Cutler Bay neighborhoods with the market data that actually moves a decision.
73 Cutler Bay community guides, each with real pricing, HOA/CDD reality, and flood/insurance posture. Below: the Cutler Bay market snapshot, then every community we cover.
Cutler Bay market snapshot
$601,000Median sale price
$341.3Median $/sq ft
40Median days on market
+4.7%Year over year
+165.9%10-yr appreciation
485Communities with sales data
Median sale price by year
Aggregated from MLS closed-sale records across 485 Cutler Bay communities; latest data 2026. Aggregate statistics only, deemed reliable but not guaranteed; not an appraisal. Refreshes with each MLS data update.
All Cutler Bay communities (73)
Aurora ParkAurora Park in Cutler Bay, FL: 20 homes built 1976–1980, ~1,511 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale.Bel AireBel Aire in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $682K (2026), median 44 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Benson ManorBenson Manor in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $550K (2025), $508/sq ft, 96 sales since 2012. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Black Creek VillasBlack Creek Villas in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $338K (2026), median 48 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.C B PalmsC B Palms in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $625K (2026), median 14 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.CantamarCantamar in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $748K (2026), median 38 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.CapistranoCapistrano in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $964K (2026), median 106 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.CentennialCentennial in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $565K (2026), median 55 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Century at Cutler BayCentury at Cutler Bay in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Century StarCentury Star in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $745K (2026), median 28 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Costa BravaCosta Brava in Cutler Bay, FL: 14 homes built 1999–2018, ~2,319 sq ft, 4 bd/3.5 ba. ZIP 33139 median $790K, 497 for sale.Cove CondoCove Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $265K (2026), median 35 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler CayCutler Cay in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $1.10M (2026), median 59 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler Country GrovesCutler Country Groves in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $1.50M (2023), $462/sq ft, 32 sales since 2012. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler Country Groves PlaCutler Country Groves Pla in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $1.13M (2026), median 98 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler Creek ClubCutler Creek Club in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $468K (2026), median 18 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler Creek VillageCutler Creek Village Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33190 median $535K, 79 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Cutler LakesCutler Lakes Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: 7 homes built 2005–2007, ~1,060 sq ft, 2 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale.Cutler RidgeCutler Ridge is a master-planned community in Cutler Bay, FL recorded as 3 villages and sections in the MLS: 24 homes for sale or pending across them…Cutler Ridge Manor EstateCutler Ridge Manor Estate in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $625K (2026), median 22 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Cutler Ridge PinesCutler Ridge Pines in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $610K (2026), median 40 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Eureka Drive EstatesEureka Drive Estates in Cutler Bay, FL: 20 homes built 1961–1969, ~2,430 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Herfa SubHerfa Sub in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $560K (2026), median 25 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Holiday HouseHoliday House in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $668K (2026), median 83 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the BayLakes by the Bay in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $535K (2026), median 56 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay AmberLakes by the Bay Amber in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $640K (2024), $284/sq ft, 61 sales since 2012. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay CeeLakes by the Bay Cee in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $415K (2026), median 13 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay DayLakes by the Bay Day in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $605K (2026), median 33 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay Eve ReplLakes by the Bay Eve Repl in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $385K (2026), median 31 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay Faye ReplLakes by the Bay Faye Repl in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Lakes by the Bay GeeLakes by the Bay Gee in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $410K (2026), median 75 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay JayLakes by the Bay Jay in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $402K (2026), median 58 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Lakes by the Bay KayeLakes by the Bay Kaye in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $582K (2026), median 85 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Le Club at Old Cutler ConLe Club at Old Cutler Con in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $240K (2026), median 37 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Mark Manor PinesMark Manor Pines in Cutler