The Best Neighborhoods in Umatilla, FL (2026)
Looking for the best neighborhoods in Umatilla? Instead of opinions, we ranked Umatilla’s 18 communities by the numbers that actually matter when you’re choosing where to live — how fast homes sell, price per square foot, and how values are moving. Here’s where Umatilla stands, by the data (as of 2026-06-16).
Fastest-selling neighborhoods in Umatilla
Where homes sell quickest — a sign of strong buyer demand. (Lowest median days on market, communities with recent closings.)
- SILVER BEACH HEIGHTS — 53 days on market · $336,000
- EAST UMATILLA — 79 days on market · $306,000
- Seasons at Magnolia Pointe — 326 days on market · $347,000
Most affordable neighborhoods in Umatilla (price per sq ft)
The lowest median price per square foot in Umatilla — where your dollar stretches furthest.
- Seasons at Magnolia Pointe — $157/sq ft · $347,000
- SILVER BEACH HEIGHTS — $173/sq ft · $336,000
- EAST UMATILLA — $213/sq ft · $306,000
Top neighborhoods in Umatilla by Momentum Score
Momentum’s overall 0-100 market score blends value, demand, and momentum.
- EAST UMATILLA — score 82 · $306,000
- Seasons at Magnolia Pointe — score 54 · $347,000
- SILVER BEACH HEIGHTS — score 45 · $336,000
How we ranked these
These lists come from Momentum’s MLS data for Umatilla, limited to communities with recent closings so the numbers are meaningful. ‘Fastest-selling’ uses median days on market, ‘most affordable’ uses median price per square foot, ‘fastest-appreciating’ uses the 1-year price change, and the Momentum Score is our overall 0-100 read on each market. The right neighborhood for you also depends on schools, commute, and lifestyle — use these as a data-driven starting point.
Explore Umatilla further
Common questions
What are the best neighborhoods in Umatilla?
What’s the median home price in Umatilla?
How were these Umatilla neighborhoods ranked?
Rankings are aggregates from Momentum Realty’s MLS data for Umatilla, as of 2026-06-16, and change over time. A data-driven starting point, not a guarantee or an endorsement of any community. Equal Housing Opportunity.