St. James City neighborhoods with the market data that actually moves a decision.
17 St. James City community guides, each with real pricing, HOA/CDD reality, and flood/insurance posture. Below: the St. James City market snapshot, then every community we cover.
Community-level market data for this city is compiled from MLS closed sales and fills in here as sales history accrues; it refreshes with each data update.
All St. James City communities (17)
Bayview AcresBayview Acres in St James City, FL: Median sale $664K (2026), 91 homes, built 1959-2022, median 45 days on market.Buccaneer InnBuccaneer Inn Condo in St James City, FL: ZIP 33956 median $490K, 78 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Cherry EstatesCherry Estates in St James City, FL: Median sale $340K (2026), 191 homes, built 1971-2024, median 16 days on market.Fishermans WharfFishermans Wharf Condo in St James City, FL: 4 homes for sale from $276K to $340K, ~1,053 sq ft typical. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public…Flamingo BayFlamingo Bay in St James City, FL: Median sale $115K (2026), 264 homes, built 1952-2024, median 334 days on market.Galt Island ShoresGalt Island Shores in St James City, FL: Median sale $750K (2026), median 220 days on market. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.Gulf Shores EstatesGulf Shores Estates in St James City, FL: 2 homes for sale from $344K to $579K. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.GulfhavenGulfhaven in St James City, FL: Median sale $406K (2026), median 102 days on market. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.Island AcresIsland Acres in St James City, FL: 1 home for sale from $549K. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.Palm Tree HarborsPalm Tree Harbors in St James City, FL: ZIP 33956 median $490K, 78 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Pine Island CovePine Island Cove in St James City, FL: Median sale $136K (2026), 118 homes, built 1980-2024, median 97 days on market.Pine Island ShoresPine Island Shores in St James City, FL: Median sale $655K (2026), 26 homes, built 1985-2023, median 117 days on market.Pine Island Tropical HomesitesPine Island Tropical Homesites in St James City, FL: 30 homes, built 1952-2019. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.Pine Island VillagePine Island Village in St James City, FL: 28 homes, built 1979-2024. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.St James CitySt James City in St James City, FL: Median sale $582K (2026), 21 homes, built 1965-2006, median 160 days on market.St Jude HarborsSt Jude Harbors in St James City, FL: 51 homes, built 1971-2024. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public records.TrailerhavenTrailerhaven in St James City, FL: 3 homes for sale from $300K to $380K, 1 pending, ~960 sq ft typical. Live Florida Gulf Coast MLS data and public…