Bay, FL: 36 homes built 1971–2000, ~1,723 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Old Cutler CoveOld Cutler Cove in Cutler Bay, FL: 70 homes built 1973–2019, ~1,803 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Old Cutler CoveOld Cutler Cove in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $669K (2026), median 22 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Old Cutler EstatesOld Cutler Estates in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $1.55M (2026), median 34 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Old Cutler GroveOld Cutler Grove in Cutler Bay, FL: 25 homes built 1973–2006, ~2,744 sq ft, 4 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Omni EstatesOmni Estates in Cutler Bay, FL: 30 homes built 1963–1980, ~2,722 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Paradise PointeParadise Pointe Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $195K (2026), median 61 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Pelican Bay at Old CutlerPelican Bay at Old Cutler in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $622K (2026), median 31 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Perrine GrantPerrine Grant in Cutler Bay, FL: 8 homes built 1952–2016, ~3,330 sq ft, 5 bd/3.5 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Pine Tree ManorPine Tree Manor in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $585K (2026), median 49 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Point RoyalePoint Royale Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: 9 homes built 1974–1976, ~1,215 sq ft, 3 bd/1.5 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Point Royale Buildings NiPoint Royale Buildings Ni in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Point Royale Buildings onPoint Royale Buildings on in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Precious Homes at Lakes BPrecious Homes at Lakes B in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $525K (2025), $346/sq ft, 71 sales since 2012. Live MIAMI MLS data and public…Ridgeview Gardens Condo #Ridgeview Gardens Condo # in Cutler Bay, FL: 6 homes built 1983–1988, ~903 sq ft, 2 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Rl Old CutlerRl Old Cutler in Cutler Bay, FL: 20 homes built 2006–2013, ~3,222 sq ft, 5 bd/4 ba. ZIP 33156 median $1.10M, 190 for sale.Rosewood HomesRosewood Homes in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Royale Point-Townvillas CRoyale Point-Townvillas C in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $338K (2024), $307/sq ft, 14 sales since 2018. Live MIAMI MLS data and public…S Coral HomesS Coral Homes in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $568K (2026), median 70 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Saga BaySaga Bay in Cutler Bay, FL: 401 homes built 1972–2023, ~2,139 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…Saga Bay GardensSaga Bay Gardens Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $190K (2026), median 86 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Saga Bay TownhomesSaga Bay Townhomes in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $420K (2025), $246/sq ft, 52 sales since 2013. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Saga Bay Townhomes 1st AdSaga Bay Townhomes 1st Ad in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $409K (2026), median 70 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Santa BarbaraSanta Barbara in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $415K (2026), median 30 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Sea Grape Town HomesSea Grape Town Homes in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $520K (2025), $238/sq ft, 43 sales since 2012. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Section Nineteen Bel AireSection Nineteen Bel Aire in Cutler Bay, FL: 10 homes built 1972–2020, ~1,656 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33157 median $610K, 193 for sale.Silver PinesSilver Pines in Cutler Bay, FL: 12 homes built 1991–2023, ~2,367 sq ft, 4 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale.So Miami HeightsSo Miami Heights in Cutler Bay, FL: 54 homes built 1962–1983, ~1,815 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale.South Coral HomesSouth Coral Homes in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $595K (2026), median 34 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.The Courts at BayshoreThe Courts at Bayshore in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $299K (2026), median 90 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.The Courts at Bayshore I CThe Courts at Bayshore I C in Cutler Bay, FL: 5 homes built 2007–2017, ~1,383 sq ft, 3 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 33190 median $535K, 79 for sale.The RidgesThe Ridges in Cutler Bay, FL: ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.The ShoresThe Shores Condo in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $350K (2026), median 95 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Trellis at BayshoreTrellis at Bayshore in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $505K (2026), median 58 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Villas at Cutler Bay CondVillas at Cutler Bay Cond in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $178K (2024), $181/sq ft, 25 sales since 2017. Live MIAMI MLS data and public…Villas of Old CutlerVillas of Old Cutler in Cutler Bay, FL: 26 homes built 1991–1998, ~2,285 sq ft, 4 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale.Whispering Pines EstatesWhispering Pines Estates in Cutler Bay, FL: Median sale $700K (2026), median 64 days on market. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.Whispering Pines ParkWhispering Pines Park in Cutler Bay, FL: Recent sales median $605K (2025), $433/sq ft, 19 sales since 2014. Live MIAMI MLS data and public records.ZenithsZeniths in Cutler Bay, FL: 7 homes built 1959–2020, ~1,272 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 33189 median $575K, 117 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…