Umatilla neighborhoods with the market data that actually moves a decision.
74 Umatilla community guides, each with real pricing, HOA/CDD reality, and flood/insurance posture. Below: the Umatilla market snapshot, then every community we cover.
Umatilla market snapshot
$303,365Median sale price
$186.2Median $/sq ft
57Median days on market
-8.6%Year over year
+277.5%10-yr appreciation
92Communities with sales data
Median sale price by year
Aggregated from MLS closed-sale records across 92 Umatilla communities; latest data 2026. Aggregate statistics only, deemed reliable but not guaranteed; not an appraisal. Refreshes with each MLS data update.
All Umatilla communities (74)
Anna D GuerrantAnna D Guerrant in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1920–2024, ~1,869 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Babb EstatesBabb Estates in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.BrennandBrennand in Umatilla, FL: a single-family community, 4,283 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract).Bryn Mawr On LakeBryn Mawr On Lake in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Clear CrestClear Crest in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1973–2020, ~1,273 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…Crest HavenCrest Haven in Umatilla, FL: 8 homes built 1959–2024, ~2,003 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…Crooked Oak EstatesCrooked Oak Estates in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Donna VistaDonna Vista in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Dream Lake Poultry RanchesDream Lake Poultry Ranches in Umatilla, FL: 8 homes built 1979–2019, ~2,039 sq ft, 4 bd/3 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.East UmatillaEast Umatilla in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $330K (2026), 80 homes, built 1915-2024, median 48 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public…Eus-UmaEus-Uma in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Eustis ParkEustis Park in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $147K (2025), $133/sq ft, 18 sales since 2014. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Gateway Commerce CenterGateway Commerce Center in Umatilla, FL: 17 homes, built 2021-2023. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Gibson & GothermansGibson & Gothermans in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32702 median $515K, 3 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Given'SGiven'S in Umatilla, FL: 4,268 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract). Live Stellar MLS data and public records.GlendaleGlendale in Umatilla, FL: 27 homes, built 1920-2023. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Hi Land CourtHi Land Court in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Hidden OaksHidden Oaks in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $290K (2024), $150/sq ft, 10 sales since 2005. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Lake Cooley EstatesLake Cooley Estates in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Lake Dalhousie EstatesLake Dalhousie Estates in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $908K (2025), $215/sq ft, 34 sales since 2004. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Lake Murphy EstatesLake Murphy Estates in Umatilla, FL: 10 homes built 1978–2026, ~2,616 sq ft, 4 bd/3 ba. ZIP 32736 median $502K, 25 for sale.Lake Smith EstatesLake Smith Estates in Umatilla, FL: 8 homes built 1997–2005, ~1,800 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.LakenridgeLakenridge in Umatilla, FL: 16 homes built 1955–2008, ~1,784 sq ft, 3 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…Lee AcresLee Acres in Umatilla, FL: 10 homes built 1974–2022, ~2,046 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…LynnwoodLynnwood in Umatilla, FL: 30 homes, built 1950-1986. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Magnolia PointMagnolia Point in Umatilla, FL: 9 homes built 1999–2025, ~1,954 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Magnolia PointeMagnolia Pointe in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $314K (2026), median 78 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Merrill-VaughnMerrill-Vaughn in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.MitchenorsMitchenors in Umatilla, FL: 10 homes built 1910–2022, ~2,283 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…N J TrowellsN J Trowells in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.North UmatillaNorth Umatilla in Umatilla, FL: 33 homes built 1925–2025, ~1,320 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Peggys CovePeggys Cove in Umatilla, FL: a single-family community, 4,283 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract). Live Stellar MLS data and public…Seasons At Magnolia PointeSeasons At Magnolia Pointe in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $348K (2026), 24 homes, built 2024-2024, median 205 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and…Shorelin RanchShorelin Ranch in Umatilla, FL: 4,268 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract). Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Shoreline RanchShoreline Ranch in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Silver Beach HeightsSilver Beach Heights in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $442K (2025), $180/sq ft, 43 sales since 2004, 95 homes, built 1946-2020. Live Stellar MLS…Silver Beach HightsSilver Beach Hights in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Smiths Carrie ESmiths Carrie E in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Smiths W WSmiths W W in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Tarpon DevelopmentTarpon Development in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $354K (2025), $215/sq ft, 5 sales since 2024. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Thomas & CoxThomas & Cox in Umatilla, FL: 94 homes for sale in ZIP 32784 (22% under contract), 9 MLS sales on record since 2005.Thomas CoxThomas Cox in Umatilla, FL: 7 homes built 1910–2025, ~1,120 sq ft, 3 bd/1.5 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes…Three LakesThree Lakes in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $292K (2025), $184/sq ft, 35 sales since 2014, 114 homes, built 1920-2021.Twin Lake EstatesTwin Lake Estates in Umatilla, FL: 19 homes built 2001–2026, ~1,529 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Twin Lakes EstatesTwin Lakes Estates in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $374K (2026), median 34 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.UmatillaUmatilla in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $385K (2024), $234/sq ft, 24 sales since 2005. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Bryn Mawr On LakeUmatilla Bryn Mawr On Lake in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1999–2022, ~1,800 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla Buena VistaUmatilla Buena Vista in Umatilla, FL: 94 homes for sale in ZIP 32784 (22% under contract), 1 MLS sale on record since 2026.Umatilla Cottages at Waters EdgeUmatilla Cottages at Waters Edge in Umatilla, FL: 11 homes built 2007–2018, ~1,211 sq ft, 2 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla De VaultsUmatilla De Vaults in Umatilla, FL: 5 homes built 1881–1922, ~2,090 sq ft, 4 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla Grove ParkUmatilla Grove Park in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1982–1986, ~1,053 sq ft, 3 bd/1.5 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla Kristin TerraceUmatilla Kristin Terrace in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla Lake Mary EstatesUmatilla Lake Mary Estates in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $230K (2026), median 34 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Lake Region Realty CoUmatilla Lake Region Realty Co in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $275K (2025), $195/sq ft, 5 sales since 2017. Live Stellar MLS data and public…Umatilla MitchenorsUmatilla Mitchenors in Umatilla, FL: 20 homes built 1900–2022, ~1,544 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla NorthUmatilla North in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $219K (2026), median 58 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Oak ParkUmatilla Oak Park in Umatilla, FL: Recent sales median $299K (2025), $188/sq ft, 13 sales since 2016. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Orange CourtUmatilla Orange Court in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla Osceola ParkUmatilla Osceola Park in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $215K (2026), median 33 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Palm CourtUmatilla Palm Court in Umatilla, FL: Median sale $246K (2026), median 41 days on market. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla SinksUmatilla Sinks in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla Smith TurnerUmatilla Smith Turner in Umatilla, FL: 5 homes built 1984–1988, ~1,804 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla Smiths A JUmatilla Smiths A J in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla Swiss BellevueUmatilla Swiss Bellevue in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla Turpentine CosUmatilla Turpentine Cos in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1935–2007, ~1,254 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla Twin Lake EstatesUmatilla Twin Lake Estates in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla VaughnUmatilla Vaughn in Umatilla, FL: 4,268 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract). Live Stellar MLS data and public records.Umatilla Veterans VillageUmatilla Veterans Village in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla WhitcombsUmatilla Whitcombs in Umatilla, FL: 5 homes built 1964–2009, ~2,324 sq ft, 4 bd/3 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.Umatilla WhitleyUmatilla Whitley in Umatilla, FL: ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for sale.Umatilla YanceysUmatilla Yanceys in Umatilla, FL: 6 homes built 1900–1957, ~1,711 sq ft, 4 bd/2.5 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale.WhidbysWhidbys in Umatilla, FL: 7 homes built 1966–2024, ~1,259 sq ft, 3 bd/2 ba. ZIP 32784 median $247K, 15 for sale. Schools, HOA & nearby homes for…WhitcombsWhitcombs in Umatilla, FL: a single-family community, 4,283 homes for sale in Lake County (26% under contract).XX in Umatilla, FL: 98 homes for sale in ZIP 32736 (29% under contract), 10 MLS sales on record since 2005. Live Stellar MLS data and public records.