and ZIP figures cover August to October 2026, ZIPs do not match the project areas exactly, and the figures are deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Sources
- Sarasota County gives up Live Local lawsuit, clears way for Celery Fields development, Suncoast Searchlight, November 17, 2026.
- Judge Deals Death Blow to Sarasota County's Fight Against Live Local Act, Sarasota Magazine (Suncoast Searchlight), November 6, 2026.
- Momentum Market Pulse, Stellar, October 2026 edition, Momentum Research report built from Stellar MLS records, generated November 18, 2026.
- Sarasota market data hub, Momentum Research.
Disclosure: Jon Brooks is a co-founder of Momentum Realty, a Florida real estate brokerage that owns and funds Florida Housing Intelligence. Momentum has a financial interest in Florida real estate transactions, including in markets named here. See our editorial standards.
Market statistics in this article are computed from MLS data licensed by Momentum Realty, and are current as of the date shown. Data may be preliminary and subject to revision by its source. This article is general information, not advice about any specific property, transaction, or financial decision, and is not a representation about any specific property, community, builder, or association.
Equal Housing Opportunity. Editorial standards · Corrections · About
