Momentum Research · Market data

Market Brief

Two of the five operators bidding to run Lower Keys Medical Center on Stock Island have put workforce housing money in their offers: $100 million from current operator Community Health Systems and $130 million from Mount Sinai.

Five operators remain for the Lower Keys Medical Center lease. Two pledge $100M to $130M for worker housing; Key West homes sell near $1.16M.

Two of the five operators competing for the next lease of Lower Keys Medical Center on Stock Island have included workforce housing money in their proposals, the Keys Citizen reported on November 12, 2026. Current operator Community Health Systems (CHS) lists $100 million for workforce housing assistance, including employee stipends, and Mount Sinai lists $130 million. Baptist Health and Larkin Health System made no specific housing commitment. The current lease ends April 30, 2029. For context, homes in Key West ZIP 33040 sold at a median $1,160,000 from August to October 2026 across 60 closings, according to our Florida Keys Market Pulse.

This piece covers what each bidder offered, when the board decides and why housing money is part of the bids. Monthly price, pace and sales figures for Monroe County are on the Florida Keys market data hub.

Who is bidding to run Lower Keys Medical Center?

The publicly owned hospital at 5900 College Road is leased to a private operator. The local hospital board's request for proposals closed on September 28, and seven responses came in. One was ruled non-responsive and HCA Healthcare later withdrew, leaving five: Sana Healthcare, Baptist Health, Community Health Systems, Larkin Health System and Mount Sinai. The article reports these headline commitments:

BidderHeadline commitmentNew hospitalWorkforce housing
Community Health Systems (current operator)$740 million over the lease term$250 million within 10 years$100 million, including employee stipends
Mount Sinai$1.2 billion over a 30-year lease$250 million within 10 years$130 million
Baptist HealthNot stated as a total$200 million within five yearsNo specific commitment
Larkin Health System$337 million in reinvestmentNo new hospitalNo specific commitment
Sana HealthcareNot detailed in the reportNot detailedNot detailed

Source: Keys Citizen, November 12, 2026. The report notes the bidders used different methods, so the totals are not directly comparable.

The CHS figure also includes $65 million for equipment and technology, $190 million for physician recruitment and a $90 million community fund. Mount Sinai proposes returning all net hospital income to the Lower Keys with no management fees.

When will the hospital board decide?

The board met on November 10 at the DoubleTree Grand Key Resort. Mandatory in-person interviews with the bidders are set for December 1 to 3 and are closed to the public, replacing the board's regular December meeting. A public meeting to share interview findings and compare proposals is expected in January 2027. An earlier report put a final decision more than a year away, and the new lease is expected to run about 30 years.

Why are hospital bidders offering housing money?

Housing cost is a recruiting issue for every large employer in the Keys, and a hospital needs nurses, technicians and support staff who live within commuting distance. A pledge of $100 million to $130 million is large next to local home prices. Spread over home purchases at Key West's recent median, it would equal the full price of roughly 86 to 112 homes, though neither bidder has said how the money would be split between stipends, rentals or ownership.

Our October Market Pulse shows where Lower Keys prices sit. These figures cover sales from August through October 2026 in ZIP codes with at least 15 closings:

ZIPAreaClosingsMedian sale priceMedian days on market
33040Key West and Stock Island60$1,160,00065.5
33042Cudjoe Key area52$1,075,00063.5
33043Big Pine Key28$846,50096
33050Marathon48$1,350,00083.5

Source: Momentum Market Pulse, Florida Keys, October 2026 edition, built by Momentum from Florida Keys MLS records. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Even Big Pine Key, the lowest median on the map, sat above $800,000. Lower-cost options in the Keys are mostly condos and manufactured homes: in October alone the Pulse recorded 15 condo sales at a median $883,500 and 8 manufactured home sales at a median $447,500 across Monroe County. Pages for Key West, Stock Island, Cudjoe Key, Big Pine Key and Marathon carry current local listings and prices.

How does this connect to new housing supply in the Keys?

Money alone does not create units in the Keys. New homes need a building allocation under Monroe County's rate-of-growth system, and our building rights piece covers the county's revised plan for 657 new allocations in unincorporated Monroe County, which returns to commissioners on November 17. A hospital operator with a housing budget would still need allocations, land and approvals to add units, or it could use the money on rent help and purchase assistance for existing homes.

What should Keys owners and buyers watch next?

For buyers, the near-term signal is January's public comparison of proposals, which should show how each bidder would deliver its housing money. No bidder has said whether it would buy, lease or subsidize homes for staff. Our Monroe County tax bill piece and same-home resale piece cover carrying costs and how prices have moved for homes that sold twice.

People also ask

Who is bidding for the Lower Keys Medical Center lease? Five operators remain: Sana Healthcare, Baptist Health, Community Health Systems (the current operator), Larkin Health System and Mount Sinai. HCA Healthcare withdrew, according to the Keys Citizen on November 12, 2026.

Which Lower Keys hospital bidders include workforce housing? Community Health Systems lists $100 million for workforce housing assistance, including employee stipends, and Mount Sinai lists $130 million. Baptist Health and Larkin made no specific housing commitment.

When does the Lower Keys Medical Center lease expire? The current lease with Community Health Systems expires April 30, 2029. Bidder interviews are set for December 1 to 3, 2026, with a public comparison expected in January 2027.

What is the median home price in Key West? Homes in Key West ZIP 33040 sold at a median $1,160,000 from August to October 2026 across 60 closings, with a median 65.5 days on market, according to the Momentum Market Pulse.

Limitations

Bid details come from one news report and the bidders' own summaries, which use different methods and are not directly comparable; terms can change during interviews and negotiation. The homes-equivalent figure is a simple division of each pledge by the Key West ZIP median and does not describe how any bidder would spend the money. ZIP figures cover August to October 2026 in ZIPs with at least 15 closings; county property-type figures cover October 2026 only. Market figures are computed by Momentum from Florida Keys MLS records and are deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Sources

Disclosure: Jon Brooks is a co-founder of Momentum Realty, a Florida real estate brokerage that owns and funds Florida Housing Intelligence. Momentum has a financial interest in Florida real estate transactions, including in markets named here. See our editorial standards.

All nineteen Florida markets · Housing data release calendar

Market statistics in this article are computed from MLS data licensed by Momentum Realty, and are current as of the date shown. Data may be preliminary and subject to revision by its source. This article is general information, not advice about any specific property, transaction, or financial decision, and is not a representation about any specific property, community, builder, or association.

Equal Housing Opportunity. Editorial standards · Corrections · About