Belle Haven
Homes for Sale in St. Augustine, FL

Belle Haven market snapshot (as of July 11, 2026): the median sale price is about $244K ($192 per sq ft over the trailing 12 months of closed sales), and a median 31 days on market for closed sales.

Belle Haven is a modestly priced pocket of St. Augustine where the per-foot figure does more to explain value than square footage does — meaning what you're buying, and its condition, matters more here than the headline price alone.

A $244,000 median paired with roughly $192 per square foot tells you these are not sprawling homes; the price is being set by smaller footprints where each foot counts. In practice that pushes the spread wide on either side of the median — a well-updated home and a dated one at the same square footage will not trade for the same money. Expect condition to drive the negotiation more than any comparable-sales shortcut.

The 31-day median suggests a market that clears but doesn't rush. That's a healthier posture for a buyer than a hot one: you can see it, inspect it, and make a considered offer. For a seller, it means the home needs to be presented honestly and priced to its actual condition, because buyers here have the time to notice the difference.

When a market is driven by per-foot value and home condition rather than a tidy price range, comp interpretation is everything. We work Belle Haven listing by listing, judging each home on its updates and layout rather than the median alone — and we'll tell you plainly when a given asking price isn't supported by what's actually behind the door.