How to Find the Best Real Estate Agent in Fleming Island, FL

Searching for the best real estate agent in Fleming Island, FL — or a top Realtor or listing agent? You’re making a hiring decision. Here’s what makes a great Fleming Island, FL agent, the questions to ask, the current market, and how to reach a proven local expert across 12 Fleming Island, FL communities.

Fleming Island, FL market at a glance

From Momentum’s MLS data for Fleming Island communities, current as of September 12, 2026:

What this market means when you hire an agent

Homes here are selling at 97% of asking after about 28 days on market. That points to a healthy market right now. Neither side has a clear edge, so execution decides the outcome: ask how the agent prices to the current comps, what their marketing reaches beyond the MLS, and how they negotiate inspections and appraisal gaps.

Dig deeper: Fleming Island housing market tracker · homes for sale in Fleming Island.

80 Momentum Realty agents who work Fleming Island

Listed with the neighborhoods each one covers (self-reported), years licensed and a direct line. Pick by area and transaction type, or use the form and a broker matches you.

• 
  Justin Timmons

  21 years licensed · SFR

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 472-4359
• 
  Luke Morris

  20 years licensed · ePRO

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (813) 545-5550
• 
  Carolina Salcedo

  14 years licensed

  Real estate investors

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 270-9596
• 
  Alex Watson

  13 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Historic / pre-1980 homes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 608-1977
• 
  Amber Hysler

  13 years licensed · MRP, Other

  Condos / townhomes, New construction, Equestrian / large acreage, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island, Middleburg, Westside Jacksonville

  (904) 982-2726
• 
  Beatrice Bredeson

  13 years licensed · CRS, CLHMS, MRP, Other

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Mandarin, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island

  (847) 648-0626
• 
  Luis Perez Roman

  13 years licensed · CSSE (Certified Short Sale Expert)

  Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Jacksonville, Duval County, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach

  (904) 708-6502
• 
  Heather Strazinsky

  12 years licensed · MRP, PSA, SFR

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 598-4656
• 
  Tiffany Riley

  11 years licensed · ABR, Other

  Luxury, Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach

  (904) 200-9755
• 
  Amanda Kinard

  9 years licensed · MRP

  Luxury, New construction, Land / acreage, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 650-5297
• 
  Stephani Barnes

  9 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, 55+ communities, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (325) 733-8048
• 
  Adam Collins

  8 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 449-1928
• 
  Chris Moore

  8 years licensed

  Distressed properties, Probate / inherited homes, Fix-and-flip, Historic / pre-1980 homes, Multi-family, Real

  Serves: Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island, Middleburg, Southside Jacksonville, Arlington

  (904) 662-0133
• 
  Danielle Rodriguez

  8 years licensed · MRP, SFR

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (908) 447-1971
• 
  Brooke Hewitt - Jax Listing Sisters

  7 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 252-7390
• 
  Corey Miller

  6 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Historic homes, Multi-family, Golf communities, Generalist

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 699-2424
• 
  Tammy Baranowski at Jax Listing Sisters

  6 years licensed

  Serves: Clay County, Duval County, St. Johns County, Nassau County, Baker County

  (904) 708-0468
• 
  Savannah Ellison

  5 years licensed

  Luxury, Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Mandarin, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, St. Augustine, World Golf Village

  (904) 501-6107
• 
  Jax Listing Sisters (Tammy Baranowski & Brooke Hewitt)

  (904) 708-0468
• 
  Kirk Killebrew

  26 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Multi-family, First-time buyers

  Serves: Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee

  (904) 463-1131
• 
  Daniel Stephenson

  25 years licensed

  Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (414) 736-6371
• 
  Hameed Siddiq

  25 years licensed · GRI,SFR,BPOR

  Generalist · 25+ years · Investment · International · 1031s

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 962-3187
• 
  Mike Pisacreta

  25 years licensed · ABR, SRS, CLHMS, MRP, SRES, ePRO, SFR

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 528-7372
• 
  Jeannine Koski

  23 years licensed · MRP

  Luxury, Waterfront, Condos / Townhomes, New Construction, First-Time Buyers, Relocation, Military / VA

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (407) 697-8899
• 
  Janette Sterner

  20 years licensed

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island

  (904) 752-2020
• 
  Lisa Taylor

  20 years licensed

  Waterfront / ocean / river, I am a generalist, First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 673-6637
• 
  Amy Williams

  19 years licensed

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 424-0113
• 
  Jill Powers

  19 years licensed

  New construction, Waterfront, Land, Multi-family, First-time buyers

  Serves: St. Augustine, World Golf Village, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island, Middleburg

  (386) 916-4077
• 
  Timothy Newman

  13 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 755-0307
• 
  Alex Norkus

  12 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront, Condos / Townhomes, New Construction, First-Time Buyers, Relocation, Military / VA

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 894-5525
• 
  Christine Chavis

  12 years licensed · ABR, SRS, MRP, SFR

  Military relocation, New construction, Short sales, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 955-3789
• 
  Lauren Gordon

  12 years licensed · Other

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach

  (904) 524-3093
• 
  Debra Pappas

  11 years licensed

  Luxury, New construction, Multi-family, First-time buyers

  Serves: Clay County- Orange Park, Fleming Island, Middleburg, Westside Jacksonville, St. Augustine

  (904) 608-7232
• 
  Jamie Wilkerson

  11 years licensed · MRP

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Amelia Island / Fernandina, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island, Middleburg, Yulee

  (904) 655-9799
• 
  Beth McElhinny

  10 years licensed

  Condos / townhomes, Historic / pre-1980 homes, Multi-family, Real estate investors

