What $400K Buys in St. Johns County, FL

A $400K budget buys a very different house depending on which St. Johns County city you point it at. This page compares every city with at least five active listings within 10% of $400K — size, age, bed and bath count, price per square foot, how much of the inventory is new construction and how long it has been sitting — from today’s live MLS actives, and lists the communities with the most homes at that price. It refreshes every night.

There are 281 homes for sale in St. Johns County, FL priced between $360,000 and $440,000 right now. At $400K, the typical home is 1,782 sq ft, built 2021, at $228/sq ft; 28% of them are new construction and the median has been on the market 58 days. The most house for the money is in Elkton (2,089 sq ft median); the least in Ponte Vedra Beach (1,149 sq ft); the newest in Hastings (median build year 2026).

What $400K buys, city by city

CityHomes for saleMedian sq ftBeds / bathsMedian year built$ / sq ftNew constructionMedian DOM
St. Augustine1971,7963 / 22021$22123%54
St. Johns331,7103 / 22024$24642%58
Ponte Vedra281,5833 / 2.52025$26054%123
Ponte Vedra Beach61,1492 / 21984$3720%68
Hastings51,7744 / 22026$210100%23
Elkton52,0893 / 22006$2070%48

By ZIP code: where $400K goes furthest

The same budget by ZIP — useful where one city covers most of the county.

ZIPHomes for saleMedian sq ftMedian year built$ / sq ftNew construction
32092 St. Augustine861,8972025$21348%
32084 St. Augustine581,7972019$2162%
32259 St. Johns341,7312024$24538%
32081 Ponte Vedra281,5832025$26054%
32086 St. Augustine271,6992000$2314%
32095 St. Augustine161,7922022$21719%
32080 St. Augustine161,0501975$3730%
32082 Ponte Vedra Beach61,1491984$3720%
32145 Hastings51,7742026$210100%
32033 Elkton52,0892006$2070%

Communities with the most homes near $400K

CommunityCityHomes for sale near $400KMedian sq ftMedian year built
Woodland Park At NocateePonte Vedra141,5322026
Reverie At TrailmarkSt. Augustine121,7942026
SilverLeafSt. Augustine111,9262027
EntradaST AUGUSTINE111,9862022
St Augustine SouthSt. Augustine101,5451980
TrailmarkST AUGUSTINE92,0482023
San SalitoSt. Augustine91,8032018
Brook ForestJacksonville71,4542026
Del WebbPonte Vedra71,8152018
Watersong At RivertownSt. Johns71,7312026
RiverTownSt. Johns51,6012026
StillwaterSt. Johns51,8912022
Reverie At SilverleafST AUGUSTINE51,7092027
Morgans CoveSt. Augustine51,7962022
StonecrestSt. Johns51,5032024

How to read this

Counts and medians are computed from active MLS listings priced within 10% of $400K ($360,000–$440,000) as of November 15, 2026; property mix at this price: Single-family 70%, Townhouse 20%, Condo 9%. Cities with fewer than five listings in the band are folded out of the city table but still count in the county total. Prices are asking prices, not closings — see the county page for sale-to-list ratios. Source: live MLS feeds compiled by Momentum Research. Other budgets in St. Johns County: $300K, $500K, $750K, $1M. Back to homes for sale in St. Johns County, FL.

Hiring an agent in St. Johns County, FL?

Get matched with the right local expert.

Tell us your goal in St. Johns County, FL and we’ll connect you with the Momentum agent who knows it best — backed by a RealTrends 500 brokerage. No pressure, no obligation.

Prefer to talk now? Call (904) 351-6461.

Work with a local St. Johns County, FL expert

A real conversation with a local specialist, usually within one business day.

or call (904) 351-6461

Common questions

What does $400K buy in St. Johns County, FL?

Across 281 active listings within 10% of $400K, the median home is 1,782 sq ft and was built in 2021, at about $228 per square foot. Elkton gives the most space at that price (2,089 sq ft median); Ponte Vedra Beach the least.

Which St. Johns County city has the newest homes around $400K?

Hastings, where the median listing near $400K was built in 2026 and 100% of them are new construction.

How much new construction is there at $400K in St. Johns County?

About 28% of the 281 homes listed near $400K are new construction. The highest builder share is in Hastings (100%), Ponte Vedra (54%), St. Johns (42%).