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 652-4099
• 
  Danielle Jarman

  10 years licensed · ABR, CLHMS, MRP, SRES, PSA, C2EX, CNE (Certified Negotiation Expert)

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, St. Augustine

  (904) 673-4177
• 
  Jay Wike

  10 years licensed · SFR

  First-time buyers, Relocation, Military / VA, 55+ buyers, Real estate investors

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 219-8331
• 
  Argen Mustafa

  9 years licensed

  Luxury, New construction, Golf course communities, First-time buyers

  Serves: Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Neptune Beach, Orange Park / Clay County, Fleming Island

  (904) 422-9975
• 
  Danny Fontaine

  9 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, New construction, First-time buyers, Relocation, Military / VA loan

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 476-1523
• 
  Lindsey Parham

  9 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Palatka, East Palatka, Hastins, St, Augustine

  (386) 530-1737
• 
  Susan Timmons

  9 years licensed

  First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee

  (904) 669-1474
• 
  Tim Sherman

  9 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach

  (443) 223-6773
• 
  Brittany Garner

  8 years licensed · MRP

  Serves: Clay, St. Johns, Duval, Baker, and Nassau

  (904) 505-7788
• 
  Christina Wedderburn

  8 years licensed · ABR, SRS, MRP, PSA, RENE, SFR, Other

  Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers, Relocation

  Serves: Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, St. Augustine

  (904) 334-2259
• 
  Evelyn Vergara

  8 years licensed

  Luxury, Condos / townhomes, New construction, First-time buyers

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (413) 271-0785
• 
  Jayna Belardo

  8 years licensed · ABR, MRP, AHWD

  Generalist, First-Time Buyers, Relocation, Military / VA

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (732) 278-5602
• 
  Juanita Vasquez

  8 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront, Condos / Townhomes, New Construction, First-Time Buyers, Relocation, Military / VA

  Serves: Riverside / Avondale, San Marco, Mandarin, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach

  (904) 432-5485
• 
  Alexis Short

  7 years licensed

  Luxury, Waterfront / ocean / river, Condos / townhomes, First-time buyers

  Serves: Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee

  (904) 466-1447

More Momentum agents serving Fleming Island: Danielle Bennett, Jessica Crittenden, Lynn Pace, Julius Young Sr., Abe Hamidy, Alicia Slater, Andrew Griffith, Melissa Lampugnano, Paris Herbin, GRI, Pier Coutoune, India Green, Joey McAlister-Kiser, Norm Rodriguez, Phillip Morency, Rachel Mcneal, Sandy Swanson, Sarah Johnson, Gavin Miller, Kady Andreoli, Matthew Braddy, Sarah Luther, Dj Ferreira, Nicole Dacuyan, Cory DeRoin, Daniela Acosta, Gregory Grant, Holly Barry, Brandon Locke, Crawford Timbs, Daniel Judycki, Jennifer Pledger, Noah Tomlinson.

Agents by city: Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, Ponte Vedra Beach, St. Augustine, St. Johns, Orange Park, Middleburg, Green Cove Springs, Yulee, Fernandina Beach, Gainesville, Ocala, Palm Coast, Palatka, Tampa · all Florida agents · full directory.

What makes a great real estate agent in Fleming Island, FL

The best Fleming Island, FL agents share four things: real local sales experience, pricing accuracy from true comps, marketing that reaches the right buyers, and negotiation that protects your money. For sellers, a top listing agent’s marketing wins top dollar; for buyers, a strong buyer’s agent protects you. The difference is local depth — an agent who truly knows Fleming Island, FL, not just the region.

Questions to ask before you hire a Fleming Island, FL agent

• How many homes have you sold in Fleming Island, FL in the last year?
• How will you price my home or help me bid, and what comps are you using?
• What’s your marketing plan, and where will my home show up?
• How do you handle negotiations, inspections, and appraisal gaps?
• How and how often will you communicate?
• Can you share recent references?

The long-form versions, with the answer a good agent gives and the one that should worry you: questions to ask a realtor when selling your house and the full buyer and seller checklist.

Best agents by community in Fleming Island, FL

• Best agent in Eagle Harbor
• Best agent in Fleming Island
• Best agent in Pace Island
• Best agent in Lake Ridge Villas North
• Best agent in Autumn Glen
• Best agent in Harbor Island
• Best agent in Fleming Oaks
• Best agent in Island Forest
• Best agent in Margaret's Walk
• Best agent in Creighton Pointe
• Best agent in Hibernia Plantation
• Best agent in Lake Ridge North

Meet your local expert

Your local expert

Brittany Brooks — Co-Founder, Momentum Realty

Brittany co-founded Momentum Realty, a RealTrends 500 brokerage (ranked #440 in the U.S.) with 320+ agents and $3.5B+ in closed sales across Florida. Tell her what you’re looking for and she’ll connect you with the right local Momentum specialist — and make sure you’re taken care of from first call to closing.

★★★★★ 5.0 · 12 reviews on Zillow

“If we could give Brittany and Jon Brooks a ten-star review we would. This couple is amazing at what they do.” — Jake S., Zillow
“I have now worked with Brittany and the Brooks Group / Momentum Realty to both buy and sell a property over the past 3 years. I had an outstanding experience.” — A. Lloyd, Zillow

Talk to Brittany →

Common questions

Market figures are aggregates from Momentum Realty’s MLS data for Fleming Island, FL, as of 2026-09-12, and change over time. General guidance on choosing an agent, not a ranking or endorsement of any individual. Equal Housing Opportunity.